Best Pizza in Indy (Updated Jan 2023)

(In the interest of full disclosure, I’m from Chicago and so have very high standards for pizza!)

But after eating my way through 11 pizza places in Indy, I’m ready to let you know who has the best slice in town. Spoiler alert: it’s definitely not what you’d expect!

I’m here to take you on a tour of Indianapolis’ most delicious pizza joints — with a few laughs along the way! This is going to be an entertaining adventure, and I hope you enjoy the ride as much as I did!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Futuro

I had the pleasure of visiting their restaurant recently, and I can confidently say that their pies are top-notch. The dough was perfectly cooked with a crunchy yet chewy texture. The sauce was incredibly flavorful and the cheese melted in my mouth. As for the toppings, they had an impressive array of options that each added something unique to the overall flavor. Everything about this pizza was phenomenal!

The atmosphere at Futuro is also special. It feels cozy and inviting, like you are sitting in someone’s family kitchen. The staff is friendly and it truly feels like they care about your experience. They are always happy to answer any questions you may have and will help make sure your meal is perfect!

My one wish would be that they offer more vegetarian options, but aside from that I’m a huge fan of this place. So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Indy, look no further than Futuro!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Greenwood!

#2 Last Chance Pizza

This pizza joint is a no-nonsense eatery with great taste in both the food and the décor. Its walls are adorned with prints of famous Italian dishes, while a menu featuring hand-tossed pizzas hangs right above the cash register. The topping choices are plentiful and creative, offering something for every palate.

The pies themselves are cooked in a brick oven to perfection. Every bite of their crust is crunchy and chewy, just like it should be. The cheese is always freshly grated and full of flavor, never greasy or soggy. Last Chance Pizza’s toppings are generous and the combinations of flavors offered make for an interesting mix that will excite any pizza enthusiast.

I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Last Chance Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Indy! They provide excellent service, great taste, and generous portions – all at a price that won’t break the bank. It’s definitely worth giving them a try for your next pizza night!

#3 Manhattan Pizzeria

The atmosphere is as inviting as the pizza is delicious. The restaurant itself looks homey and comfortable – not like it’s trying too hard to have some sort of upscale feel, which I appreciate. It’s perfect for a casual night out with friends or family.

The menu offers an array of different pizzas made from fresh ingredients, so there’s something for everyone. The crust was perfectly cooked and nicely crunchy, yet still fluffy on the inside. All the toppings were flavorful and melted together in a way that created an unforgettable combination of flavor and texture.

Speaking of flavor, the sauces were also amazing! They had a nice blend of sweetness and spiciness that added another layer to the pizza without overpowering it. And don’t forget about their special garlic-herb oil – it really takes their slices up a notch!

All in all, Manhattan Pizzeria truly deserves its title of having some of the best pizza in Indy – if not in the world! If you’re ever feeling hungry and looking for great food, this is definitely the place to go.

#4 Pronta Pizzeria

The crust is just the way it should be — thin, crispy, and full of flavor. The tomato sauce is rich and bold, while the cheese is just creamy enough that you won’t need any extra dipping sauces.

To top it all off, Pronta Pizzeria offers a wide variety of toppings to choose from. Whether you want pepperoni, mushrooms, or even pineapple (yes, pineapple on pizza!), they’ve got it!

Service wise, the staff are friendly and attentive. We never had to wait long for our orders and they always made sure we had enough drinks. Plus they have a great selection of beers that go perfectly with their pizzas.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Indy then Pronta Pizzeria should be your first choice!

#5 Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

I was delighted with the atmosphere of the pizzeria — it’s a hip, modern place and the décor is spot on. Plus, the staff are friendly and accommodating, and there’s usually a good crowd.

The pizza itself? I’d say it’s some of the best in town. They have all the classic Italian toppings and then some, from pepperoni to anchovies to artichoke hearts. And they make sure their crusts are crispy yet tender — no cardboard here! Plus, they have lots of vegetarian options too.

To top it off, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza offers a great selection of craft beers to accompany your meal, making it THE spot for pizza night!

