Best Pizza in Indianapolis (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve tasted pizza all over the world, from Italy and Greece to NYC and Chicago. And I’m ready to share my experiences with Indy’s best pizzerias.

Maybe you’re in the mood for a classic cheese pizza, or something more exotic like fig and goat cheese? In any case, I’ve got you covered! I’ve carefully tried 11 places in Indianapolis, so you can be sure you’ll get quality recommendations.

You won’t find me judging pizza restaurants too harshly here – this is meant to be fun! Sit back and get ready for a lighthearted look at some of the best pies Indy has to offer.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Futuro

From the classic styles like Margherita and Pepperoni to their more creative varieties like Roasted Garlic and Jalapeño Popper, their pizzas are always cooked with precision. The chefs here really know how to get that perfect char on the crust.

The well-seasoned sauces add a nice layer of flavor, and their custom blend of Italian cheeses provides that feeling of creamy indulgence. You can tell they put extra love into every bite!

The service at Futuro is always friendly and attentive. There are plenty of seating options too, so if you’re looking for a relaxed dinner or a fun night out with friends then this is definitely the place to go.

In conclusion, I think it’s safe to say that Futuro has some of the best pizza in Indianapolis! If you’re looking for an enjoyable meal in an inviting atmosphere then this should be your first choice.

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Greenwood!

#2 Last Chance Pizza

The crust is perfectly cooked and has the perfect amount of crunch when you bite into it. The sauce is flavorful, with just enough spice to keep things interesting. And the cheese—oh, the cheese! It’s not overly greasy and gives that tasty hint of mozzarella that makes it so delightful.

The toppings are also top-notch. You can choose from all sorts of meats, vegetables, and other goodies – so much to choose from! And it all tasted great—there’s definitely something for everyone at Last Chance Pizza.

As for atmosphere, Last Chance Pizza definitely does not disappoint there either. The restaurant has a cozy vibe with dim lighting, nice décor, and friendly staff who will always make sure your dining experience is nothing short of perfect.

If you’re looking for a place that serves some of the best pizza in Indianapolis (and maybe even the world!) head over to Last Chance Pizza – you won’t be disappointed.

#3 Manhattan Pizzeria

The staff was friendly and accommodating, and the atmosphere was classic and inviting. Even the wait time was reasonable – no long lineups here.

The pizza crust was crispy, but not too thick, providing the perfect balance for all their toppings. My favorite combination, pepperoni and feta cheese, with a hint of garlic, was delicious! The sauce had just the right amount of tanginess as well.

I’d highly recommend a visit to Manhattan Pizzeria if you’re ever in Indianapolis looking for great pizza. Definitely one of the best in town!

#4 Pronta Pizzeria

The restaurant itself is inviting and warm, with a staff that is always friendly and helpful in finding the perfect pizza for you. The atmosphere helped make my experience enjoyable, but it was the food that really sealed the deal.

The pizzas are cooked perfectly to a golden-brown color and have some of the freshest ingredients I’ve ever tasted. From their signature “Pronta” pizza loaded with pepperoni and vegetables to their unique pasta dishes like gourmet mac & cheese pizza, I can honestly say I’ve never tasted better combos.

I highly recommend Pronta Pizzeria if you’re looking for a taste of Italian perfection! They’ve earned my stamp of approval as one of the best pizzerias in Indianapolis!

#5 Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

Upon walking in to this delicious dining establishment, I was warmly greeted and seated at a cozy booth. The ambience was inviting, with lively music playing throughout the room and tantalizing aromas of fresh dough and melted cheese coming from the kitchen.

The menu boasted an impressive selection of specialty pizzas – there was something for everyone! After much deliberation, I decided on the Inferno pizza with jalapenos, pepperoni, and extra hot sauce. This pizza did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crisp while still being fluffy; the sauce had a delightful kick; and all the ingredients were high-quality and distinctive in flavor. It’s easy to see why Jockamo is considered one of the best pizzerias in Indianapolis!

Other highlights include friendly waitstaff that go out of their way to make sure you’re having a great experience, prompt delivery service for when you don’t feel like going out, and a variety of non-pizza dishes if you’re feeling adventurous. All in all, it’s easy to see why Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is considered one of the best pizza restaurants in Indianapolis—they serve up amazing pies with unbeatable hospitality!

