Best Pizza in Nutley NJ (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve been all over the world and sampled pizzas from every continent, so I was excited to try out some of the local offerings in Nutley. And after a long weekend of research (i.e., eating lots and lots of pizza!) I think I’ve found the 11 best places for lovers of good pies.

I’ll tell you what to expect from each spot: everything from atmosphere to toppings and crusts. But be warned – this review is not for the faint-hearted; it’s full of humor, puns, and snarky comments! So get ready to discover your next favorite pizza place in Nutley!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza

I recently had the chance to visit Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza and sample some of their amazing pizza. Let me tell you, it was absolutely delicious!

The crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were incredibly flavorful. It certainly met my high standards for great pizza. The atmosphere was also quite pleasant, with a cozy and inviting vibe that made it easy to stay and enjoy a meal.

The service was also impeccable. Our waiter was extremely helpful and friendly, making sure we had just the right amount of food and that our drinks stayed full throughout the course of our meal. Plus, they offer free delivery so if you don’t feel like going out, you can have Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza come to you.

Overall, I think Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza is the best place for pizza in Nutley NJ. Every element from the atmosphere to the attentive service to most importantly-the great pizza makes this place stand out from all others!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Clifton!

#2 Queen Margherita Trattoria

The atmosphere of the restaurant sets you up for an unforgettable night of pizza. From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this place takes pride in their pizzas. The restaurant was bustling with people, and I could smell the mouth-watering aroma of fresh-baked pizza wafting through the air.

When it came time to order, I was not disappointed! They had a wide selection of delicious toppings and sauces that are sure to satisfy everyone’s taste buds. And when my pizza arrived, it was cooked to perfection – hot, crispy and bursting with flavor. I savored every single bite!

I can honestly say that Queen Margherita Trattoria has some of the best pizza in Nutley NJ! If you’re craving a slice (or two) then this is definitely the place to go!

#3 Alberto’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

The first thing that struck me as I entered was the smell—it was heavenly! The pizza, cooked to perfection in a classic stone-floor oven, had a delightful smoky flavor and delicious chewy crust. It wasn’t greasy like some pizzas, but it had all the flavor you could ask for.

The toppings were also top-notch; the pepperoni was flavorful and abundant and the cheese melted just right. I could tell they used high quality ingredients because everything tasted so fresh and tasty.

Overall, Alberto’s Restaurant & Pizzeria is definitely my top pick if you’re looking for the best pizza in Nutley NJ. They have amazing food, friendly staff, and competitive prices—what more could you ask for? Highly recommended!

#4 Taste of Tuscany – Clifton NJ

The restaurant’s atmosphere was cozy and inviting. The décor was reminiscent of Italy, without being too cliche.

But the real star of the show was their incredible pizza! The crust came out perfectly crisp and slightly charred on the edges– just like in Tuscany. And the sauce was made with high quality tomatoes that had been slow cooked to perfection. To top it off, their cheese selection included generous amounts of classic mozzarella with a hint of parmesan for extra flavor.

I even tried one of their unique specials: the ‘Amalfi’ pizza which is made from zucchini, mushrooms, prosciutto, and arugula! It was something I’d never tasted before, but I absolutely loved it!

All in all, my experience at Taste of Tuscany – Clifton NJ surpassed my expectations. I would highly recommend it to anyone in Nutley NJ looking for authentic Italian pizza made with top-notch ingredients!

#5 Bell Paese Deli Pizzeria and Trattoria

I arrived at Bell Paese with high expectations, after all, I had heard from some locals that their pizza was the best in Nutley. But I was still unprepared for the amazing feast that lay before me!

The first thing I noticed about Bell Paese’s pizza was the thin, crispy crust. Whenever I’m eating pizza, this is always my highest priority and it definitely didn’t disappoint. It was cooked to perfection and had just the right amount of crunch when I bit into it – they clearly take pride in making their crusts absolutely delicious!

The toppings at Bell Paese are also out of this world. They have a huge variety of classic Italian ingredients like pepperoni, mushrooms and mozzarella, as well as some unique options like buffalo chicken and banana peppers. Every topping was cooked perfectly, creating an incredibly flavorful combination that made me want to keep coming back for more!

This place has become one of my favorite spots to get a good slice of pizza. And after tasting a lot of pizzas around the world, I can confidently say that Bell Paese Deli Pizzeria and Trattoria has some of the best pizza in Nutley NJ!

#6 Luna Wood Fire Tavern

Their classic wood-oven pizza is cooked to perfection, with a lightly charred, crispy crust and a delicious topping selection. The service was great too – my waiter was friendly and quick to attend to my needs.

