Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Mass (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Massachusetts

Best Pizza in Mass (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

212 Views

I’ve been all around the world, tasting some of the best pizza imaginable and making sure I got a slice of it (literally). So, you can imagine how thrilled I was when I set out to find the twelve best pizza places in Mass.

I took my time trying each one and wrote down all my impressions. What ensued was a hilarious journey that tested not only my knowledge of great pizza but also my palate’s ability to take in all that flavor!

From traditional Neapolitan pies to thick-crust Sicilian-style creations, come join me as we explore the twelve best pizzas in Mass.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Massachusetts

#1 Jinny’s Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew it was something special. The walls were covered with pictures of their famous pizzas and the staff had smiles on their faces. It felt like a warm welcome.

Once I sat down at my table, I was blown away by their menu. They had so many different kinds of pizza to choose from – thin crust, deep dish, stuffed crust and gluten-free options! After much deliberation, I decided on the classic pepperoni pizza. It was delicious – the perfect combination of crunchy dough, flavorful sauce and succulent pepperonis.

The service at Jinny’s Pizzeria was top notch – friendly and attentive without being intrusive. My drink glass was never empty and the staff was happy to answer any questions about the pizzas.

In short, Jinny’s Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Mass! If you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by for a slice or two – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Newton Corner!

#2 Galleria Umberto

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew this place was special. The decor is quaint and cozy – perfect for a romantic night out, or for grabbing a pizza with friends. And speaking of friends, thankfully Galleria Umberto serves alcohol!

My friends and I ordered up several pies, and were not disappointed. The thin-crust pizzas were loaded with flavor – a perfect combination of sauce, cheese and just the right amount of tangy topping. My mouth is watering just thinking about it!

However, one downside to Galleria Umberto is that they don’t deliver – so you’ll have to come in if you want to try the deliciousness yourself. Fortunately though, it’s such an ideal spot for tourists that it’s well worth a visit!

All in all Galleria Umberto deserves serious consideration when searching for the best pizza in Boston MA. You won’t be disappointed!

#3 Ciao! Pizza and Pasta

I visited on a Tuesday night, and the atmosphere was surprisingly lively. The restaurant had great music playing and the scent of bubbling cheese in the air.

The food was fantastic, with some really unique options for vegetarians as well as classic Italian dishes. I particularly loved their house-made pizza; it was cooked to perfection, with crusty edges and a crispy yet chewy center. It was topped with generous amounts of fresh veggies, meats and cheeses; my tastebuds were in heaven!

On top of that, I found out that they serve alcohol too! It was nice to enjoy a cold beer while eating my pizza. And when I felt like having something sweet after dinner, they also offered some delicious desserts that definitely hit the spot.

My only negative thought about Ciao! Pizza and Pasta is that they don’t offer delivery services. But if you’re willing to make a short drive, it’s more than worth it – especially considering how reasonable their prices are!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Mass, look no further than Ciao! Pizza and Pasta – your taste buds will thank you later.

#4 FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca

I have heard many great things about this small eatery, located in the North End, and decided to try it for myself. Upon arriving, I was surprised at the quaint yet inviting atmosphere that the restaurant had to offer. Once I was seated, the smells from the brick ovens filled the air with a tantalizing aroma that had my mouth watering.

The staff was incredibly friendly and very knowledgeable about their dishes, which is always a welcomed sight. After much deliberation, I finally settled on their classic Margherita pizza and let me tell you – it did not disappoint! Crispy thin crust topped with fresh mozzarella and tomatoes were cooked to perfection in their brick ovens giving each bite an unforgettable flavor.

All in all, FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca offers some of the best pizza in Boston MA (and maybe even the world)! The atmosphere and staff are top-notch, making any visit here truly special. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack or a romantic evening meal, this establishment has it all!

#5 Pizzeria Rustico

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was impressed. The atmosphere was warm, inviting and the staff were friendly and always eager to answer my questions.

The pizza here is truly incredible – it’s cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving it a unique flavor that you won’t find elsewhere. The ingredients are top notch too, with an ever-changing array of toppings available to choose from. My favorite is their ‘Mushroom Delight’, which is topped with mushrooms, sweet peppers, mozzarella and anchovies!

I also sampled some of their appetizers, including the stuffed peppers and garlic knots – these were both delicious as well!

Overall, Pizzeria Rustico has really impressed me – if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Boston MA then look no further than this place!

#6 Lily’s Pizza

The atmosphere is fun and inviting, with a rustic charm that can be felt from the moment you step in the door. The menu offers a variety of authentic pizzas, from margheritas to gourmet creations like eggplant parmigiana. For a food critic, it was hard to choose just one!