#6 Greek’s Pizzeria 16th Street

From the moment I stepped into this place, I was struck by its lovely atmosphere. The walls were lined with Greek artifacts, and the delicious smell of freshly-made pizza filled the restaurant. The staff was extremely hospitable, and my server was charismatic and knowledgeable about their menu.

When it came time to order, I decided on one of their signature pies – a Greek Special. It was a seafood-based pizza topped with olives and feta cheese. All these ingredients combined perfectly to create an explosion of flavors in my mouth! The crust was cooked to perfection and crisped nicely around the edges.

To top off this amazing meal, I had some homemade baklava for dessert – it was hands down the best baklava I’ve ever tasted! It truly put this pizza eatery over the top for me.

I would highly recommend Greek’s Pizzeria 16th Street for anyone looking for great pizza in Indianapolis – it’s definitely worth a try!

#7 Some Guys

The first thing that caught my eye when I stepped into Some Guys was the rich aroma of pizza dough cooking in the oven. I sat down, and a friendly server brought me a menu that featured a wide variety of classic pizzas as well as some unique options.

I decided to go with the Sicilian-style deep dish, and it definitely didn’t disappoint. The crust was perfectly cooked, crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside. Topping it off were delicious sausage and pepperoni slices, fresh mushrooms, onions, and zesty red sauce. This combination really set Some Guys apart from all other pizza places I’ve been to – I can honestly say their pizza is one of the best in Indianapolis!

Aside from the wonderful food, I was also impressed by the atmosphere at Some Guys. It’s cozy enough for a romantic date night but still lively enough for groups of friends to hang out – plus they have big screen TVs so you can watch your favorite team while you eat!

Overall, my experience at Some Guys was outstanding. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza in Indianapolis, look no further than Some Guys!

#8 Magoo’s California Pizza

The pizza here is truly unique; it’s a delicious combination of classic Italian flavors and distinct California style. It’s the perfect hybrid for all of your pizza cravings! Every bite is packed with flavor, and there are plenty of menu options to choose from.

The atmosphere of Magoo’s is also really fun. The staff is very friendly and welcoming – they even remembered my name after I visited the restaurant only once! Plus, their outdoor seating area offers an enjoyable view of Indianapolis.

For me, Magoo’s easily has the best pizza in Indianapolis. It tastes great, it looks great, and makes for an overall enjoyable experience – what more could you possibly want? Check out Magoo’s today – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Fishers!

#9 Greek’s Pizzeria

I stopped in on a whim and was surprised by how delicious their pies were. The crust was light and fluffy, just the way I like it, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The cheese and sauce were perfectly balanced, making for an unforgettable experience.

The service was great too! My server was friendly and attentive and made sure I had everything I needed throughout my meal. Plus, they offer a variety of beers to pair with your pizza so that you can make the most out of your meal.

If you’re ever in Indianapolis looking for the best pizza around, Greek’s Pizzeria should be at the top of your list for sure!

#10 Xtrordinary Pizza

I had the supreme pizza and it was absolutely divine. The crust was perfectly crunchy and the sauce had just the right amount of kick to it. Toppings were plentiful and flavorful, from pepperoni to jalapenos to olives. It was like a party in my mouth!

The cheese was absolutely delicious – shredded mozzarella with a hint of parmesan that made every bite better than the last. I can honestly say this is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

On top of all that, Xtrordinary Pizza offers generous portion sizes, so you’ll definitely get your money’s worth here. Service is also friendly and efficient, which makes dining at Xtrordinary an even more enjoyable experience.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Indianapolis (which you should be!), then look no further than Xtrordinary Pizza! You won’t be disappointed.

#11 Pasquale’s Pizza & Pasta

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, the aroma of baking pizza in the air was enough to make my mouth water. The staff greeted us warmly and were very helpful in making recommendations that suited our party’s tastes.

Speaking of which, the menu offers a wide variety of options, from classic pepperoni and cheese to more gourmet toppings like prosciutto and figs!

I had the pleasure of tasting many different pies. To name a few: The Four Seasons – A delicious combination of mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, pepperoni and sausage – was a hit at our table; the Margherita – simple but flavorful with fresh basil and garlic; and the Diavola – spicy Italian salami that gave it just the right kick!

But what truly impressed me was their Crust. It was light, fluffy yet crisp on the outside. Perfection! All these pizzas were made in wood-fired ovens for an authentic Italian experience.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Indianapolis then Pasquale’s Pizza & Pasta should be your first stop. With delicious options to choose from, wonderful customer service and quality ingredients all around – you won’t regret it!