Best Pizza in Chicago IL (Updated Jan 2023)

I’m here to judge what Chicago has to offer in terms of pizza, and I’m not going to take it lightly! I’ve sampled 11 different places throughout the city – all in the name of research, of course.

From deep dish favorites to trendy Neapolitan pies, I’m ready to crown the best pizza in Chicago IL. Get ready for some cheesy suspense and lighthearted jokes as I make my way around town.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Milly’s Pizza In The Pan

The atmosphere at Milly’s is cozy and inviting, and there’s a plethora of different toppings to choose from. The crust is perfectly cooked, with just the right balance between crispy and soft. And the sauce… oh, the sauce! It’s full of flavor and incredibly delicious.

And if you like spicy pizza, Milly’s is right up your alley! They have several different varieties that range from mild to extra hot – something for everyone!

I’d be remiss not to mention their cheesy breadsticks and garlic knots – simply divine. If I could give them ten stars out of five, I would!

But don’t just take my word for it; go check out Milly’s Pizza In The Pan for yourself and see what all the fuss is about. You won’t regret it – I guarantee it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Chicago!

#2 Naudi Signature Pizza

I was immediately impressed by the quality of ingredients used in their pizza. The crust was so flavorful and crisp, and their tomato sauce was incredibly fresh and fragrant. Their choice of cheese was top notch – you could really taste the difference!

Toppings-wise, I think Naudi Signature Pizza goes all out. They have so many creative topping combinations that all work together to give a unique flavor profile to each slice. From truffle oil to chili flakes to hot peppers, there’s something for everyone here.

Moreover, the staff at Naudi Signature Pizza were all amazingly friendly and helpful – it made for a great atmosphere! They always had great suggestions for what kind of pizza would best suit my tastes, which I sincerely appreciated.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Chicago IL, look no further than Naudi Signature Pizza!

#3 Spacca Napoli Pizzeria

The crust here is to die for – it’s crunchy on the outside, yet soft and fluffy in the center. The toppings are generous, but not overwhelming – just enough to give you all the flavors without being too much.

The service is great as well – our waiter was knowledgeable and friendly, definitely adding to the experience. The atmosphere is quaint yet stylish, providing a nice environment for enjoying your pizza.

Most importantly though, the taste of their pizza is mouth-watering! If you’re looking for genuine Neapolitan-style pizza, then this is THE place to go. I mean it when I say that Spacca Napoli Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Chicago IL. Highly recommended!

#4 Bonci Pizzeria

I was immediately impressed with the restaurant’s atmosphere. The decor had a modern Italian vibe that felt welcoming and comforting.

The chef in charge of creating these masterpieces is no ordinary cook. He has an impressive resume that includes experiences abroad in many different cities, so I knew that this pizza had to be good!

But it wasn’t just the atmosphere that wowed me – the pizza did too! The crust was thin and chewy, with just the right amount of crunch. It was topped off with an array of fresh ingredients from imported cheese to local herbs, all cooked to perfection. Every bite had a burst of flavor that transported my taste buds to another world.

Bonci Pizzeria has definitely earned its spot as one of the best pizzerias in Chicago IL! If you’re looking for a delicious slice of Italy in the Midwest, you have to try this place!

#5 George’s Deep Dish

I arrived at the restaurant, passing through a traditional Italian-style archway to get to the restaurant’s cozy interior. As soon as I walked in I was hit with the heavenly aroma of fresh pizza dough and tomato sauce. You could tell they took their pizzas seriously here!

The atmosphere was inviting and relaxed, with soft music playing in the background. It was obvious that a lot of thought had gone into creating an enjoyable atmosphere for its guests.

The pizza was the star of the show, however! The crust had a nice crunchy texture that wasn’t too thick or too thin – just perfect. The tomato sauce was rich and flavorful, while the cheese was meltingly delicious. The toppings were generous without overwhelming the other flavors, making each bite truly enjoyable.

It’s no wonder why George’s Deep Dish has become one of Chicago’s most beloved pizza spots – it definitely lives up to its reputation! If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Chicago IL, this is definitely your spot!

