Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Stratford CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in Stratford CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

98 Views

After weeks of trying different places, I’ve narrowed down my list to the 12 best pizza spots in Stratford. With each slice, I could taste the hard work put into making a delicious, perfectly balanced pizza that would satisfy any craving.

Every restaurant has something unique to offer and it was tough to pick my favorites! But after eating hundreds of slices, I’m ready to share with you my picks for the best pizza in Stratford. Prepare your tastebuds because this journey is gonna’ be fun!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Star Pizza Restaurant

The atmosphere alone was enough to make me want to stay a while. Soft music played over the speakers, with cozy booths for couples and large tables for families. The wait staff were friendly and eager to answer any questions I had about their menu items.

But when it came time to get down to business and taste the pizza, I wasn’t disappointed! The crust was delicious – not too thick or thin – and the sauce had just the right amount of spice and sweetness. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, with all sorts of interesting combinations available.

All in all, if you’re ever in Stratford CT looking for great pizza, look no further than Star Pizza Restaurant! Their pizza is sure to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters. I can easily say it’s some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Milford!

#2 The Parlor

I have to admit, this place really exceeded my expectations. From the mouthwatering aroma of the freshly made dough and zesty tomato sauce wafting out of the door, to the cheerful atmosphere and friendly staff, The Parlor is truly a unique pizza parlor.

The pizzas themselves are something to behold. Each one comes out piping hot with just the right amount of cheese and your choice of toppings. I was particularly impressed with their wide selection of vegetarian options; they really cater to everyone! You can also customize your order if you’re feeling adventurous – double cheese, extra toppings, even side dishes like garlic knots or stuffed mushrooms.

I’m honestly blown away by how delicious The Parlor’s pizza is – it’s some of the best I’ve ever had in my life! Not only that, but it’s amazingly affordable too. They offer great prices on individual slices as well as whole pies, so you can get quality food at an unbeatable price.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stratford CT, look no further than The Parlor. From its friendly staff to its delicious food, this place has something for everyone!

#3 Papa’s Pizza & Pasta

Upon arriving at my destination, I couldn’t help but notice the warm and inviting atmosphere that welcomed me to this pizzeria. The service was impeccable – the staff was attentive, friendly and knowledgeable about their menu items.

The pizza itself was outstanding! The dough was light and airy with a slight crunch from baking in their brick ovens. On top of that, the ingredients were fresh and flavorful. This wasn’t just any ol’ pizza; this was gourmet quality! They also offer an extensive selection of pasta dishes if pizza isn’t your thing.

Overall, I give Papa’s Pizza & Pasta five stars for being one of the best spots for grabbing a slice in Stratford CT! Highly recommended if you’re ever visiting the town.

#4 Delizioso Brick Oven Pizza

The crust was truly out of this world – it was thin, but still held its shape against the generous toppings. The sauce was flavorful and just the right amount of sweet and tangy. As for the cheese, it was gooey perfection!

But that’s not all. The cooks at Delizioso take their pizza making seriously – each artfully crafted pie is made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in a brick oven imported from Italy.

I simply must recommend Delizioso Brick Oven Pizza if you’re looking for the best pizza in Stratford CT. They use only the finest ingredients to ensure each slice is delicious! And don’t forget to order one of their special pies like “The Finocchio” or “The Scarpariello” – they are absolute must-haves!

#5 Juliano’s Pizza Restaurant

As soon as I walked in, I could smell the deliciousness of their perfectly cooked pizzas. They have an extensive menu full of Italian favorites like cheese and sausage pizza, pepperoni lovers’ pies, and vegetarian options like their zucchini & tomato slices.

The service was top-notch and friendly. Every time I visited, my order was taken quickly and my pizza delivered fresh and hot to my table. The staff always made sure I had a pleasant experience, which is something very important to me when it comes to dining out.

When it comes to flavor and toppings, Juliano’s Pizza Restaurant definitely knows what they’re doing! Every bite of my slices was a heavenly delight! Their homemade dough was delicate yet crunchy and the sauce had just the right amount of seasoning — not too sweet, but still with enough flavor to make me want to savor every single bite!

To sum it up: Juliano’s Pizza Restaurant offers some of the best pizza in Stratford CT no doubt about it! From their impeccable customer service to their flavorful toppings– this restaurant is sure to leave you feeling satisfied after every visit!

#6 Paradise Pizza Restaurant

I was instantly impressed with the rustic, cozy atmosphere of the restaurant. I was welcomed in by attentive staff and its “page-turner” owner, who created a wonderful experience for first time patrons.

The pizza itself? It’s out of this world! From their classic Margherita to their traditional pepperoni option, every bite was packed with delicious flavor. The crust was light, airy and just had the right amount of crispiness – it was as if they mastered how to combine all the elements of perfect pizza making!

Not to mention they also had some specialty items like cheesy garlic bread appetizers and calzones filled with mouthwatering ingredients.

To sum it up, Paradise Pizza Restaurant is a must visit for anyone looking for the best pizza in Stratford CT! Their quality ingredients combined with their attention to detail make them an easy choice when it comes pizza cravings. Good Job Paradise Pizza Restaurant!

#7 Dal Mare Pizzeria

I have to admit that I was skeptic at first, as Stratford isn’t necessarily known for its pizza. But I’m glad I decided to give them a chance. From the first bite, it was clear that they knew how to make pizza!

The dough was made with care and was cooked to perfection – crisp on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The sauce had a nice balance of sweetness and acidity, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful – especially their signature pepperoni.

Plus, their service is top-notch! The staff greeted me warmly and made sure my meal went smoothly from start to finish. It’s easy to see why Dal Mare Pizzeria has been in business for over 20 years – they understand quality!