But what really sets this place apart is the unique taste of their signature pizzas. The ‘Luna Special’ is an award-winning masterpiece: prosciutto, arugula, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese atop a charred Neopolitan crust – simply divine! For dessert, I had the Nutella-stuffed calzone that was utterly delicious!

The atmosphere at Luna Wood Fire Tavern is top notch as well. With its cozy interior featuring rustic wooden tables, soft lighting and happy people everywhere it’s hard not to settle into the ambiance here.

Overall I had an incredible experience at Luna Wood Fire Tavern and would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for the best pizza in Nutley NJ.

#7 Algieri’s Pizza

The moment I stepped foot in the door of this cozy pizza joint I could tell it was the real deal. The smell of tomatoes, cheese, and spices filled the air and my mouth immediately started watering.

I was quickly seated at a table and handed a menu. The selection of items was outstanding! Not only did they have great classic pizzas like Pepperoni Pizza, but they also had heartier options like Calzones and Chicken Parmesan Pizza. Truly something for everyone.

Once I had made my choice, the pizza arrived and it was just as good as I had hoped it would be! Every single bite was bursting with flavor – it tasted homemade! The crust was fluffy yet crisp on the edges. The ingredients were all fresh and perfectly balanced with each other – no one flavor overpowered the others. Plus, Algieri’s sauce is truly unique – definitely the best I’ve ever had!

The service here is also top-notch. Everyone is friendly and attentive to your needs, ensuring that you have a pleasant dining experience.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Nutley NJ then Algieri’s Pizza is definitely where you should go! It’s definitely worth every penny (and maybe even another slice or two).

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Montclair!

#8 Ralph’s Pizzeria

The crust was perfectly crisp and the pizza sauce was so flavorful. I had a hard time deciding between the pepperoni and extra cheese, but eventually opted for both! The slices were large and amazing. I may have even eaten two slices instead of one… shh!

I also appreciate how friendly the staff is at Ralph’s Pizzeria. Everyone is always so helpful with anything you might need, from extra Parmesan to suggesting which toppings to choose next. Plus their servings are abundant; if you want pizza that lasts, then this is the place you need to go to!

If you’re in Nutley NJ and craving some delicious pizza, look no further than Ralph’s Pizzeria — it’s certainly my top pick for best pizza in town!

#9 Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven

The atmosphere at Ritacco Brothers was so welcoming that I immediately felt like a part of the family. The restaurant was packed with customers, which is always a good sign.

I decided to order one of the signature pizzas, and I have to say that it lived up to its reputation! It had a perfectly crisp crust, flavorful sauce, generous amounts of cheese and toppings, and just the right amount of seasoning.

The service was friendly and helpful as well. The staff went out of their way to make sure my experience was enjoyable – they explained all of the different toppings that were available, gave me advice on what type of pizza would be best for my taste buds, and even suggested some great pairings with it.

To sum it up, Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven is without a doubt one of the best pizzerias I’ve had the pleasure of visiting. If you’re in Nutley NJ, this should definitely be your go-to spot for some top-notch pies!

#10 Mamma Mia’s

I recently visited and was blown away by their delicious pies. The crust was thin, but not too thin – just the way I like it. As for the sauce, it was zesty and flavorful without being too overpowering. And don’t even get me started on the cheese! It had a sharp flavor to it that really elevated the overall taste of the pizza.

The main thing that surprised me about Mamma Mia’s is their topping selection. They had so many different options that I couldn’t even pick which one to go with! From traditional pepperoni to more adventurous varieties such as eggplant, there was something for everyone’s palate.

Overall, my experience at Mamma Mia’s was an absolute treat. Not only did they serve up some of the best pizza in Nutley NJ, but they also had exceptional customer service and friendly staff members who were always willing to help out. So if you ever find yourself in Nutley NJ, make sure you stop by Mamma Mia’s for a slice (or two) of their tasty pies!

#11 Pizza Village Cafe #2

This place is top notch. My personal favorite is the Chicken Parmigiana Pizza – a flavorful and unique combination of crispy chicken, mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce, and fresh basil. The flavors meld together perfectly to create an amazing pizza that’s incredibly hard to resist!

The crust is also delicious – it has just the right amount of crunchiness. Not too hard and not too soft. It’s baked in a wood-fired oven which imparts an extra layer of flavor to the pizza.

The service here was also some of the best I’ve ever experienced anywhere. Everyone was incredibly friendly and accommodating. They really made us feel at home, like part of their family.

All in all, this place is one of my top picks for the best pizza in Nutley NJ! If you haven’t been there yet – do yourself a favor and go! You won’t be disappointed!