#6 Zazas Pizzeria

I’m not usually one for hyperbole, but the pizza here was out-of-this-world! The crust had the perfect balance between crunch and softness, the sauce was flavorful and had just the right amount of sweetness, and the cheese was simply divine. Of course, you can’t forget about the toppings – there’s a dizzying array of options to choose from, ranging from classic pepperoni to more exotic selections like artichoke hearts and eggplant.

The atmosphere at Zazas Pizzeria is equally as delightful; friendly staff will greet you with a smile as soon as you enter, and the decor is quaint yet welcoming. Plus, they also have a great selection of craft beers to pair with your meal!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Chicago IL, look no further than Zazas Pizzeria – I guarantee that you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Coalfire

This unassuming pizza joint really packs a flavor punch. The crust is perfectly thin and crisp, with just the right amount of char and crunch. The cheese is creamy and flavorful, with each bite full of gooey deliciousness. And the sauce! It’s rich and flavorful, spicy but not overwhelming.

The toppings are always fresh. They have all the classics like pepperoni and mushrooms, as well as some unique options like spicy sausage and roasted red peppers. I always find something new to try each time I visit Coalfire – it keeps me coming back again and again!

But what makes this place truly remarkable is the staff! Everyone I’ve encountered has been incredibly friendly and welcoming. They take their time explaining each topping option and make sure to ask if I’d like extra cheese or different sauces on my pizza.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Chicago IL, then look no further than Coalfire!

#8 My Pi Pizza

Let me tell you, I’m no rookie when it comes to pizza. From New York City slices to Neapolitan pies, I’ve tasted the good and the bad–but My Pi Pizza is something special.

Now I know what you’re thinking – “Just another Chicago deep dish spot!” Well, let me tell you that while they do have amazing deep-dish creations (the pepperoni and roasted garlic combo is to die for!), they also offer thin crust options that are just as delicious.

Their ingredients are top-notch—you can really taste the freshness in every bite. The staff is super friendly too! They’re always willing to answer any questions about their ingredients or cooking methods.

Overall, My Pi Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Chicago IL! If you haven’t paid them a visit yet, you’re seriously missing out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Chicago!

#9 Forno Rosso Pizzeria Napoletana

The first thing that stood out to me was the cozy atmosphere. The brick-oven pizzas are made right in front of you, and the delicious smell fills up the room! The decor is simple and minimalistic, but it’s very inviting and makes for a great place to chat with friends.

When it comes to their pizza, Forno Rosso does not disappoint! I sampled several different flavors and each one was more delicious than the last. From the classic Margherita to the Prosciutto & Arugula – each pie had its own unique flavor. The crust is light and airy, giving it a great texture.

I’m confident in saying that Forno Rosso Pizzeria Napoletana serves some of the best pizza in Chicago IL! If you have yet to check them out, I highly recommend doing so soon – my taste buds were not disappointed!

#10 Craft Pizza

I’m not sure how they do it, but the crust is the perfect balance of crunchy and soft, while the toppings are always cooked to perfection. The garlic knots are out of this world – HUGE! I’m talking bigger than a fist! Plus, the cheese pull is phenomenal.

The staff creates a welcoming environment and it’s clearly evident that they take pride in their work. They even attempted to teach me some of their secret recipes! I also had a chance to sample some unique sauces which were definitely intriguing.

No matter how often I visit, I’m always impressed and leave feeling satisfied with my meal. Craft Pizza stands out from other pizza places in the area – hands down the best pizza in Chicago IL!

#11 Pequod’s Pizza

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately greeted with a comforting smell of burning wood and delicious cheese. The restaurant is cozy and inviting, with the wood-fired oven taking center stage.

The staff were super friendly, answering all of my questions about the menu and being patient when it took me a while to decide what I wanted. Once I finally ordered, my pizza arrived quickly. And it was worth the wait!

The crust was cooked to perfection, crispy on the outside and soft inside. It had great flavor thanks to the wood-fired oven, but it wasn’t overly charred or burnt. The cheese was melty and flavorful, while the toppings were fresh and plentiful. It really hit the spot!

Overall, Pequod’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Chicago IL without a doubt! Not only is their pizza incredibly tasty, but the atmosphere is also warm and inviting. If you’re in town looking for amazing pizza, look no further than Pequod’s Pizza!