Best Pizza in Midtown NY (Updated Jan 2023)

After scouring the area, I collected data on 11 local pizza places and tested them out. The good news is that all of the pizzas were delicious – but some definitely stood out more than others. Of course, tastes vary, so my goal is to give you a humorous yet lighthearted description of all 11 pizzas so you can decide for yourself which one suits your taste buds best!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Carnegie Pizza

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was immediately overwhelmed by the aroma of freshly-baked, cheesy pizza wafting through the air. As I took my first bite, I wasn’t disappointed – the perfectly cooked crust and perfectly balanced toppings made this one of the tastiest pies I’ve ever had.

The atmosphere of the restaurant was just as good as the pizza. Not only did they offer outdoor seating for those who want to enjoy their meal in the sun, but inside there’s a lively and cheerful atmosphere full of locals coming back for their favorite slices.

My overall experience at Carnegie Pizza was excellent. The pizza is some of the best in Midtown NY – it rivals even some of my favorite Italian spots abroad! If you’re looking for an amazing slice or two, Carnegie Pizza is definitely worth a visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!

#2 NY Pizza Suprema

The pizza here is nothing short of amazing. The crust is indulgently thin and crispy, but still chewy without being overly doughy. And the sauce? A perfect balance of sweet and savory with just the right amount of spice.

The toppings are fresh, too. Everything from classic pepperoni to unconventional delights like jalapeños and pineapple are accounted for. Oh, and don’t forget to try their specialty – the Big Apple!

To top it all off, the customer service was outstanding. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable, taking time to explain the restaurant’s history to us as well as recommend some great combos for our pies.

Overall, NY Pizza Suprema has some of the best pizza in Midtown NY – it’s well worth a visit!

#3 My Pie Pizzeria Romana

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with classic Italian music playing in the background. I decided to keep it simple and ordered their signature Margherita pizza. The thin crust was crunchy yet doughy at the same time, and the basil topping was fresh and fragrant. Even better than the taste was how generous they were with their cheese. It was literally dripping off my slice!

I thoroughly enjoyed my experience at My Pie Pizzeria Romana, so much so that I almost forgot to save room for dessert! Lucky for me, they offer a selection of delicious Italian Gelato flavors that were simply divine.

Overall, this place is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for the best pizza in Midtown NY!

#4 B Side Pizza Bar

The pizza at B Side Pizza Bar is simply divine. Their pizzas contain a perfect balance of crunchiness in the crust, along with a variety of different toppings to choose from. The Margherita pizza is especially delicious – you can taste the rich tomato and mozzarella flavors as soon as it hits your tongue!

The atmosphere at B Side Pizza Bar is also top-notch. It’s a cozy spot that can easily accommodate larger groups, so it’s great for gathering with friends or family to enjoy some quality time and amazing pizza. Additionally, they have an expansive selection of craft beers on tap that pair nicely with their mouth-watering pies.

All in all, I highly recommend B Side Pizza Bar for anyone looking to grab the best pizza in Midtown NY! You won’t be disappointed – I’m sure you’ll come back again and again!

#5 Stone Bridge Pizza & Salad

I’ve had a lot of great thin-crust pizzas in my time, but the crust here is something especially special. It’s almost as if it was made to perfection – with just the right amount of crunch from the oven and a lightness that could only come from fresh, local dough.

The toppings are equally impressive. They don’t skimp on quality ingredients and instead deliver generous amounts of flavorful toppings. The classic Margherita pizza is my absolute favorite; you can really taste the salty cheese and zesty sauce!

But Stone Bridge Pizza & Salad isn’t just about their delicious pies. Their salads are also surprisingly tasty. I love their Caprese salad, which has tomato slices, mozzarella balls, and basil leaves drizzled with extra-virgin olive oil and sea salt.

All in all, I give Stone Bridge Pizza & Salad two thumbs up! Best pizza in midtown NY? You betcha!

#6 Joe’s Pizza Broadway

The atmosphere is perfect for a pizza-lover like myself. The walls feature vintage posters and classic arcade games, which I think gives it a unique touch.

The star of the show however, is their pizza. Every bite had me wanting more! Freshly made dough with just the right amount of cheese and toppings – Joe’s Pizza Broadway knows exactly what they’re doing. I even enjoyed their special sauce as an added bonus.

If you want great pizza in Midtown NY, be sure to check out Joe’s Pizza Broadway – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Capizzi

The atmosphere is inviting, cozy, and reminiscent of a classic Italian pizzeria. The staff is friendly and the slice-selection is unrivaled. Whenever I’m in town, Capizzi’s is my go-to spot for a delicious slice.

The ingredients are top-notch. They use only the freshest tomatoes to make their marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese that melts like butter on your tongue. I’m salivating just thinking about it!

The crust has the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, and their signature “Capizza” pie is not to be missed — with generous slices of pepperoni tucked carefully into each layer of cheese (it almost looks like pizza art!).

All in all, Capizzi lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizza places in Midtown NY. If you’re ever looking for a great slice (or two) you can’t go wrong with this place!

#8 99 Cent Fresh Pizza

As soon as I stepped in, the smell of delicious cheese and sauce wafting through the air was enough to make my mouth water. The restaurant had a cozy feel to it with friendly staff and a great atmosphere.

The selection of pizzas on offer was impressive, with everything from classic margherita to gourmet creations like pesto and feta. I opted for their signature pepperoni-and-mushroom combination and I wasn’t disappointed – every bite was full of flavor!

I love that even though the pizza is delicious, it’s still budget-friendly – making it perfect for an indulgent night out or an affordable lunchtime treat. Best of all, they serve slices so you can get exactly the amount you want without any waste.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Midtown NY, head to 99 Cent Fresh Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in New York!

#9 Marta

The atmosphere was great, like a traditional Italian restaurant with an urban twist. The service was excellent and the staff were very accommodating.

But it was the pizza that won me over! The crust was perfectly crunchy, yet fluffy, and it had just the right amount of sauce and cheese. It was cooked to perfection in wood-burning ovens and had the proper ratio of ingredients for maximum flavor.

I tried their pepperoni pizza and it was out of this world! The combination of spices gave it a unique flavor that I haven’t tasted anywhere else. I also got a chance to try their white pizza with mushrooms, which was delicious as well.

All in all, Marta serves some of the best pizza in Midtown NY! If you’re ever in town, make sure to give them a try – you won’t regret it!

#10 99 Cent Fresh Pizza

The restaurant is small but inviting. I was immediately hit with the smells of delicious pizza and spices, which made my stomach grumble in anticipation.

I ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza, and it certainly did not disappoint! The crust was crisp and light, the sauce was perfectly balanced between sweet and spicy, and the cheese was super stretchy. It almost felt like they had put a little extra love into each slice.

The prices at 99 Cent Fresh Pizza may be cheap but you won’t find fresher or more delicious pizza anywhere else in Midtown. If you’re in the area looking for a great pizza experience, I highly recommend this place!

#11 Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

The atmosphere is inviting and cozy, with a great selection of beer and wine to pair with your pies. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, always willing to help with recommendations if you’re stuck for ideas.

My first visit was the classic Pepperoni Pie – it was delicious! The thin crust was nicely cooked and had that perfect New York style chewiness that I love in a pizza. Every bite was filled with flavor: the tomato sauce had just the right amount of garlic, oregano, basil and onions mixed in. And don’t even get me started on the cheese – it was divine!

On my second visit, I went for the Margherita Pizza – and wow, it did not disappoint! The basil added a nice zest to each slice after every bite.

Overall, Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza has some of the best pizza in Midtown NY – a must-have when in town!