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Indy, look no further than Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Some Guys

The staff at Some Guys welcome me with open arms, which was certainly a nice change from the other pizza places I’ve been to. The vibe of the restaurant was welcoming and friendly, so I knew I was in for a treat.

When it came time to order, I couldn’t decide what to get! The options were seemingly endless – they had so many delicious pizzas on their menu! After much debate (and drooling), I settled on their classic margherita pizza and let me tell you, it did not disappoint.

The crust was perfectly crisp and fluffy, yet still chewy and doughy. Topped off with fresh tomatoes, fragrant basil, melted mozzarella cheese and a generous drizzle of olive oil, this pizza was full of flavor. Combined with the cozy atmosphere of the restaurant – filled with the smell of freshly cooked dough – it felt like being back in Italy!

Overall, my experience at Some Guys was simply delightful – and made for one of the best pizzas I’ve had in Indy. If you’re ever in town and looking for a place to enjoy some seriously good pizza, then look no further than Some Guys!

#7 Greek’s Pizzeria 16th Street

My first bite of their signature 16th Street Special Pizza left me speechless. The combination of the perfect crust, mouth-watering toppings and just the right amount of cheese was enough to make me swoon. I was surprised by how the ingredients complemented each other and the overall flavor balance was spot on.

The service at Greek’s Pizzeria 16th Street is also top notch. The staff were friendly and helpful—they even gave me a few tips to help make my pizza experience even better! Plus, they have a great selection of craft beers on tap to compliment your meal.

In summary, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Indy then you won’t regret visiting Greek’s Pizzeria 16th Street—you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Magoo’s California Pizza

The first thing that struck me when walking into Magoo’s was the atmosphere – it was cozy and inviting, something that really adds to the pizza experience.

When it came time to order, I opted for their signature California Pizza. It was a classic combination of sausage, bell peppers, mushrooms, red onion and garlic – all perched atop a crispy thin crust. The ratio of toppings to crust was perfect and it was cooked to perfection! I could tell that all the ingredients were fresh with robust flavors.

But what truly makes Magoo’s stand out from the rest is the service. The staff are friendly and attentive, making sure that your experience is top notch.

Overall, my visit to Magoo’s California Pizza exceeded all my expectations – delicious pizza plus phenomenal service equals the best pizza in Indy!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Fishers!

#9 Greek’s Pizzeria

No exaggeration, I had the most wonderful pizza experience of my life at this place. From the moment I walked in, I was blown away by the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff.

The pizza itself was simply delicious. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and had a slight hint of garlic that made me keep coming back for more! The toppings were fresh and cooked to perfection – definitely not disappointing.

The entire time, the staff were attentive and made sure that our experience was enjoyable. They even let us sample some of the specials they have available so we could find something perfect for each of us.

In conclusion, if you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Indy, Greek’s Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out!

#10 Bazbeaux

The first thing that strikes you when you walk into Bazbeaux is the smell. It’s amazing – they must be doing something right! Then, you take a look at the menu and realize there is an abundance of options. From white pizza to BBQ chicken pizza and everything in between, there truly is something for everyone.

When I tried the Margherita pizza, I was impressed by the heavenly combination of flavors. The cheesy goodness paired with just enough tangy tomato sauce and fresh basil really made for an unforgettable experience. Not only did it taste great, but it was well-cooked too!

And not to forget the crust! It was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside – with just enough crunch to make every bite even more enjoyable.

To sum it up, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Indy, look no further than Bazbeaux!

#11 Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave.

The first thing that struck me upon entering the restaurant was the lively atmosphere and friendly staff. It also didn’t hurt that they’ve got an extensive selection of alcohol, including hard liquor, which made my visit even more enjoyable.

Speaking of food, Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave. offers an array of delicious pizzas, with vegetarian options available too! I personally went for a pepperoni-mushroom combo but they have something to satisfy everyone’s tastes. On top of that, you can finish off your meal with some tasty desserts.

The only downside I found at Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave was the lack of delivery options; however, it is a great tourist spot so this isn’t really a problem for most visitors!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Indy then head over to Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave. You won’t regret it!