Best Pizza in Northwest AR (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve tasted pizza all over the world, so I wouldn’t say I’m an easy critic to please, but Northwest AR certainly didn’t disappoint. Of the 11 pizza joints I have visited in this area, there were some standouts that really hit the spot.

To make sure everyone can find their favorite type of pie, I divided them into categories like thin-crust and deep dish. And just for a bit of fun, I added ratings for the less-traditional toppings like macaroni in case you want to test your taste buds.

So read on to see who makes my list of the best pizza in Northwest AR!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arkansas

#1 Wicked Wood Fired Pizza

The atmosphere was incredibly inviting and cozy, with an open kitchen so you can watch the team of master pizza-makers as they craft their delicious pies. The crust is cooked to perfection in the wood fire oven – it’s thin and crispy, yet still manages to hold all that delicious toppings. And what toppings! There’s a huge selection, from classic pepperoni to veggie medleys, so everyone’s sure to leave satisfied.

The service was also outstanding – my waiter was helpful and courteous – he made sure I had everything I needed and knew exactly which pie to recommend.

But ultimately, it’s the pizza that seals the deal at Wicked Wood Fired Pizza. Everyone there could tell that this place takes great pride in their pizza-making process and it really shows through in its taste. I know for a fact that whenever I’m in Northwest AR, Wicked Wood Fired Pizza will always be my first choice for pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Bentonville!

#2 The Odd Soul

Not only does this place serve up authentic gourmet pizza, but they also serve alcohol! And not just beer, but an impressive array of hard liquor too. It’s the perfect spot to grab a bite with friends after work and catch the game on their big screen TVs.

The atmosphere of The Odd Soul is great and it attracts a diverse crowd of locals and tourists alike. It’s great for a night out or just to sample some delicious pizza and enjoy some craft beers!

The only downside? No delivery service. But for the best pizza in Northwest AR, I am more than willing to make the trip every time I’m craving that perfect pie!

#3 Tim’s Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and vibrant, and the staff were incredibly friendly. The decor was interesting, with some cool graffiti on the walls.

The pizza itself was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly crispy, the cheese was gooey, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. I had a delightful pepperoni pizza that kept me coming back for more!

On top of that, their prices are very reasonable. They offer great deals on combo meals too, so you can get a lot more food for your money than some other places in town.

I would highly recommend Tim’s Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Northwest AR!

#4 Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar

It’s a cozy little spot, perfect for a romantic dinner or a gathering of friends. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting with wood paneled walls and checkered tablecloths. The menu is full of delicious pizza pies, sandwiches, salads, and more.

The pizza here is absolutely divine! You can tell that the ingredients are top-notch – my favorite pizza was the Mediterranean-style pie topped with artichoke hearts, black olives, feta cheese and freshly grated Parmesan. It was light, airy and packed with flavor – an absolute delight! For those looking for something a bit heartier, there’s also the classic pepperoni and sausage slices as well as some creative concoctions like the BBQ Chicken Pizza.

The service was excellent – everyone from the host to our server went out of their way to make sure we had an enjoyable experience. And the prices were very reasonable; definitely worth every penny.

If you’re ever in Northwest AR and looking for the best pizza around, Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar won’t disappoint!

#5 Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville

Upon arriving the first thing I noticed were the unique and colorful decor. The walls where painted with some of the most vibrant and cheerful colors I’ve ever seen in a restaurant.

The menu had an array of choices to choose from, something for everyone’s taste. I decided to try their famous Mushroom Club pie, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! Every bite was unbelievably delicious, as every ingredient found its way into my mouth perfectly balanced.

The pizza crust was cooked to perfection, just the right amount of crispiness and chewiness that made this pizza all the more enjoyable. The topping selection was spot on too! Each topping tasted incredibly fresh, nothing that could have been sitting in the refrigerator for days like some places will do. The wait staff were friendly and attentive as well!

If you’re ever looking for a great pizza experience in Northwest AR, Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville is definitely the place to go! With its unique atmosphere and delicious pizzas, they are sure to satisfy any pizza lover’s cravings!

#6 Guido’s Pizza – Tontitown

When entering the restaurant, I instantly felt its quaint Tontitown charm. The staff was very friendly and welcoming and I knew I was in for a good experience while dining there.

One of the great things about Guido’s Pizza is that they offer alcoholic beverages. Whether you’re looking to have a beer or a glass of hard liquor, they’ve got it all! If you’re travelling with kids, they even offer an extensive kid’s menu, so everyone is happy. For those who prefer vegetarian options, Guido’s has plenty of choices.

On top of everything else, Guido’s Pizza also offers delicious desserts like homemade ice cream and cheesecake that were beyond amazing! As if all this wasn’t enough, the restaurant itself provides quite the tourist attraction for visitors to enjoy as well.

The only downside to this wonderful pizza place is that they don’t offer delivery services – only take-out and dine-in. Despite this minor setback, Guido’s Pizza – Tontitown still easily earns my highest recommendation!

