Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Nassau County (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Nassau County (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

287 Views

I’ve been all over the world, tasting some of the best pizza around, and I thought it was finally time to see how Nassau County stacked up against other pizza-producing areas. So, I embarked on an impressive mission—taste-testing 12 of the best spots for pizza in Nassau County.

Throughout my journey, I experienced unique slices that ranged from traditional Italian-style pies to creative fusion pizzas. Each bite was more delicious than the last!

Come along with me as I share my recommendations for the absolute best pizza in Nassau County. Let’s get ready to drool!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Acqua e Farina Pizzeria

I arrived at the restaurant hesitant to expect too much, but my jaw dropped when I saw their wood-fired brick oven cranking out pizzas. The smell of delicious dough and melted cheese filled the air, and it was all I could do to contain my excitement.

The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the sauce had just the right level of sweetness. Topped with fresh mozzarella cheese and pepperoni, this pie was nothing short of amazing. All in all, it wasn’t a pizza—it was a work of art!

The service here is excellent; they make sure to check up on you regularly while you’re waiting for your pizza. Plus, they even have an outdoor area with a fire pit if you want to enjoy your dinner al fresco.

If you ever find yourself in Nassau County looking for a great pizza, look no further than Acqua e Farina Pizzeria—it’s definitely worth the stop!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Huntington!

#2 Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant

There’s a lot to love about Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant. The crust is crisp and full of flavor. The toppings are fresh and delicious. There’s a great variety of toppings to choose from, so everyone should be able to find something they like.

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting. You feel like you’re dining in someone’s home rather than a restaurant! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, always willing to answer any questions or make recommendations for what kind of pizza to get.

I have to say that my favorite feature of the restaurant is their wood-fired oven. It adds a smoky flavor to the pizza that I just can’t get enough of! I’ve also never been disappointed with the speed of service – it’s always speedy and efficient, no matter how busy they are.

Overall, if you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Nassau County, then you need to check out Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant! I highly recommend it – you won’t be disappointed!

#3 Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana

The atmosphere is nice and cozy, with wood-paneled walls and a genuine Italian feel. The food was amazing, especially the pizza. All of their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, and they have a great selection of toppings to choose from.

The pizza crust was flavorful and perfectly cooked – it reminded me of the pizza I had while in Naples. The flavors were balanced and delicious! They also offer a wide range of specialty pizzas that are truly unique, like the Hawaiian Pizza made with pineapples, prosciutto, and gorgonzola cheese.

I have to say that Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana has definitely lived up to its reputation as one of the best in Nassau County. If you’re looking for an authentic Italian experience, this is the place to go!

#4 Villa Milano

I visited Villa Milano not knowing what to expect, but I walked away with a full stomach and an even fuller appreciation for the delicious pizza that I had enjoyed. The crust was wonderfully thin and crispy – perfectly cooked! On top of that, there was an abundance of perfectly spiced sauce and delicious cheese, which combined together create an amazing flavor.

The atmosphere at Villa Milano is also worth noting. It’s very inviting – complete with dim lighting, cozy tables, and plenty of cozy seating. Not to mention the helpful staff who seemed genuinely happy to serve us some of the best pizza in the area.

In conclusion, I’m sure this isn’t my last visit to Villa Milano! If you’re looking for great pizza in Nassau County, then make sure you pay a visit here!

#5 Pat’s Family Pizzeria

I have to say, I was blown away by how delicious the pizza was. The crust was perfectly crisp, the cheese melted in just the right way, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It almost made me want to stay in Nassau County to eat Pat’s pizza every day!

As far as customer experience goes, I was welcomed with friendly smiles and warm hospitality. The staff were excited to show off their beloved pizzeria and were so proud of their craft that they were eager to answer any questions I had.

One thing that really sets Pat’s Family Pizzeria apart is their commitment to quality ingredients – they only use locally-sourced produce for their toppings and hand-kneaded dough for their crust. They also offer vegan and gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions. This is rare in a pizzeria; it really shows how much Pat’s cares about delivering an unforgettable pizza experience!

In conclusion, Pat’s Family Pizzeria is certainly the best pizza in Nassau County – it has earned my seal of approval and will be my go-to spot whenever I’m craving a slice!

#6 King Umberto

I’ll start off by saying the restaurant itself is quite unassuming. You could easily walk past it and not give it a second glance. But when I tell you the pizza is exceptional, you’ve gotta believe me!

The pizza itself is really great. It’s one of the best pizzas I’ve tasted in my life! The dough is thin and crispy and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. You can definitely taste a difference between their pizzas and your typical fast food chain pies. They also offer a wide selection of unique toppings so everyone can find something to satisfy their cravings.

The service at King Umberto is excellent as well. The staff is always polite and welcoming – they treat all customers with kindness and warmth which makes eating there more enjoyable.

Overall, King Umberto’s pizza definitely lives up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in Nassau County! If you’re ever in town, make sure you stop by for an unforgettable experience!

#7 Talluci’s Pizzeria

The pizza is always cooked to perfection, with a crispy crust and fresh toppings. Plus, they offer a great selection of specialty pizzas that you won’t find anywhere else – the Hawaiian BBQ is one of my favorites!

The atmosphere at Talluci’s is casual yet inviting. The staff are incredibly friendly, and they always make sure your dining experience is top-notch. I love how the kitchen staff dance to music while preparing your pizzas – it really adds to the enjoyable dining experience.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around Nassau County, Talluci’s Pizzeria is the place for you! Whether you’re a local or just visiting for a few days, this spot should definitely be on your radar.