The pizzas here are famous for their perfectly-crafted crusts that are perfectly charred in the wood-fired oven. The toppings are fresh and delicious and the flavor combinations are out of this world! Every bite left us wanting more. Plus, they offer some unique options like their signature House Special Pizza which makes me revisit each time I’m in town.

But my favorite thing about Lily’s Pizza is their amazing staff! Everyone who works there has an infectious energy that truly makes it an enjoyable experience – they make sure you feel welcome and appreciated as soon as you walk in.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Boston MA, don’t miss the chance to visit Lily’s Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#7 Max and Leo’s Pizza Newton

Upon my first visit to this small, unassuming pizzeria, I immediately felt welcomed. The warm atmosphere and friendly staff put me instantly at ease and made me excited to try the pizza.

Once I got down to business, it was clear why Max and Leo’s Pizza Newton is considered one of the best in Mass. From the fluffy crust, to the generous portions of cheese, it was truly a delight for the taste buds. The sauce was tangy yet sweet, with just enough spice to keep things interesting. Every bite was heavenly!

The selection of toppings was also impressive; they had everything from pepperoni and olives, to pineapple and artichoke hearts. I highly recommend giving them a try if you’re looking for something that’s both indulgent and unique.

Overall, Max and Leo’s Pizza Newton is definitely worth a visit, no matter what kind of pizza fan you are! With its delicious flavors and inviting atmosphere, it won’t take long for you to become a regular here. Best pizza in Mass? You bet!

#8 Regina Pizzeria

The moment I stepped in, the smell of fresh dough and melted cheese wafted through the air, making my mouth water. The owners immediately welcomed me and I knew I was in for a great experience.

I decided to sample their classic Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The combination of flavors—salty, sweet, savory—was perfection. The crust was the perfect balance between crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. And how could I forget about the cheese? It was so creamy that it simply melted in my mouth.

In addition to the delicious food, Regina Pizzeria also offers a cozy atmosphere with warm decor. And as an added bonus, they have a wide selection of craft beers to pair up with a slice or two of pizza – just what this weary food critic needs after so much traveling!

If someone asked me where to go for some of the best pizza in Boston MA, without hesitation I’d tell them to go to Regina Pizzeria!

#9 Picco

From the moment I stepped in the door, I was impressed. The décor is classy and cozy – it made me feel like I was part of the family. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable – they answered all my questions about their pies in no time!

The menu has a great selection of pizzas, from classic margherita to more creative topping combinations. My personal favorite was the Sicilian sausage and spinach pizza – the sweet fennel sausage brought out the sweetness of the red sauce, while the spinach added a nice touch of green to balance everything out.

Plus, you can’t beat their wine list. They carry some excellent Italian wines that pair perfectly with their pies.

All in all, Picco’s is living up to its reputation as one of Boston MA’s best pizzerias. Whether you’re looking for a quick weekday dinner or a special occasion night out, you won’t be disappointed by Picco’s delicious creations!

#10 Ernesto’s Pizza

My first impression of this establishment was how inviting the atmosphere was. Upon entering, I was welcomed with a relaxed Italian vibe and live music playing in the background. I knew I had come to the right place for pizza!

The menu at Ernesto’s Pizza had so many options that it was hard to choose just one slice. After much deliberation, I eventually decided on a classic cheese pizza, which blew me away. The dough was cooked to perfection and the flavors combined together perfectly. There were also generous portions of high-quality ingredients in every bite – no skimping here!

But that’s not all: Ernesto’s Pizza also has a delicious selection of sandwiches and salads available too! Although they do not have dessert options, they more than make up for it with their wood-fired pizzas. And don’t forget about their craft beers, which perfectly complement any meal you order there.

Overall my experience at Ernesto’s Pizza was top notch. They managed to deliver amazing food quality that made me feel like I had stepped into an Italian restaurant in Rome. This is definitely some of the best pizza in Boston MA – two thumbs up from this highly satisfied customer!

#11 Locale

First of all, the atmosphere is simply delightful. The cozy interior and brick ovens give it a welcoming vibe that’s perfect for a leisurely night out. And to top it off, the staff was incredibly friendly.

When it comes to the food, they really knocked it out of the park. Their classic margherita pizza was amazing – the crust was perfectly crispy yet light and airy, and the combination of mozzarella, tomatoes and basil were an absolute match made in heaven! For those who like something with a bit more kick, their spicy pepperoni pizza packs quite a punch.

And let’s not forget about the side dishes – their garlic knots were especially noteworthy. They were super soft on the inside with just the right amount of crunch on the outside. Plus they’re covered with Parmesan cheese and served with marinara sauce that really added to their deliciousness!

Overall I’d have to say Locale offers some of the best pizza in Boston MA. From its charming atmosphere to its scrumptious food and friendly staff, this place is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town!