#7 Geraldi’s

Upon arriving, the atmosphere was cozy and familiar; the staff was friendly and welcoming, so I immediately felt at home. The space itself is warm and inviting with classic Italian decor that really sets the mood for a great pizza experience.

The menu features a wide variety of pizzas from classic margherita to more unique combinations like “Tequila Lime Chicken” and “BBQ Pulled Pork”. I decided to try one of their specialty pizzas – the “Supreme Supreme” – and it was simply divine! It was loaded up with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and olives. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside yet still soft in the center. And the sauce? Oh my gosh! It truly made this pizza memorable; the perfect balance of tangy tomato flavor combined with garlic and oregano gave it an extra kick.

To top off what had already been an amazing pizza dining experience, we ended our meal with some incredibly tasty tiramisu. This dessert did not disappoint – fluffy layers of espresso-soaked sponge cake were sandwiched between freshly whipped cream and dusted with cocoa powder. To say it was delcious would be an understatement!

Overall, I’m confident that Geraldi’s is the best pizza in Northwest AR. If you’re ever in town looking for incredible Italian food, then be sure to check out this gem of a restaurant; you won’t regret it!

#8 MJ Pizzeria SPRINGDALE

My recent visit to this place was fantastic. I started off with an order of the delicious vegetarian pizza and it was outstanding. It tasted like it was fresh out of a wood-fired oven, and the toppings were incredibly flavorful.

Next, I tried their famous hard liquor selection. Not only did they have a variety of drinks to choose from, but they also paired each one with a special pizza topping to go with it – genius!

No review of MJ Pizzeria SPRINGDALE would be complete without mentioning their dessert options. To say they are insanely good is an understatement! The tiramisu alone was enough to make me want to return again soon.

The only downside is that there’s no delivery option here. But, considering all the other positives, such as the kid’s menu, it’s well worth getting in your car and heading over there for some tasty pies!

I highly recommend MJ Pizzeria SPRINGDALE for anyone looking for a great spot for lunch or dinner. And you won’t regret trying out their specialty cocktails paired with unique pizza toppings – trust me, you’ll love them!

If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Eureka Springs!

#9 The Rail – A Pizza Company

The atmosphere of this restaurant is really great. As soon as I walked in, I knew that the staff was dedicated to making sure that every customer had a wonderful experience. Plus, they offer alcoholic drinks, which can make it a perfect spot for relaxing after a long day.

I’m not a fan of having to physically go to a place to get my pizza, and The Rail – A Pizza Company does not offer delivery services. But the quality of the food and the remarkable hospitality more than makes up for this minor inconvenience. I was absolutely blown away by their unique selection of pizzas as well!

One thing I liked is that they have many different types of toppings and crusts available, so you can find something that interests you no matter your preferences. And if you have any dietary restrictions, they are sure to accommodate those as well. To top it all off, they even offer desserts which means you can complete your meal with something sweet and delicious!

Overall, I am thoroughly impressed with The Rail – A Pizza Company’s offering! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Northwest AR, then The Rail – A Pizza Company is definitely worth checking out!

#10 Wood Stone Craft Pizza

The moment I stepped foot into the joint, I could not help but notice the inviting atmosphere and delicious aromas emanating from the kitchen. My mouth began to water in anticipation.

I started off with their house specialty, the Wood Stone Pizza. It was cooked to perfection with a perfect crust and an abundance of toppings that bursted with flavor. The cheese was melted just right, and each ingredient was seasoned exquisitely.

For my second dish, I opted for the Featherton Farms Pizza. This time, I was treated to a multi-grain crust topped with locally sourced mushrooms, roasted peppers and creamy taleggio cheese. All of the ingredients blended together perfectly – creating a unique flavor that only Wood Stone Craft Pizza can provide!

Finally, I indulged in one of their amazing homemade desserts – the Key Lime Pie Pizza. It looked like a regular slice at first glance but had an alluringly sweet (and tart) surprise inside each bite!

Overall, Wood Stone Craft Pizza is undoubtedly one of the best places around to get pizza in Northwest AR. Whether you are looking for something classic or something a bit more adventurous – they have something for everyone!

#11 Mojo’s Pints & Pies

I was thoroughly impressed with my experience at Mojo’s. The atmosphere was casual yet inviting and the staff were friendly and knowledgeable.

I started off my meal with a few of their signature pies. The Margherita pizza was fantastic! It had the perfect balance of cheese, tomato, and basil – it was simply delicious. I also tried the Quattro Formaggi – a mixture of four different cheeses on a thin crust – which was equally as good.

When it came time for dessert, the Neapolitan pizza stole the show! This traditional Italian pizza is made from San Marzano tomatoes and Fior di Latte mozzarella. I could definitely taste the quality in every bite!

Overall, Mojo’s Pints & Pies has earned its title as having some of the best pizza in Northwest AR. If you’re ever in the area, make sure to stop by this wonderful restaurant for a slice or two (or three)!