Best Pizza in Highlands Ranch (Updated Jan 2023)

Having eaten more pizza than I can count in all sorts of cities, from New York to Rome to Tokyo, I’ve never shied away from a challenge when it comes to finding the best one.

That said, I decided that Highlands Ranch was worth checking out – and the 11 great places I visited did not disappoint!

Join me on this lighthearted and humorous journey as I sample some of the best pies in town and declare which is truly the best pizza in Highlands Ranch once and for all!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 Big Bill’s New York Pizza

I was greeted with a warm welcome and attentive staff when I arrived in the cozy and inviting atmosphere of Big Bill’s. The restaurant has an authentically New York-style décor, complete with tinned ceilings and vintage pizza posters on the walls.

After perusing the menu, I opted for the classic New York-style cheese pizza and let me tell you, it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly crispy, yet still soft on the inside. The marinara sauce had just enough tang to cut through the richness of the cheese. Every bite was delicious!

In addition to amazing food, Big Bill’s also offers an impressive selection of craft beers and wines. They also have live music on select nights which adds to the overall experience.

All in all, it’s safe to say that Big Bill’s New York Pizza is some of the best pizza in Highlands Ranch – it definitely deserves my stamp of approval!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Parker!

#2 Jet’s Pizza

I was amazed by the beautiful, crisp crust that Jet’s Pizza creates. It held together the wonderful flavors of their freshly made ingredients, from the subtle sweetness of red sauce to the sharpness of their pepperoni. The cheese was melty and delicious and went perfectly with the toppings they allowed me to customize my pizza with.

Despite being a humble restaurant, Jet’s Pizza offers a great atmosphere too! The owners were friendly and accommodating as I asked for my custom order. Plus, they had a wide selection of beer on tap so I could sit back and enjoy my meal while sipping on some cold suds.

Overall, I am thrilled to have found Jet’s Pizza here in Highlands Ranch – I can confidently say that it may very well be the best pizza in town!

#3 MOD Pizza

I took my first bite, and was immediately impressed by the flavor of the perfectly cooked crust. The Mod Pizza crust is thin but sturdy enough to hold all the toppings without getting soggy. The sauce was flavorful, yet subtle enough to allow the individual flavors of each topping to shine through.

The toppings they offer are like no other pizza place I’ve had before with options like bacon and feta cheese – this unique combination made for an incredible taste experience! The team at MOD Pizza were incredibly helpful in creating a customized pizza that catered to my personal preferences.

The prices are also very reasonable for the quality of ingredients and pizzas you get – it’s certainly a good value for your money.

Overall, I would highly recommend MOD Pizza if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Highlands Ranch – it’s definitely one of the best around!

#4 Coloradough Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is casual and inviting. It’s a great place to hang out with family, friends, and coworkers.

As for their pizza, it’s outstanding! They use the freshest ingredients in all their recipes and they don’t skimp on quality. The crust was perfectly cooked – crispy, yet fluffy. The sauces were vibrant and flavorful, while the cheese was simply divine.

But the real star of this show is the toppings. From classic favorites like pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms to gourmet varieties like prosciutto and arugula, Coloradough Pizza has something for everyone. You can also create your own signature masterpiece for something truly unique!

Overall, I would give Coloradough Pizza five stars! My taste buds were delighted by every single bite I took – it truly is some of the best pizza in Highlands Ranch!

#5 Via Baci

On my recent visit, I was welcomed by the friendly staff and immediately impressed by the atmosphere. The restaurant had a cozy and inviting vibe which made me feel right at home.

The menu had an impressive selection of gourmet pizzas, with something for everyone. But I had to go for the classic pepperoni – it didn’t disappoint! The pizza had a crunchy base, with just enough cheese and the perfect ratio of tomato sauce and herbs. It’s safe to say that I’ve finally found the best pepperoni pizza on my travels!

But there’s more to Via Baci than just great pizza; their salads are also incredibly delicious and well-presented. I also wanted to try out one of their desserts, but unfortunately we were so stuffed after our meal that we decided against it.

I would highly recommend Via Baci to anyone looking for great food in Highlands Ranch! With its amazing atmosphere, fantastic food, and friendly staff, you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Marco’s Coal-Fired | Englewood

On entering the restaurant, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere – the kind of place that makes you want to stay for hours. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, which gave me plenty of choices.

