Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Clearwater FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Clearwater FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

160 Views

I’ve been lucky enough to sample pizza from all corners of the globe, and I’m here to tell you that Clearwater has some real gems. After trying out 12 pizza places in the area, I’m ready to proclaim which one stands out as the ‘Best Pizza In Clearwater FL’, but not without a few laughs and stories along the way!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Infinity Pizza

For starters, it’s hard to beat their location right across the street from the beach. The atmosphere is always so inviting and cozy that I could easily spend an entire day here.

The pizza itself is outstanding! It’s cooked to perfection with a thin, crispy crust and just perfect amount of cheese. Their signature toppings are second-to-none and really make the pizza stand out from the crowd. Once you take a bite, you won’t regret it!

The staff at Infinity Pizza is also top notch; they’re friendly, knowledgeable about their pizzas, and always willing to give recommendations.

In conclusion, I’m happy that I found Infinity Pizza; it’s easily one of the best pizza restaurants in Clearwater FL. If you’re ever in town, be sure to check them out – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Dunedin!

#2 Alba Pizza & Cafe

My first visit to Alba was a treat for my taste buds. I started with the basic ‘Margherita’ and wow, it just melted in my mouth! The homemade pizza sauce, oozing of mozzarella cheese, and freshly cut basil was a delicious combination.

The second time around I decided to go for something more daring — a signature creation called the ‘Tutto Mare’. It features anchovies, fresh mussels and calamari on top of the Margherita base. When the pizza arrived at my table I just knew that this was the one. The salty flavor from the anchovies combined perfectly with the sweetness of the seafood made this pizza unforgettable.

If you’re looking for a fantastic dinner experience while in Clearwater FL, then Alba Pizza & Cafe should be your go-to spot! With their delectable menu options and hospitable service, you can be sure that you’ll have an enjoyable evening out. As far as I’m concerned, Alba is providing some of the best pizza in town – make sure to check it out soon!

#3 Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza

Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza is a truly unique spot. They use a coal oven to give the pizza an extra crispy and robust flavor that you can’t find anywhere else. Plus, the toppings are always fresh, varied and delicious.

The atmosphere at Cristino’s is welcoming and inviting. One thing I especially loved was the cheerful staff who made sure all my questions were answered and that I felt comfortable while enjoying my slice of pizza!

Overall, Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza was an amazing experience that I would highly recommend to anyone looking for the best pizza in Clearwater FL. With delicious pizza, friendly staff and an unforgettable coal oven flavor, this place is well worth checking out!

#4 Mellow Mushroom Clearwater

The thing that makes Mellow Mushroom stand out is their unique selection of pizzas. From the traditional cheese and pepperoni to the more exotic options like ‘Southern Heat’ and ‘Mighty Meaty’, they have something to please everyone’s palate.

I had the chance to enjoy the Southern Heat pizza, which was absolutely delicious. The combination of spicy sausage and jalapenos combined with a light sauce and creamy mix of cheeses was a delightful surprise.

Another great thing about Mellow Mushroom Clearwater is the atmosphere. It’s relaxed vibe makes it a great stop for lunch on a busy day or dinner with friends. On top of that, the staff was friendly and efficient, making sure my order was taken care of quickly so I could enjoy my meal.

Overall, I highly recommend Mellow Mushroom Clearwater to anyone looking for delicious, creative pizza options in Clearwater FL! It’s definitely worth your time and money if you’re in town looking for some great pizza!

#5 Gondolier Pizza

The first time I tried their pizza, I knew something was special. It had a nice, thick crust that was cooked perfectly and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The cheese was of superior quality – it had just the right amount of moisture and flavor.

The sauces were particularly pleasing to me. Gondolier Pizza has several options to choose from, including marinara, pesto, Alfredo, and more! Each one packed a punch of wonderful flavors that made the pizza even better.

The atmosphere at Gondolier Pizza is inviting and relaxed. The staff is friendly and always willing to help with anything you need. Plus, they have some really nice outdoor seating areas if you decide to eat in.

In my opinion, Gondolier Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Clearwater FL – both in terms of taste and atmosphere. If you’re ever in this area looking for a great pizza experience without breaking the bank, look no further than Gondolier Pizza!