If you’re looking for authentic Italian pizza in Stratford CT, look no further than Dal Mare Pizzeria. Their pizza is some of the best I’ve had anywhere in the world!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Fairfield!

#8 Spartan Pizza

From the moment I stepped in, I felt like an honored guest. The classic Italian-inspired decor gave me a sense of nostalgia and made me want to stay for even longer.

The menu was packed with unique options, from the traditional Margherita to a delicious meat-lovers special. After much deliberation, I finally decided on the classic cheese pizza, and it did not disappoint! The crust was thin and chewy, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese melted perfectly.

The ambience at Spartan Pizza was also fantastic – it definitely has an Italian pizzeria vibe going on. On top of that, the staff were very friendly – they were attentive to my needs throughout my visit and really made me feel like part of the family.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stratford CT, then look no further than Spartan Pizza! From its delicious pizzas to its warm atmosphere, Spartan Pizza is sure to please!

#9 Di Roma’s Pizzeria of Stratford,Connecticut

The atmosphere of this restaurant was truly delightful. There were cozy leather booths, vibrant paintings on the walls, and even a vintage jukebox playing old-timey tunes.

The pizzas here are simply exquisite. They have an amazing variety of classic and specialty pizzas, all cooked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens. I had the Quattro Formaggi pizza with artichokes and it really hit the spot! The mix of cheeses and the smoky flavor from the oven were delicious.

The service at Di Roma’s is top notch as well. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful throughout our meal. Plus, they had a great selection of local beers to pair with our pizza!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stratford CT then look no further than Di Roma’s Pizzeria!

#10 Salerno’s Apizza

The moment I stepped into this charming and cozy restaurant it was clear that they take pizza seriously. The wood-fired oven is in plain sight, proudly displaying the authentic Italian technique of cooking a true Neapolitan style pie.

I ordered their classic Margherita, and boy oh boy was it delicious! The light and airy crust tasted like it had just been pulled from the oven, but still managed to have a nice crisp on the outside. The tomatoes were sweet and fragrant, with gooey, melted mozzarella cheese cascading down the sides. It’s no wonder why Salerno’s Apizza has won awards for best pizza in Stratford CT – this place knows what they’re doing!

Overall, my experience at Salerno’s Apizza was out of this world. If you’re in Stratford CT looking for an amazing gourmet pizza experience, you won’t be disappointed if you choose Salerno’s Apizza. I’ve never been more satisfied with a slice of pizza, and I would definitely give them 5 stars!

#11 La Fortuna Bar & Restaurant

I was so impressed with the quality of their ingredients and the skillful hands of their chefs! The crust had a perfect texture that was both airy and crunchy, while the cheese was gooey yet not greasy. I especially enjoyed the generous portions of vegetables added to my pizza. Not only did they look great on the plate, but they gave each bite an extra layer of flavor.

And then there was the service… it felt like I had been welcomed into a family restaurant! They were prompt and friendly as they served up my pizza, and always made sure I had everything I needed.

Overall, La Fortuna Bar & Restaurant is one of the best places in Stratford CT for pizza lovers! The quality of the ingredients, cooking techniques, and customer service make this spot one to remember. With thin crusts, fresh toppings, and generous helpings – you won’t be disappointed when you take a seat at La Fortuna Bar & Restaurant!

#12 Big Jim’s Galley

The atmosphere is lively and upbeat, with jovial waiters and chefs running around to make sure everyone in the restaurant is well fed. The pizza is made with fresh ingredients—I could tell that it wasn’t just some reheated frozen pizza.

My favorite was the Big Jim’s Supreme—it had everything a pizza should have: pepperoni, olives, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and Italian sausage. It was cooked to perfection: crispy edges but still a soft almost pillow-like center. The sauce was tangy and sweet with just enough spice to keep you wanting more.

And let’s not forget about the cheese—it was gooey and creamy with every bite!

Overall I’d highly recommend Big Jim’s Galley if you’re looking for the best pizza in Stratford CT!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Stratford Fairfield Pizza

Walking into Stratford Fairfield Pizza feels like stepping into pizza paradise. The aroma wafting through the air is enough to make any carb lover weak at the knees. The walls are adorned with photos of pizza slices from every corner of the world. I could practically hear the dough whispering, Eat me, Edward! And so, I did.

The thin crust at Stratford Fairfield Pizza is like a work of art. It’s as thin as a supermodel’s waistline, yet sturdy enough to hold an impressive amount of toppings. The cheese stretches like a rubber band when you take a bite, creating that epic cheese pull we all know and love. I swear, if Michelangelo were alive today, he would’ve spent his days sculpting pizza crusts instead of marble.

The menu is like a dream come true for any pizza lover. From classic Margherita to inventive creations like the BBQ chicken with pineapple, there’s a pizza for every taste bud. I even spotted a pizza topped with mac and cheese. Yes, you heard me right. It’s the perfect marriage of cheesy goodness and carb overload. I would marry that pizza if I could.

The staff at Stratford Fairfield Pizza are a hoot. They make you feel right at home, joking and bantering while tossing dough in the air. It’s like watching a comedy show and a cooking demonstration all at once. You can’t help but smile as they expertly maneuver the pizza peels like a magician with his wand.

So, if you’re like me and have a serious case of pizza obsession, run, don’t walk, to Stratford Fairfield Pizza. You won’t be disappointed. And if you see a guy named Edward shoveling down a whole pizza by himself, that’s me. Just wave, and maybe even challenge me to a pizza eating contest. Let’s see if Stratford Fairfield Pizza’s thin crust can stand up to my insatiable appetite.