Best Pizza in Bergen County NJ (Updated Jan 2023)

From thin-crust to thick-crust, and everything in between, I’ve tested 11 pizzerias in Bergen County to determine which one has the best pie. Traveling all over the world has given me an understanding of how pizza is made from region to region. I like to think that my experience gives me a unique perspective when I’m evaluating different pizzas for taste and quality.

I’m ready to break down what makes each of these places stand out, so you can find your favorite spot to get your pizza fix – with a bit of humor and lightheartedness along the way!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Pizza Side

The atmosphere at Pizza Side is second to none. The place has a cozy and inviting feel, with friendly staff members that make you feel right at home.

And the pizza?! Wow! It surpasses any pizza I’ve had before (even in Italy). The crust is light and crisp, the sauce so flavorful…it’s like heaven in your mouth. Topping options are abundant, with traditional favorites as well as some creative surprises – nothing is off limits here!

I particularly enjoyed their creative topping combinations (shrimp and mango was surprisingly tasty!). And don’t even get me started on those garlic knots! Perfectly cooked and covered in herbs and spices – they’re delicious.

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Bergen County NJ, look no further than Pizza Side – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Secaucus!

#2 Blaze Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was delightful, with friendly and efficient staff who were always happy to answer any questions. The open kitchen layout allowed me to watch the preparation of the pizzas and made me feel like I was part of the process.

The pizza dough was perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside yet still soft and fluffy on the inside. The toppings selection was impressive, with a range of seasonal fresh ingredients that allowed me to choose exactly which flavors I wanted. My favorite combination is prosciutto, artichokes, mushrooms, and ricotta cheese – so flavorful!

One thing that really sets Blaze Pizza apart from others is their commitment to quality. Not only did they use locally sourced ingredients like organic tomatoes, but their packaging was also sustainable, with minimal plastic waste. This made me feel good about enjoying their delicious creations!

Overall, Blaze Pizza had some of the best pizza in Bergen County NJ and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience!

#3 Napoli Wood Fired Pizza & Bakery

On my recent trip, I stopped by Napoli expecting a good slice, but came away awe-struck at the amazing flavors and textures found in the pizza. The wood-fired oven fills the air with aromas that make it impossible to walk past without wanting to jump in and join the party. I opted for a classic margherita and couldn’t believe how much flavor was packed into each bite. The tangy tomatoes combined with the herbaceous basil leaves complemented by gooey, melted cheese on top of a crispy crust made this one of my favorite pizza experiences yet!

The service at Napoli was also top notch. The staff was friendly and welcoming, taking the time to chat with me about their unique pizza making process. They even went out of their way to let me sample some of their recently cooked pies. I’d recommend stopping by Napoli for anyone looking for an exceptional pizza experience – trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Corleone’s Pizzeria

I visited the restaurant on a Thursday night and was immediately impressed with their service. The staff was friendly and welcoming and they even offered to recommend menu items based on my taste preferences.

The pizza at Corleone’s is truly amazing. Their secret sauce is one of the best I’ve ever had, especially when paired with their perfectly cooked crust. They have some great topping combinations as well! My favorite has to be their classic Margherita pizza – it’s nothing short of perfection!

In addition to the pizza, Corleone’s offers a variety of additional Italian dishes as well. From lasagna to meatball subs, there is something for everyone. The prices are competitive and definitely worth the cost for the quality you get in return.

Overall, I highly recommend Corleone’s Pizzeria for those seeking out great pizza in Bergen County NJ. From the tasty pies to the friendly service, it’s an experience that should not be missed!

#5 Urban Tomato

When I walked into Urban Tomato, I could immediately tell that I was in for a treat. The countertops were lined with fresh tomatoes and the kitchen staff were hard at work rolling out dough. The aroma of herbs and spices filled the room, instantly making my stomach grumble.

I decided to try their classic cheese pizza and it did not disappoint! It had a crispy crust made from freshly made dough that was perfectly cooked. Topped with melty mozzarella cheese, homemade tomato sauce, and just the right amount of herbs and spices, it was evening better than I could have imagined. The flavors married together so well they should get a marriage license!

I am always up for trying something new so I also opted to try their stuffed deep dish pizza. As expected, it was an absolute knockout! Stuffed with cheesy goodness and topped with sausage, peppers, onions and mushrooms; this pizza certainly blew me away.

Urban Tomato is certainly the best pizza in Bergen County NJ and judging by the crowd in the restaurant tonight I can tell they are doing something right! If you’re ever looking for delicious pizza in this area make sure you stop by Urban Tomato—you won’t be disappointed!