#6 Monty’s Pizzeria

My experience at Monty’s Pizzeria was nothing short of amazing. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was greeted with a cheerful “Welcome to Monty’s! We have the best pizza in Clearwater FL!” Immediately, I was impressed by their enthusiasm and dedication to making sure their customers had the best experience possible.

I ordered my pizza with extra cheese and mushrooms and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crisp, yet still wonderfully fluffy inside – just how I like it. Even more impressive were the generous toppings – they gave me more than enough cheese and mushrooms to give each bite a delicious flavor and texture.

But that wasn’t all that made me happy at Monty’s Pizzeria; the service was phenomenal too! Everyone from the cooks to the waiters were friendly and accommodating. They went out of their way to make sure my pizza was cooked to perfection and served immediately upon request.

Overall, my experience at Monty’s Pizzeria was excellent! After tasting some of their mouth-watering pizzas for myself, there is no doubt in my mind that this is indeed some of the best pizza in Clearwater FL! If you’re ever in town and looking for an amazing place to grab a great slice of pizza (or two) then look no further than Monty’s Pizzeria – you won’t be disappointed.

#7 Roundabout Pizza

The moment I walked in, I noticed the warm and inviting atmosphere. The brick oven pizza was being prepared right in front of me, which made me even more excited to try it.

When my pizza finally arrived, my mouth started to water. The thick crust was cooked perfectly and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It had just the right amount of sauce and cheese for a savory taste.

What really impressed me the most was how creative their pizzas were! From unorthodox combinations like pineapple and bacon to traditional favorites like pepperoni and sausage, they had something for everyone.

I also wanted to mention that Roundabout Pizza has very friendly staff who are always willing to answer any questions you may have. This is one of those restaurants where you don’t just feel welcomed but also appreciated!

To sum it up: if you’re looking for some amazing pizza with top-notch service then Roundabout Pizza is your place! With a large selection of pizzas made with fresh ingredients and creative combinations, I guarantee that you’ll be coming back for more!

#8 Amore Pizzeria

I was delighted to find they had an impressive array of topping options, ranging from the classic pepperoni and mushroom to more exotic options like capers and artichokes. There’s something for everyone!

The star of the show was their crust, which was light and fluffy with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce wasn’t too sweet or acidic, it was just right. Plus, the cheese was a thick, creamy mozzarella that melted in my mouth.

The staff here is also wonderful. Everyone from the owner to the waitstaff were friendly, courteous and helpful. Plus, they always made sure my pizza came out hot and fresh.

All in all, I give Amore Pizzeria five stars for their top-notch pizzas! If you’re ever in Clearwater FL and looking for the best pizza around, look no further than Amore Pizzeria!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Tarpon Springs!

#9 Paul’s Chicago Pizza

The first thing I noticed when walking in was the smell of pizza baking in the oven, which made my mouth water. The interior was very clean and inviting, with a hint of Chicago flair.

The menu had plenty of options available and the prices were reasonable. After some deliberation, I decided to go with a classic deep dish pizza.

When it came out, the cheese was melted perfectly into the crust and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Every bite was better than the last!

The service was also excellent and the staff were friendly and efficient. They knew their menu inside-and-out which made ordering easy.

If you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Clearwater FL, Paul’s Chicago Pizza is definitely worth checking out – I guarantee it won’t disappoint!

#10 King’s Pizza & Grill

When I walked into the restaurant, my first thought was: “This must be the place!” The tables and chairs were set up invitingly with checkered tablecloths, and the smell of freshly made pizza wafted through the air.

The menu was full of unique creations I had never seen before, from Italian-style deep-dish pizzas to vegetarian-friendly options. But I knew what I wanted; a classic cheese pizza. Everything else can wait for another time!

I waited anxiously to see how my pie turned out. When it was placed in front of me, it looked perfect – with golden-brown crust, just the right amount of sauce and cheese, and plenty of toppings. The pizza was so delicious that I almost forgot why I was there in the first place!

