Best Pizza in Butler Pa. (Updated Jan 2023)

After sampling 11 different pizza places in the area, I’m humbled to say that Butler has some truly world-class pies! The search for the best pizza was tough, but with every slice I tasted, I got closer to finding it. With a lighthearted and humorous attitude, I’d like to share my findings with you. So let’s dive in and find out which place serves up the best pizza in Butler Pa.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Mac's Brick Oven Pizza

#1 Mac’s Brick Oven Pizza

Open Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11AM-8PM
Wednesday: 11AM-8PM
Thursday: 11AM-8PM
Friday: 11AM-8PM
Saturday: 11AM-8PM
Sunday: Closed

Benefits
  • Offers dessert
  • Nice tourist spot
  • Has some vegetarian options

Downsides
  • No delivery


I was pleasantly surprised at the range of options available; not only does this restaurant offer a good selection of traditional pies, but they also have some great vegetarian options. What more could I ask for! But the best part of my visit was the dessert. The thick and gooey brownie was truly to die for.

The atmosphere is quite nice too; while I can’t vouch for its accuracy, I’m told that it’s meant to replicate an Italian village. To me, it felt like a real tourist spot. All in all, if you’re looking to get a slice in Butler then I highly recommend Mac’s Brick Oven Pizza!

Unfortunately, they do not offer delivery. So if that’s your thing you may need to look elsewhere. Still, Mac’s Brick Oven Pizza is definitely worth trying out any time you’re in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Tani's Pizza

#2 Tani’s Pizza

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-9PM
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 11AM-9PM
Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Sunday: 11AM-9PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert
  • Has a kid’s menu


My visit started with a report from my good friend and fellow pizza connoisseur, “Hey Edward, if you ever find yourself in the Butler area you absolutely have to try Tani’s Pizza!” They were right!

I walked through the doors and knew I was in the right spot. The place had a great atmosphere; cozy corners outfitted with booths, tables perfectly spaced throughout, and a long bar with plenty of seating.

The pizza itself was as glorious as promised. Every slice is handmade with fresh ingredients and they don’t skimp on the toppings either! My favorite was the sausage and pepperoni combo; it had just enough cheese to keep it delicious without being too oily. Every bite was heavenly!

If that wasn’t enough-which it almost certainly was-they also have an extensive selection of beers on tap that was surely a pleasant surprise. I tried their ‘Butler Bitter’, a local ale which paired perfectly with my pizza.

I’d give Tani’s Pizza an A++ for atmosphere, quality, service, selection- well frankly everything! Don’t miss out on this gem next time you’re looking for the best pizza in Butler PA!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Villa Grande Restaurant & Pizzeria

#3 Villa Grande Restaurant & Pizzeria

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-9PM
Tuesday: 11AM-9PM
Wednesday: 11AM-9PM
Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Sunday: Closed

Benefits
  • Nice tourist spot
  • Has insanely good dessert
  • Has some vegetarian options
  • Has a kid’s menu


I had the pleasure of dining at this family owned pizza joint, and I must say that I wasn’t disappointed. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming – dimly lit with classic Italian charm.

The menu had a good selection of pizzas, as well as several other Italian classics. I decided to go with a classic Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The thin crust was perfectly cooked, the sauce had just enough sweetness, and the mozzarella cheese bubbled up beautifully. The flavors were top-notch and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

I also ordered their famous garlic knots which were crispy on the outside and soft inside – definitely one of my favorite side orders anywhere!

Overall, Villa Grande Restaurant & Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza I’ve ever had in Butler PA, hands down! From the cozy atmosphere to delicious food, it’s an absolute must visit if you’re in town.

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Anna Maria's Pizza and More

#4 Anna Maria’s Pizza and More

Open Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Sunday: 3-8PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert
  • Has a kid’s menu


From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was inviting and warm, with an exceptional pizza-making team behind the counter.

When it came to the pizza itself, there wasn’t anything that could be faulted. My personal favorite was their signature creation which had a thin base and just the right amount of topping. The crust was light and crispy, while the sauce was flavorful and tangy — not too sweet or salty.

The best part about Anna Maria’s Pizza and More? Their variety! Not only do they have classic favorites like pepperoni, but their selection also includes specialty pizzas like buffalo chicken and even vegan options. They even had gluten-free alternatives for those who require it.

If you’re looking for top-notch pizza in Butler Pa., Anna Maria’s Pizza and More is definitely a place to check out! It’s got all of your Italian favorites with a friendly staff to back it up, making it one of my favorite places to get some tasty ‘za!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - L Pizza Plus

#5 L Pizza Plus

Open Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 11AM-7PM
Thursday: 11AM-7PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Sunday: 11:30AM-7PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert


I was absolutely blown away by the quality and flavor of their pizzas. Their traditional pies were cooked to perfection, with a crispy golden crust and cheesy goodness on top. I also enjoyed their specialty pizzas, which had unique toppings like roasted bell pepper and bacon or ham. The flavors were robust and tantalizing, and the cheese was gooey and melted just right.

The service at L Pizza Plus was also excellent – my server was very friendly and helpful, offering suggestions for what type of pizza I should try. He even let me sample a slice before ordering!

Overall, this restaurant lived up to its reputation as Butler Pa.’s best pizza joint. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in the area!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Pizza Pie

#6 Pizza Pie

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-10PM
Tuesday: 11AM-10PM
Wednesday: 11AM-10PM
Thursday: 11AM-10PM
Friday: 11AM-11PM
Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Sunday: 12-9PM

The first thing that impressed me was the pizza dough – it had a perfect consistency and was cooked just right, with the perfect amount of crunch. The sauce was also spot on. It had a delightful sweetness to it and had an amazing depth of flavor.

