Best Pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills (Updated Jan 2023)

During my visit I tasted 11 different pizzas from different pizza establishments, and now I’m ready to share my list of the best of the best with you! As a food critic, I take pizza seriously, but that doesn’t mean I don’t have a sense of humor. Join me as I share my lighthearted reviews of the 11 pizza places in Pittsburgh South Hills that serve the best slices around.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Santoro’s Pizzeria Italiana

At Santoro’s, they take classic Italian pizza to the next level. From their award-winning crust to their delicious house-made sauces, you won’t find a better combination. They also offer a great selection of toppings – from the usual suspects like pepperoni and sausage to more exotic choices like roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts and soppressata. No matter which topping you choose, you can be sure that it will taste great.

The atmosphere at Santoro’s is also perfect for any pizza lover looking for a unique and enjoyable experience. Inside the restaurant, guests are treated to lively Italian music and friendly waitstaff who go out of their way to make sure that everyone is happy with their meal. Plus, there’s an outdoor patio that’s perfect for enjoying a slice of pizza on a warm summer day.

If I had to sum up my experience at Santoro’s Pizzeria Italiana in one word, it would be “amazing”. This restaurant serves some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills – no doubt about it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#2 Fiori’s Pizzaria

The atmosphere was inviting, and I instantly felt welcomed as soon as I walked in. The restaurant has such a cozy, classic feel with its Italian decor. I’m sure tourists will enjoy the experience that Fiori’s provides.

As for the food, everything was amazing! The pizza crusts were perfectly crisp on the outside, yet fluffy on the inside. The ingredients were also fresh and flavorful – from the simple mozzarella and tomato sauce to more complex pies topped with pepperoni, sausage, and vegetables.

One downside of Fiori’s is that they don’t offer delivery. But for me, it was worth it to get out of the house and enjoy a nice meal here! It reminded me so much of my days spent in Italy.

So if you are looking for the best pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills – look no further than Fiori’s Pizzaria!

#3 Crust! Café and Pizzeria

First off, the atmosphere was so inviting and cozy. The staff was friendly and helpful, which made ordering a breeze. Plus, they had great music playing in the background to keep everyone relaxed.

The pizzas here are some of the best I have ever had! There is something for everyone on the menu – from classic Italian favorites like Margherita to fun toppings like gorgonzola and figs. Each pizza is cooked to perfection with a crispy crust that has just the right amount of crunch. The flavor combinations are delightful, making it hard to pick just one favorite!

I also recommend trying their salads – they’re incredibly fresh and full of flavor. And don’t forget about dessert! Their homemade cannoli is sinfully delicious.

In conclusion, Crust! Cafe and Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills! If you’re looking for a place that serves amazing food in an inviting atmosphere, this is your spot. Give it a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 J B’s Pizza Place

When I first stepped into the restaurant, I immediately noticed the aroma of freshly baked pizza and it felt like an old Italian pizzeria. The decor was full of classic Italian vibes, which put me in the right mindset to indulge in some delicious pizza.

The menu offered a great selection of pizzas made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. I opted for their signature dish – a spinach and mushroom pizza – and it didn’t disappoint! The crust was nice and thin but still sturdy enough to hold the generous amounts of toppings. And the flavor combination was amazing, with just the right balance of sweetness from the mushrooms, tanginess from the tomatoes, and saltiness from the cheese.

Overall, my experience at J B’s Pizza Place was unforgettable! From the classic Italian atmosphere to their flavorful dishes made with fresh ingredients, this restaurant is truly worth a visit if you’re looking for some of Pittsburgh South Hills’ best pizza.

#5 Badamo’s Pizza – Mt. Lebanon

When I arrived at Badamo’s, the first thing that caught my eye was the enormous brick oven. It was clear that they take their pizza seriously here. After being welcomed by a friendly and knowledgeable staff member, it was time to dive in and try some of their signature creations.

I started with their Margherita pizza which had an amazing chewy crust and just the right amount of tomato and basil topping. For my next pie, I went with their ‘White Pie’ which featured mushrooms, garlic and mozzarella cheese – all cooked in an incredible creamy white sauce. The blend of ingredients created an out-of-this-world flavor combination that made this one of the best pies I’ve ever tasted!

All in all, my experience at Badamo’s Pizza – Mt. Lebanon was nothing short of incredible. If you’re ever looking for great pizza in the Pittsburgh South Hills area, make sure to add Badamo’s to your list! You won’t be disappointed!