I opted for their signature coal-fired pizza, and it really did not disappoint! The crust had that perfect crunch and the toppings were cooked to perfection. The pizza was so tasty that I even went back for another one!

I highly recommend this restaurant if you’re looking for amazing pizzas in Highlands Ranch. From the ambiance to the flavor, Marco’s Coal-Fired | Englewood has it all!

#7 Carmines Pizza & Pasta

The atmosphere of the restaurant is great. It’s a warm and inviting place that always feels like home. The staff are friendly and make sure you’re always taken care of.

The pizza is definitely the star attraction here. Their pizzas are hand-tossed and made from the freshest ingredients, ensuring an outstanding flavor every time. On my most recent visit, I had a delicious combo pizza topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, black olives, onions, and Italian sausage. It was divine!

Other menu items include pastas and salads, but I would really recommend that you stick to the pizza if you’re looking for an excellent meal.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Highlands Ranch then look no further than Carmines Pizza & Pasta! Whether it’s their hand-tossed pizzas or their other specialty dishes, it’s sure to be a hit with everyone in your party!

#8 Jet’s Pizza

It’s no wonder this place is always packed—the pizza here is absolutely scrumptious. From the thin crust to the fresh toppings and just-right amount of cheese, the taste is truly incomparable. The margherita pizza was especially delicious; it tasted like I was eating a slice of Italy in Colorado!

The service at Jet’s Pizza was also top notch. Everyone was incredibly friendly and accommodating; they went above and beyond to make sure my dining experience was unforgettable.

Perhaps most impressive of all, though, were their prices—incredibly affordable for such high-quality food. I could easily see myself visiting Jet’s Pizza any time I’m in Highlands Ranch! All in all, it’s definitely one of the best places around for pizza: A definite must-try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Littleton!

#9 Nicolo’s Chicago Style Pizza

The first thing that stood out to me was the atmosphere. The restaurant is decked out with all the classic Chicago-style decor, from red and white checked tablecloths to neon signs of pizzas everywhere. It definitely contributed to my overall experience.

The pizza itself is absolutely delicious! Every bite I took was filled with intense flavors that danced on my tongue. From the thinly-sliced pepperoni to the gooey mozzarella cheese, I could tell that a lot of love and care went into every single slice.

I also have to give a special mention to their garlic knots – they are simply divine! The dough is light and airy while still having this amazing crunchy texture, and the hint of garlic is just the right balance of flavor without being overpowering.

Overall, if you’re ever in Highlands Ranch looking for some great pizza, then make sure you check out Nicolo’s Chicago Style Pizza. It certainly lives up to its name as one of the best pizzerias in town – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 The Varsity Inn

The Varsity Inn had such a great atmosphere — there was classic rock playing and the waitstaff always had a smile on their faces, like they were truly happy to be there.

The pizza? Oh my goodness. Simply put, it is the best I’ve ever had in all my travels around the globe. Their thin-crust has just the right amount of chewiness while still maintaining that perfectly crisp texture. Not to mention, they perfectly managed to balance out their sauce and cheese with fresh toppings — I especially enjoyed their signature pepperoni slices!

And don’t even get me started on their dessert pizzas… mouthwateringly delicious. Even after finishing an entire 12-inch pizza between two people, we couldn’t help but indulge in one more slice of their incredible apple churro pizza!

All in all, The Varsity Inn is quite simply one of the best pizza restaurants in Highlands Ranch — or anywhere for that matter! If you’re ever in town looking for some truly incredible pizza, look no further than this place!

#11 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

From the moment I entered the restaurant, I was struck by the inviting atmosphere and friendly customer service. But it was the pizza that really wowed me.

The crust is absolutely perfect – not too thick and not too thin, with just a hint of crunchiness. The balance of cheese and sauce is just right and all the toppings are distributed evenly. And what really sets Papa Murphy’s apart is their generous portions – you can always expect to get your money’s worth!

Overall, Papa Murphy’s truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizza places in Highlands Ranch. My only complaint? That I have to wait for my pizza to cook when I get home – but that’s a small price to pay for a delicious slice of pizza perfection!