Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Colorado Springs (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Colorado

Best Pizza in Colorado Springs (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

162 Views

I like to think of myself as a pizza connoisseur, so what I’m about to share is no small feat; after tasting 12 pizzas across Colorado Springs, I’ve found the best!

This isn’t a serious scientific study – nothing ever is with food – but rather, a lighthearted and humorous journey around the city in search of cheesy goodness. You won’t find any dry commentary here about the crust or sauce ratios; just an honest opinion from someone who loves pizza and craves a good slice.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 High Rise Pizza Kitchen

My first thought when stepping into the restaurant was that I had found a hidden gem in this city. The decor was modern and stylish, and the atmosphere was unrivaled. As for the pizza itself, it just hit all the right notes. The crust was cooked to perfection, the cheese and toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the sauce was the perfect blend of sweet and savory.

The service here was also top-notch. Our server greeted us with a smile and immediatly made us feel welcome; she even recommended some signature pies that weren’t on the menu! We eventually ended up ordering one for each of us to share—the Pesto Sunrise (pesto base topped with red onions, mushrooms, spinach, feta) and 4 Cheese Heaven (Mozzarella, Cheddar, Feta & Gorgonzola)—and they were both out of this world.

Overall I’d have to say that High Rise Pizza Kitchen is by far the best pizza joint in Colorado Springs. If you’re looking for a great pizza experience then look no further; you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 31 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Castle Rock!

#2 Slice 420

The pizza is always cooked to perfection here, with a perfectly balanced and crispy crust that holds up the delicious toppings. On my most recent visit, I had their signature “420” pizza, which was loaded up with fresh pepperoni, mushrooms, peppers, and onions. It was just the right level of cheesy and flavorful, and not too greasy.

The atmosphere at Slice 420 is relaxed and inviting, with people from all walks of life gathering around the tables to enjoy some great slices together. The waitstaff are friendly and knowledgeable about their menu selections, ensuring that customers are well taken care of.

I would highly recommend Slice 420 for anyone looking for the best pizza in Colorado Springs!

#3 Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria

The first thing that stood out for me was the atmosphere. As soon as you walk in, you can smell the delicious aroma of freshly made pizza and the decor just gives off a cozy vibe that makes it feel like home.

The service at Bambino’s is outstanding – everyone from the wait staff to the cooks are friendly and happy to help make your experience great. The menu offers a variety of unique pizza options, so there’s something for everyone! My favorite part was trying their classic margarita pizza – it was simple yet flavorful and definitely hit the spot.

This place really knows how to make some of the best pizza in Colorado Springs. From the amazing staff to their fresh ingredients, Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria should definitely be on your list of places to check out if you’re looking for some good eats!

#4 Leon Gessi New York Pizza

My first impression of Leon Gessi was that it was the epitome of a no-frills New York pizzeria. Red-and-white checkered tablecloths, faded pictures of Italy on the walls, and an old-school jukebox blaring away in one corner. It felt like I had stepped right into a scene from Goodfellas!

The pizza here is really something special. There’s something magical about the crust – it’s wonderfully thin and light, but still manages to hold up to all the toppings without getting soggy. And speaking of toppings, Leon Gessi certainly knows how to put together a great combination – my favorite being their classic pepperoni and mushroom pizza! The sauce has enough zing to really bring out the flavors, but isn’t so overpowering that it distracts from the rest of the ingredients.

It wouldn’t be a proper review if I didn’t mention the customer service here as well – it was exceptional! Everyone from the delivery driver to the restaurant manager went out of their way to make sure I had everything I needed for a top notch dining experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Colorado Springs then look no further than Leon Gessi New York Pizza!

#5 Roman Villa Pizza

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew this place was special. The décor is both classy and inviting; great for a romantic evening or just an evening with friends. The service is top-notch as well. Everyone from the cashier to the waiters shows great attention to detail—they even remembered my name!

As for the pizza—words can’t do justice to how delicious it is. Every bite had its own flavor profile, with various herbs and spices that made each slice unique. The crust was thin but not too thin, and just the right amount of crunchy. To top it off, all the ingredients were incredibly fresh!