#6 Bellisario’s Pizza Palace

From the moment I stepped in, it was obvious that this place takes their pizza seriously. The kitchen was filled with a delightful aroma of freshly-baked pizza, and the staff went out of their way to ensure that my experience was top-notch.

The menu offered a wide variety of pizzas, from classic favorites to unique and interesting creations. I opted for their signature Grandma Pie and it did not disappoint! It was cooked to perfection with a thin, crispy crust and just the right ratio of sauce and cheese. Everyone who joined me for dinner agreed that the flavors were incredible!

In addition to great pizza, Bellisario’s Pizza Palace offers delicious sides and desserts. The garlic knots were especially tasty! The staff also took great care when serving our drinks—they had excellent recommendations on Italian wines to pair with our meals.

The atmosphere at Bellisario’s Pizza Palace is warm and inviting, making it perfect for families or friends looking to enjoy some quality time together over some great food. From start to finish my experience here was fantastic—I’d highly recommend them for anyone looking for the best pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills!

#7 Jimmy Z’s Pizza South Hills

It’s no wonder why this place is always packed with customers. The atmosphere is really lively, the staff are friendly and helpful, and the pizza is simply to die for! I had the classic margherita pizza and it was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted. The tomato sauce was flavorful and the cheese was perfectly melted – not too much, not too little.

But what makes Jimmy Z’s so special is their attention to detail. Everything about their pizzas seems to have been crafted with perfection in mind – from the ingredients used to make the crust to their unique toppings. I also love how they let you choose from different types of sauces so you can fully customize your pizza experience!

All in all, Jimmy Z’s Pizza South Hills truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in town! If you haven’t tried it yet, then I highly recommend checking it out as soon as possible – trust me, you won’t regret it!

#8 Donte’s Pizzeria

I went in expecting the same old greasy, tasteless pizzas that I’m used to getting here in Pittsburgh, but boy was I wrong. Donte’s Pizzeria is a cut above the rest! The pizza was amazing – it was cooked to perfection and really had a unique flavor that you just can’t find anywhere else.

The atmosphere at Donte’s Pizzeria is also pretty great. Although there isn’t an actual sitting area, it still felt welcoming and comfortable for a take-out or delivery restaurant. Plus, the staff was incredibly friendly and helpful when I asked questions about their pizza selections.

My only complaint (if you can call it that) is that they don’t have any other food items aside from pizza – so if you’re looking for something different than pizza, this probably isn’t the place for you.

But all in all, if you’re looking for amazing pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills, look no further than Donte’s Pizzeria – trust me; you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#9 Beto’s Pizza

The atmosphere is great–it’s warm, inviting, and there’s always a smile on the face of the owner, Beto. The pizza itself is truly mouth-watering. I had the cheese pizza, which was loaded with delicious mozzarella cheese, sprinkled with seasoning and topped with freshly grated parmesan. It almost felt like I was in Italy!

On top of having great pizza, Beto also offers some unique toppings that you won’t find anywhere else in town. Some of my favorites were the chorizo and jalapeno combo and the goat cheese and roasted garlic option. They really take taste to a whole new level!

To top it all off, their prices are very reasonable and they only use fresh ingredients. What more could you ask for?! All in all, I’d say you can’t go wrong with choosing Beto’s Pizza for your next night out or dinner delivery choice—it was truly one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time!

#10 The Other Place

I love the atmosphere of this joint. The walls are covered with Pittsburgh sports memorabilia so it feels like a home away from home. The staff are super friendly and they take the time to get to know their customers, which I think is very important.

The pizzas here are simply amazing, the crusts have been cooked to perfection every single time I’ve visited and the toppings are always fresh and flavourful. You can also create your own pizza if that’s what you’re looking for. They offer all sorts of unique combinations that you won’t find at other places in the area.

Overall, The Other Place has become my go-to spot when I’m in town looking for a tasty pizza. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills then this is definitely the place to go!

#11 Carbonara’s

The place is a great tourist spot. It has a decent selection of alcohol (including hard liquor), so that adds a nice touch for any adults in the party. There’s also a kid’s menu, so it makes it easy to bring the whole family without worry about what everyone will eat. Vegetarians also have some options, which is great.

Finally, the icing on the cake (or should I say the parmesan cheese on top?) is their insanely good dessert menu. Trust me, you’ll have to pace yourself to save room for that after dinner treat!

Unfortunately, there is one small downside – Carbonara’s doesn’t offer delivery service. So if you’re looking for pizza to be delivered straight to your door, you won’t find it here.

Bottom line: Carbonara’s is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for the best pizza in Pittsburgh South Hills!