The toppings were where this place really shines. They used fresh vegetables and high-quality cheese, which made the whole pizza stand out from its competitors. The amounts used were well balanced too, so no topping overpowered the others.

The service at Pizza Pie was also fantastic – everyone was incredibly friendly and helpful when I asked about their pizzas (which I did quite a bit!).

Overall, Pizza Pie is definitely one of my top choices for pizza in Butler Pa., and I would highly recommend checking it out if you’re ever in the area!

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Third Eye Pies

#7 Third Eye Pies

Open Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11AM-8PM
Wednesday: 11AM-8PM
Thursday: 11AM-8PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Sunday: 11AM-8PM

Benefits
  • Nice tourist spot
  • Offers dessert


My first experience at Third Eye Pies was unforgettable. I walked in and was immediately welcomed by the friendly staff. They took their time to explain all the different types of pizzas they offered. I chose a classic pepperoni and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

But even better than the pizza itself was the atmosphere. From the chalkboard walls to the dimly lit corners, this place had a unique charm that made me feel right at home. And if you’re looking for an Italian feast, then you’ve come to the right place – they serve lasagna, garlic bread, and other delicious Italian dishes too!

To top it off, they have great drink specials like happy hour deals and craft beers on tap. Whether you want a quiet night out with your friends or just want some good old-fashioned pizza, Third Eye Pies has got you covered! All in all, this is definitely one of my favorite places for pizza in Butler PA – it’s simply unbeatable!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Pizza Pie

#8 Pizza Pie

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-10PM
Tuesday: 11AM-10PM
Wednesday: 11AM-10PM
Thursday: 11AM-10PM
Friday: 11AM-11PM
Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Sunday: 12-9PM

I visited Pizza Pie recently, and I have to say that it was an absolute delight. From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was vibrant and inviting, and the smell of freshly cooked pizza filled the air.

The pizza itself was out of this world. As I bit into my first slice, I tasted the strong flavors of cheese, tangy tomato sauce and indulgent spices – all perfectly balanced together to create one scrumptious bite after another. The crust was golden brown and crispy on the outside, yet soft and chewy on the inside- truly a masterpiece!

To top it off, their service is exceptional. Even though it was very busy when I visited, everyone was friendly and attentive to our needs. They even gave us complimentary slices at the end of our meal!

All in all, Pizza Pie is definitely a must-try for anyone looking for the best pizza in Butler Pa. If you’re ever in town, be sure to pay them a visit for a slice of delicious pizza that’s sure to leave your taste buds wanting more!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Penn Street Pizza

#9 Penn Street Pizza

Open Hours
Monday: 3-11PM
Tuesday: 3-11PM
Wednesday: 11AM-11PM
Thursday: 11AM-11PM
Friday: 11AM-12AM
Saturday: 3PM-12AM
Sunday: 4-11PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert


The atmosphere here was wonderful, and the staff was very friendly and made me feel right at home. The wait times were surprisingly short, considering how busy they were.

First off, I have to say that the crust was truly amazing. It had a perfect balance of crunch and softness, while still maintaining its thinness. The cheese on the pizza’s top was gooey and delicious, with just the right amount of flavor. As for the toppings – I’m pretty sure they must be using some secret ingredient because their combination of flavors is absolutely outstanding!

Not only did the pizza taste great but it also had an awesome presentation too – perfectly cooked toppings with a golden-brown crust adorned with plenty of herbs for added fragrance!

I’m glad I took the time to stop by this restaurant because it definitely lived up to being one of the best pizza places in Butler Pa., delivering high quality food every time.

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Pizza Hut

#10 Pizza Hut

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-10PM
Tuesday: 11AM-10PM
Wednesday: 11AM-10PM
Thursday: 11AM-10PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Sunday: 11AM-10PM

I recently visited the Pizza Hut location in Butler Pa., and I was amazed at how delicious their pizzas were. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy on the outside, with a perfectly light chewiness on the inside that made it almost melt in your mouth. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and had just the right amount of spices added to bring out the flavors of all the toppings.

The variety of toppings also impressed me! They offer a wide selection of meats, cheeses, veggies, and more so you can create your own masterpiece. Plus, they have some signature pizzas like their BBQ chicken pizza that are always a hit.

I must say that Pizza Hut’s pizza is definitely among some of the best I’ve ever tasted. The ingredients are top-notch quality and everything is always cooked to perfection no matter what I order. My taste buds were in heaven during my visit here!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Butler Pa., head to Pizza Hut! You won’t be disappointed!

#1 best pizza place in Butler - Pizza Joe's

#11 Pizza Joe’s

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-10PM
Tuesday: 11AM-10PM
Wednesday: 11AM-10PM
Thursday: 11AM-10PM
Friday: 11AM-11PM
Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Sunday: 12-9:30PM

Benefits
  • Has some vegetarian options
  • Nice tourist spot
  • Offers dessert


The atmosphere was great and the decor was just what you’d expect from a pizzeria, with plenty of red and white checkered tablecloths. They didn’t skimp on the quality of their ingredients either, choosing only top shelf cheeses, meats and herbs. I tasted marinara sauce that was so fresh it could have been just made hours prior!

The crust here is where they really stand out though. It’s always freshly made and cooked to perfection, providing a crunchy texture without being too hard or doughy. The pizza toppings are unique – like barbecue chicken with pineapple – but no matter what combination you choose, you can guarantee a flavor explosion in every bite!

Overall, Pizza Joe’s should definitely be at the top of your list the next time you’re looking for the best pizza in Butler Pa. My only advice is to come hungry because their portion sizes are very generous!

If you’re willing to go an extra 29 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Solve : *
17 × 26 =


Pizza Oven Radar