If you’re ever in Colorado Springs and looking for some of the best pizza around, Roman Villa Pizza should definitely be your first stop. You won’t be disappointed!

#6 MOD Pizza

To say this place has perfected their pizza would be an understatement. The atmosphere was great, the employees were friendly, and I was definitely in for an unforgettable experience.

When it comes to the pizza, they have an impressive variety of topping options like artichokes, feta cheese, roasted red peppers, and more! Plus, they offer gluten-free crusts as well as vegan-friendly options. They also have a selection of salads and sides too!

The pizza itself is always cooked just right; the thin crust is crisp and the toppings are fresh. On top of that, there’s nothing better than their prices—they are extremely affordable for such a high quality meal.

At MOD Pizza, it’s all about enjoying freshly made pizza that caters to everyone’s tastes with amazing customer service while still being wallet-friendly. I highly recommend stopping by if you’re ever in Colorado Springs—you won’t regret it!

#7 Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta

The atmosphere here is great — it’s got a cool, ’50s diner feel that’s fun and inviting. All the staff were incredibly friendly and helpful; they went out of their way to make sure I had a great experience.

As for the pizza, wow! I’d say Roadrunner has some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. The crust was just right — not too thick, not too thin. The cheese was creamy and flavorful, while the toppings were fresh and delicious. I especially loved their special parmesan-herb mix that was sprinkled on top!

Overall, my visit to Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta was a huge success! It was my first time in Colorado Springs and I’m glad I stumbled upon this hidden gem. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in town, look no further than Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta!

#8 Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders

The crust was crisp, thin and golden on the outside, with just the right amount of chewiness. The sauce was sweet and tangy and contrasted perfectly against the smoky, succulent sausage pieces scattered throughout.

The toppings were varied and creative: from roasted mushrooms to barbecue chicken to artichoke hearts, no two pizzas were alike! The separate “grinder” menu also offered some interesting combinations in subs such as spicy jalapenos with crispy bacon or spicy Italian sausage on an olive-oil slathered bun.

What really surprised me about Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders was the attention to detail in their side dishes. Their garlic knots were lightly fried yet still warm and moist inside; the parmesan potatoes wedges had a crunchy golden brown outside that melted away with each bite.

Overall, I highly recommend Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders for anyone looking for fantastic pizza! Not only have they mastered classic recipes, but they constantly strive to take their pies up a notch. With excellent service and delicious food, this restaurant is sure to please even the most discerning of pizza connoisseurs.

If you’re willing to go an extra 43 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Parker!

#9 MOD Pizza

Their atmosphere is very cool and hip. You can watch the pizza makers right in front of you, spinning and tossing the dough, sprinkling on the toppings, and sliding it into the oven in a matter of seconds!

The size of their pizzas is also amazing – they offer small, medium, and large (the largest being almost two feet wide!). I was really impressed with how quickly they make each pizza. It’s like a dance — a beautiful display of craftsmanship!

The toppings are fresh and high-quality. The sauce is well balanced with just enough sweetness to round out the overall flavor. And the cheese is always gooey, melted perfection.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Colorado Springs then MOD Pizza needs to be on your list. Their delicious pizzas combined with their sleek modern atmosphere make for an unforgettable dining experience!

#10 Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza – University Village Colorado Springs

The atmosphere is great – cozy, inviting and with a lovely view of the University Village. The staff are friendly, helpful and very knowledgeable about their menu.

The pizza is simply amazing! The crust is made from freshly milled flour, crafted with care in their wood-fired oven for an unbeatable flavor. The perfect blend of ingredients create exceptionally flavorful combinations that I would recommend to anyone!

The toppings were fresh, delicious and artfully arranged on the restaurant’s signature pizzas. We opted for the “Margarita” which was topped with house-made tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil and olives – it was divine!

And if you still have room for dessert, consider one of their unique Snow Cream specialty shakes – they’re creamy yet light, with a hint of Italian flavors. Heaven!

I’m happy to say that Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza – University Village Colorado Springs is indeed one of the best pizza places in Colorado Springs – definitely worth a visit (or two… or three!).