Overall, King’s Pizza & Grill is truly one of the best places to get pizza in Clearwater FL. Their pies are creative and tasty, and their service is always friendly and efficient. All things considered, it’s no wonder why this place always has a steady stream of customers looking for their favorite slice!

#11 “We the Pizza” Clearwater beach

When I first entered the quaint restaurant, I was immediately impressed by the traditional Italian decor. The warm atmosphere made me feel right at home.

The waitress quickly brought me a menu full of mouthwatering specialty pies like the Meat Lovers and the Margherita Pesto. I settled on their signature “We the Pizza”—a combination of pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms with a garlic-olive oil crust. It was cooked perfectly—not too crunchy or soggy—and all of the flavors blended together nicely.

The service was also top-notch: my water glass was never empty, and they were always available to answer any questions I had about their different toppings or ingredients.

Overall, if you’re looking for great pizza in Clearwater FL, “We the Pizza” Clearwater beach should be your go-to spot! The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, and they definitely have some of the best pizza around!

#12 Rizzoli’s Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was so inviting. You get a sense of home and that’s exactly what you need when searching for the perfect pizza. The service was fast and friendly, which made my experience all that much better.

I had a chance to try several of their delicious pizzas and I must say they were all amazing! The crust was light and fluffy, yet still held up well enough to support the toppings. The toppings were fresh and there was plenty of cheese – just like real Italian pies!

To top it off, the price was extremely reasonable. It surprisingly affordable considering how great the pizza tasted.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Clearwater FL then Rizzoli’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Paul’s Chicago Pizza

Let me start by saying that as a food critic, I have experienced my fair share of disappointing pizza concoctions that should be classified as crimes against humanity. But fear not, dear reader, because Paul’s Chicago Pizza is here to save the day!

Not only does this place serve mouthwatering deep dish pizzas, but they also serve alcohol. Who doesn’t love a slice of cheesy goodness with a side of booze? It’s like a match made in pizza heaven!

And if your sweet tooth is aching for attention, fear not! Paul’s Chicago Pizza offers a delectable array of desserts that will make you weak in the knees. I’m partial to their gooey, warm chocolate chip cookie pizza. It’s like a sugary slice of paradise.

Now, let’s talk about the atmosphere. This place is a nice tourist spot, which means you can impress your out-of-town friends with your impeccable taste in pizza joints. Plus, they have screens aplenty showing the latest sports games. Who needs the discomfort of stadium seating when you can enjoy the game and some delicious slices in a cozy restaurant?

However, my only gripe is that they don’t accept reservations. This place is so popular that you might have to wait a bit. So, grab your patience hat and get ready to drool over the pictures of pizza on the walls while you wait.

In conclusion, if you’re in the mood for the best deep dish pizza in clearwater, look no further than Paul’s Chicago Pizza. This place will have you saying Holy pepperoni, Batman! in no time. Bon appetit!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Mellow Mushroom Clearwater

Walking into Mellow Mushroom, I was immediately transported to a groovy, psychedelic paradise. The walls were adorned with colorful murals and everywhere I looked there was something funky and unique. I half expected to see Jimi Hendrix jamming on a guitar in the corner. But alas, it was just me and my insatiable pizza appetite.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Oh boy, it was love at first bite. The thin crust was crispy, yet chewy, with just the right amount of char. It was like the pizza gods had blessed me with the perfect crust. I even took a moment to shed a single tear of joy, because yes, it was that good.

But let’s not forget about the toppings. Mellow Mushroom Clearwater certainly knows how to get creative. They have everything from classic favorites like pepperoni and mushroom to quirky combinations like fig and goat cheese. Trust me, you haven’t truly lived until you’ve had a slice of their Magical Mystery Tour pizza. It’s a trip for your taste buds!

And let’s not overlook the service. The staff at Mellow Mushroom were not only friendly, but they also had a great sense of humor. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with silly jokes and puns that had me chuckling like a madman. It’s like they knew that laughter is the perfect seasoning for a meal.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Clearwater and craving some out-of-this-world thin crust pizza, Mellow Mushroom is the place to be. Just make sure to bring your appetite and a sense of humor, because you’re in for a wild pizza adventure!