#8 Pizzeria G

The second I stepped foot in the restaurant, I knew I was in for something special. The atmosphere was eclectic with a mix of modern and traditional Italian décor that made me feel like I had stepped right into Little Italy.

When it came time to order, I couldn’t decide which pizza to get! All of the options on the menu were mouthwatering and sounded delicious. I ended up settling on their classic Margherita pizza with some garlic bread as a side dish, and boy was it worth it!

The crust on the pizza was light and fluffy yet crispy all at once. The sauce was flavorful and not too sweet or acidic; just perfect! The cheese melted perfectly over the top and the fresh basil gave all of that flavor an added kick. And don’t even get me started about how amazing the garlic bread tasted – crunchy, cheesy garlic goodness with a hint of oregano!

I have been all around the world trying out different kinds of pizzas, but Pizzeria G has definitely served up one of (if not THE) best pizzas I’ve ever had in Nassau County. Make sure you come hungry because you won’t be able to put your fork down!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Deer Park!

#9 Taglio Pizza

The atmosphere is rustic and invigorating, with wooden tables and a coal-fired oven. The energy of the room is intoxicating – it’s like walking into an Italian pizzeria!

As for the pizza, it was thin-crusted perfection. A nice chewy crust that was both crunchy and chewy – the perfect mix. They excel at making different types of pizza, such as Sicilian style or classic Margherita, but my favorite was their taglio pie. It had a pesto base with fresh mozzarella and homemade sausage; definitely a winning combination.

I also enjoyed the variety of salads – they are all made with fresh vegetables and herbs from local farms, so you can be sure you’re getting quality ingredients in every bite.

It’s no wonder Taglio Pizza has become popular among locals – they serve some of the best pizza in Nassau County! If you’re looking for a great pizza spot, I highly recommend checking out Taglio Pizza.

#10 Di Carlo’s Pizzeria of Westbury

The minute I stepped through the door, I was hit with a wonderful smell of basil and oregano. The atmosphere was bustling, but not too loud – definitely conducive for conversation.

I started off my meal with a glass of red sangria which was sweet yet tart at the same time. As for the food, it did not disappoint. The classic margherita pizza had the proper balance between the tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese and the crust had just enough crunch to contrast the softness of toppings.

And then there were the slices! Di Carlo’s version was like nothing I had ever tasted before. The crust was perfectly thin, bubbly and chewy in all of the right places. Needless to say, I didn’t leave a single slice on my plate!

If you’re looking for some of THE best pizza Nassau County has to offer, then Di Carlo’s Pizzeria is where you should be heading! You won’t be disappointed!

#11 Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant

The restaurant is located in an unassuming strip mall, but don’t let that fool you because this place is serious when it comes to pizza. After making my way inside I was pleasantly surprised to find some of the best ingredients I’ve come across on my journey. The crust was cooked to perfection and the cheese was creamy, but not overwhelming.

The service was great too. Our waiter was personable and knowledgeable about the menu options, which made it easy to decide what we wanted. He even had plenty of interesting recommendations for us!

To top it off, Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant offers a selection of beers, wines and soft drinks to go with their amazing pizza. As someone who likes to travel around trying new places, I can honestly say this place is a must-try if you’re in Nassau County looking for a great slice!

#12 Riko’s Pizza

I must admit that I was a bit skeptical when walking into the restaurant. The atmosphere was somewhat plain and there weren’t many people inside, but then again, how crowded can a pizzeria really be at 1 in the morning? After taking a seat at the counter, I immediately noticed the large menu board behind me which was definitely promising.

I decided to go with their classic cheese pizza and it did not disappoint! The crust had an oven-baked texture that was crispy on the outside and slightly chewy on the inside. The cheesy topping was fantastic – it had just enough mozzarella cheese to provide a creamy texture without overpowering it. Plus, the sauce used had just enough spice to add some extra flavor without being too hot or overwhelming. All in all, it was one of the best slices of pizza I’ve ever eaten!

The staff at Riko’s Pizza were also incredibly friendly and helpful – they were happy to answer any questions I had about their menu items and provided lots of advice on what dishes would taste best together (hint: get two different styles!). And if that wasn’t enough, their prices are extremely reasonable for such high-quality food.

If you’re ever in Nassau County looking for great pizza, look no further than Riko’s Pizza – they serve up some of the best pies in town and won’t break your budget either!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant

When I first stepped into Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant, I immediately felt like I had been transported to a cozy little trattoria in the heart of Rome. The charming Italian atmosphere was almost enough to distract me from the mouthwatering smell of freshly baked pizza wafting from the kitchen. Almost.

Now let’s talk about the star of the show – the thin crust pizza. Oh, mama mia! The crust at Toskana is so thin, you could use it as a translucent sheet of paper, but trust me, you won’t want to waste it on any silly doodling. It’s the kind of crust that is crispy and light, yet sturdy enough to hold all of the flavorful toppings without collapsing like a tower of cards.

Speaking of toppings, Toskana has an impressive variety to choose from. Whether you’re a classic cheese lover or an adventurous gourmet seeking the wild combination of figs and prosciutto, they’ve got you covered. And let’s not forget about the cheese – they use only the finest mozzarella that stretches like nobody’s business.

But what really sets Toskana apart is their love and attention to detail. The chefs take their pizza-making duties very seriously, and it shows in every bite. They treat each pizza like a work of art, carefully crafting and curating the flavors to create a symphony of taste.

So, if you’re on the hunt for the best thin crust pizza in nassau county, look no further than Toskana Pizzeria Restaurant. Just be prepared to go back for seconds, thirds, and maybe even fourths. Mangia!