#12 Union Park Pizza

I arrived at the restaurant a bit skeptical, having been to pizzerias in places like Naples and Rome. But I was pleasantly surprised: Union Park Pizza definitely has some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!

The decor was charming and inviting, making me feel right at home. Even better was the aroma of freshly baked pizza when I walked in. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable and they enthusiastically recommended their signature pizzas.

I tried a few of the specialty pies, including a classic Margherita with mozzarella, tomatoes, garlic, basil and drizzles of olive oil. It was amazing! The crust was light and crispy yet still chewy – it had just the perfect amount of charring for an authentic Italian flavor.

The Marinara pizza also didn’t disappoint – bursting with flavor from its blend of fresh tomato sauce, oregano, garlic and basil. The balance between sweetness and acidity was spot on!

In all, Union Park Pizza easily ranks among the best places for pizza in Boston MA that I’ve visited. This place definitely deserves an A+ in my book!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Santarpio’s Pizza

It’s a small, rustic joint that oozes charm and character. As soon as you step inside, the scent of cheese and freshly baked dough wraps around you like a hungry boa constrictor. And let’s not forget the perks – they serve alcohol, and by alcohol, I mean all the delightful elixirs for your inner party animal. They even offer hard liquor, folks! So, if you’re yearning for a slice and a stiff drink, Santarpio’s has got you covered.

Now, onto the downsides. Brace yourself, my fellow pizza enthusiasts, because Santarpio’s does not accept reservations. Yes, you read that right. If you want to indulge in their delectable deep dish goodness, you have to be prepared to play the waiting game. But hey, consider it a lesson in patience and self-control, right?

But oh boy, is it worth the wait! Picture this: a thick, crispy crust that’s sturdy enough to support the hefty toppings without getting soggy. The cheese, oh the cheese! It stretches like a bungee cord, providing the perfect cheesy landing for your taste buds. And the toppings! They seem to have a magical way of transporting you to Italy with each bite. It’s like Mama Santarpio herself sprinkled some Italian magic on these pizzas.

So, my fellow foodies, whether you’re a tourist looking for a nice spot or a local in desperate need of a pizza fix, Santarpio’s Pizza is the place to be. Just don’t forget to wear your stretchy pants, because you’ll be leaving with a full belly and a heart filled with pizza love.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Regina Pizzeria

But first, let me start with the downsides. Regina Pizzeria, why, oh why, do you not accept reservations? I mean, isn’t it enough that we have to battle through hordes of hungry tourists to get a table? Now we have to stand there like vultures, waiting for someone to finish their last bite? But I digress.

Now, onto the benefits. Oh, thank the pizza gods for the fact that Regina Pizzeria serves alcohol. Nothing pairs better with a hot, cheesy slice of heaven than an ice-cold beer. And bonus points for having some vegetarian options! It’s nice to know that even us meat-eaters can bring our herbivorous friends along and not feel guilty about devouring an entire pie.

And speaking of guilt, Regina Pizzeria is a fantastic spot for tourists. Sure, it may be slightly overcrowded, but that’s part of its charm. You get to eat amazing pizza and people-watch at the same time. It’s like having dinner and a show! Plus, being surrounded by fellow pizza enthusiasts just adds to the whole experience. You can bond over your love of perfectly crisp crust, stretchy cheese, and tangy tomato sauce.

So, if you’re in the north end and craving the best thin crust pizza in town, make your way to Regina Pizzeria. Just be prepared to battle for a table and leave your reservation hopes at the door. But trust me, it’s worth every delicious bite.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar

Upon stepping into the restaurant, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese. The ambiance of the place is like stepping into a rustic pizza paradise, with their signature wood-fired oven stealing the show. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I couldn’t help but do a little dance of excitement.

But let’s get down to the important stuff: the pizza itself. The first bite sent me straight to pizza heaven. The perfectly thin and chewy crust with just the right amount of char had me swooning. The toppings were a delightful mix of flavors, from the classic margherita bursting with fresh basil and juicy tomatoes, to the adventurous prosciutto and arugula combo that left me craving for more.

But it’s not just the pizza that shines at Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar, oh no. The kitchen + bar aspect adds a whole new dimension to the experience. I couldn’t resist trying some of their craft cocktails, and boy, did they hit the spot. The mixologists here are true artists, creating concoctions that perfectly complemented the pizzas.

As a seasoned pizza traveler, I can confidently say that Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar is a true gem in the world of wood-fired pizza. The attention to detail and the passion for their craft shines through in every bite. So if you find yourself in Boston and craving a mouthwatering pizza experience, make your way to Pastoral and prepare for a pizza journey like no other.