#6 John’s Boy Pizzeria

I’m not one for the traditional chain pizzas but John’s has something special about it. The crust is crispy, yet soft, and you can definitely taste the quality of the ingredients. Plus, their sauce is a nice balance of sweet and savory.

The toppings were great, too – especially the prosciutto! It melted in my mouth with every bite. They also have a really unique selection of gourmet pizzas like the Grilled Eggplant Parmigiana pizza that was to die for – I highly recommend it!

The best part, though, was the service. Everyone at John’s Boy Pizzeria was friendly and welcoming, even when I ordered 14 different pizzas for my group! They even gave us some free garlic knots which were absolutely delicious as well.

If you’re ever in Bergen County NJ and looking for some great pizza – head over to John’s Boy Pizzeria! You won’t regret it!

#7 Trattoria La Sorrentina

I’ve been to Rome, Florence, and Venice and sampled their famous pies, but nothing compares to the deliciousness I experienced at Trattoria La Sorrentina. In fact, if you’re looking for an authentic Italian pizza experience on par with the regional pizza fares of Italy, look no further!

The pizzas here are made from scratch with fresh ingredients that are sourced locally whenever possible. The dough is light and fluffy and the sauce is packed full of flavour – it’s a perfect combination that creates a truly scrumptious pie. Plus, they offer a variety of toppings to choose from so you can customize your pizza however you’d like.

Service wise, the staff here are friendly and helpful which I really appreciated as a food critic. They took the time to explain what all the different ingredients were, so even as someone who is not familiar with Italian cuisine could understand what they were eating.

If you’re in Bergen County NJ looking for great pizza – definitely give Trattoria La Sorrentina a try; it’s easily one of the best pizza joints around!

#8 Amici’s Restaurant

From the first bite, I knew I was in for something special. The pizza crust was thin, chewy and no doubt made with love and care! Toppings were plentiful and very flavorful–I totally recommend getting the pepperoni and basil combo, it’s definitely a winner.

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, perfect for a date night out or just a casual meal with friends. And the servers were so friendly that I felt like family.

What can I say? Amici’s Restaurant is surely one of the best pizza places around. Highly recommended from this traveling food critic!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Edgewater!

#9 Brother’s Pizza

I stumbled into this amazing restaurant and decided to give it a try. When I entered, I was greeted with a warm welcome from the staff and an offer to sample the finest ingredients they had available.

The atmosphere was a classic Italian pizzeria with checkered table cloths, wood paneling, and even a red-checked hat on one of the waiters. The background music was an old-school New Jersey rap song from the ’90s, which instantly brought me back to my younger days.

I ordered the classic pepperoni pizza and could tell that something special was about to happen. As soon as it arrived at my table, I knew why Brother’s Pizza is considered among the best in Bergen County NJ! The combination of savory pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, and homemade tomato sauce were unbelievably good. The crust was perfectly cooked and light as air.

My meal didn’t end just there; Brother’s Pizza also has some of the best desserts in town! Homemade Italian doughnuts filled with cream were incredibly delicious – after one bite it was like all my tastebuds had come alive!

If you’re looking for top-notch pizza in Bergen County NJ then look no further than Brother’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Kinchley’s Tavern

I recently ventured to this pleasant little spot, and I was not disappointed. Their pizza is the perfect balance of crunchy crust, flavorful sauce and delicious cheese. The toppings are always fresh and plentiful, making for an amazing flavor combination each time.

The best part about Kinchley’s Tavern, though, is that it offers something for everyone. From their alcohol selection (and hard liquor!), to their kid’s menu, desserts and sports-watching opportunities – it’s a great place to kick back and enjoy yourself.

Sure, they don’t do delivery like some of the other spots in town, but being able to sit in Kinchley’s Tavern and savor every bite of their delicious pizza makes up for that. Plus, it’s also a great tourist spot; I’ve met plenty of locals on my visits there who can vouch for the greatness of its pies!

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Bergen County NJ (which you should be!), Kinchley’s Tavern should be at the top of your list!

#11 Soprano’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a real treat. The cozy atmosphere was inviting and the smell of the wood-fire oven cooking up perfection was tantalizing.

I decided to go with their signature pizza, “The Soprano,” which is an Italian style pie topped with sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese. It was cooked to perfection and every bite melted in my mouth! The sausage had an amazing flavor and the crunch of each veggie added texture to the overall experience.

The crust was just as good because it had that classic Italian taste that can only be achieved by using their unique method of dough preparation. And of course the sauce, which is always key when it comes to great pizza, didn’t disappoint either. It wasn’t too salty or too sweet but just right!

Overall I’d have to say that if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bergen County NJ, then look no further than Soprano’s Pizza!