#11 Pizzeria Rustica

The pizza is so fresh and flavorful that I just keep coming back for more. Not to mention their Margherita pizza, which is absolutely heavenly. Plus, they have some great vegetarian options and an outstanding selection of hard liquor to go with it!

But what really sets Pizzeria Rustica apart from the rest is their dessert menu. The cannoli cheesecake alone is worth the trip. Seriously, it’s insanely good and you won’t find anything like it anywhere else.

However, if you’re looking for delivery service then this isn’t your spot. But don’t worry; despite the lack of delivery, this place still makes a great tourist spot and an even better sit-down restaurant!

All in all, Pizzeria Rustica is without a doubt the best pizza in Colorado Springs!

#12 Duca’s Neapolitan Pizza

The first thing that strikes you about Duca’s is the amazing atmosphere: it looks like a traditional Italian trattoria, with white-washed walls, warmth radiating from the wood-fired pizza oven and friendly staff.

The pizzas at Duca’s are simply divine. The restaurant is famous for its signature Margherita with mozzarella, tomato and basil – but they offer a variety of other options including pesto, veggie and even vegan pizzas. The crust is thin but well cooked, so it isn’t too crispy or too crunchy. And the toppings are always fresh and tasty.

I’ve been fortunate enough to have tasted pizzas all over the world, but I have to say that Dulce’s Neapolitan Pizza may just be the best pizza in Colorado Springs! If you’re ever in town, make sure you give them a try – you won’t regret it!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

As I walked into Old Chicago, the aromas of melted cheese and crispy crusts captivated my senses. I was like a kid in a candy store, but instead of candy, it was pizza. The waitstaff, clad in colorful Chicago Bulls jerseys, welcomed me with big smiles and contagious enthusiasm. I couldn’t help but chuckle at the irony of being in Colorado Springs, yet surrounded by a Chicago sports vibe.

Taking the plunge into their deep dish pizza was like diving headfirst into a pool of cheesy delight. The crust was thick, buttery, and perfectly crispy, creating a sturdy foundation for the generous toppings. I opted for the classic Margherita, and it was a work of art. The vibrant red sauce danced with the melted mozzarella, giving each bite a harmonious marriage of flavors. I proclaimed it pizza perfection amidst a chorus of satisfied belly growls.

But it wasn’t just the pizza that tickled my fancy; Old Chicago also know how to keep thirst at bay. With an extensive selection of craft beers on tap, I found myself in a hoppy wonderland. From IPAs preaching the gospel of bitterness to creamy stouts that could double as dessert, there was a beer for every palate.

In conclusion, Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is a deep dish paradise in the heart of Colorado Springs. If you’re craving a slice of cheesy heaven that will transport you straight to the Windy City, look no further. Just be prepared for your taste buds to do a little happy dance, and possibly your waistline as well. Bon appétit, my pizza-loving friends!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Leon Gessi New York Pizza

First of all, this place serves alcohol! Finally, a pizza joint that understands the need for a cold brew to wash down all that cheesy goodness. It’s like they read my mind and decided to create the perfect pairing.

Now, let’s talk about the desserts. You know what they say, life is too short to skip dessert, and Leon Gessi New York Pizza knows it! I couldn’t resist their decadent chocolate lava cake. It was so rich and gooey, I almost asked for a second one. Almost, because I still had a pizza to tackle!

Speaking of pizza, their thin crust is a masterpiece. It’s crispy, yet chewy, and perfectly balances the toppings. Each bite feels like a mouthful of joy. And let me tell you, I’ve had my fair share of pizza all over the world, and this one stands out.

Now, I do have to mention one downside: they don’t accept reservations. So, if you’re planning on dining here, be prepared to join the hordes of hungry people eagerly waiting to get their hands on a piping hot slice of heaven. But hey, it’s a nice tourist spot! You can always chat with your fellow pizza enthusiasts while you wait, and maybe even make some new friends who share your love for Leon Gessi’s.

All in all, if you’re in Colorado Springs and craving the best thin crust pizza around, head to Leon Gessi New York Pizza. Just make sure to arrive with an empty stomach and a sense of adventure, because you’re in for a mouthwatering ride!