Best Pizza in Durango CO (Updated Jan 2023)

I’m sure all the pizza-lovers out there are curious – which pizzeria in the city is best? I’ve done the hard work and eaten my way through 11 spots to determine who has the top slice.

From a classic cheese to something more creative, I’m rating each spot on crust, sauce, and toppings. This review is meant to be humorous and light-hearted, so strap yourself in and let’s get ready for an epic pizza adventure!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 Johnny Pizza

The restaurant has a cozy, rustic atmosphere that is comforting. I ordered the pepperoni and sausage pizza, and it was cooked to perfection. The crust had just the right amount of crunch and the sauce was just spicy enough. The cheese was bubbling and gooey, and the toppings were cooked evenly.

The service was excellent; they were friendly, attentive and knew their menu well. They had a great selection of beers on tap too!

Overall, I’d highly recommend Johnny Pizza for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Durango CO. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 8 more pizza places in Pagosa Springs!

#2 Olde Schoolhouse Cafe

This restaurant has everything a pizza lover could want. Not only do they serve delicious and creative pizzas, but they also serve alcoholic beverages, including hard liquor. As a vegetarian, it’s great to see some non-meat options available on the menu as well!

For those that are looking for a touristy spot or a place to watch sports, Olde Schoolhouse Cafe is the perfect spot. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, and the staff is exceptionally friendly and helpful. Plus, who can resist a few drinks while watching their favorite team?

Unfortunately, Olde Schoolhouse Cafe does not offer delivery. So if you want to enjoy the amazing pizzas from this restaurant you’ll have to pay them a visit! But trust me – it’s more than worth it to savor the deliciousness of their pies in person.

So next time you’re in Durango CO and craving some of the best pizza around, make sure to check out Olde Schoolhouse Cafe!

#3 Happy Pappys Pizza n Wings

Each slice of pizza I tried was absolutely delicious. The thin and crispy crust had a great flavor. The sauce was rich and flavorful. And the cheese…oh my! It was gooey and cheesy in all the right places!

The staff at Happy Pappys was also super friendly, which made ordering a breeze. They always make sure that the orders are correct to avoid any mix-ups.

I have to say, Happy Pappys Pizza n Wings is definitely one of the best pizza places I’ve ever visited! If you’re in the Durango area, then make sure to check out this place – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Fired Up Pizzeria

I’m not sure what’s in their secret sauce, but it’s delicious. The toppings are copious and fresh and the crust is just crunchy enough. Plus, they serve alcohol, have a great kid’s menu, and offer vegetarian options!

The only downside is that they don’t deliver—you’ll have to get it yourself or with your friends. But no worries—it’s well worth the trip. Plus, it’s a great place to watch sports if you want to grab a few slices with your crew and root for the home team.

And let me tell you about the dessert selection! Fired Up Pizzeria really steps up its game here with some mouthwatering treats like brownies and cookies.

All in all, I think Fired Up Pizzeria is one of Durango CO’s best pizza restaurants. Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 49 miles, you can get to 6 more pizza places in Telluride!

#5 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The moment I stepped in, I was overwhelmed by the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. The setup is great – you can choose your ingredients, they’ll make the pizza right there in front of you, and then all you have to do is take it home to bake it yourself! It really doesn’t get any easier than that.

I got a traditional pepperoni pizza with some extra cheese thrown in for good measure. Once I got it home and popped it in the oven, my taste buds were treated to a savory delight. The crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful – definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

I highly recommend Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza to anyone looking for a delicious pizza experience that’s convenient and fun. It’s definitely some of the best pizza in Durango CO!

#6 HomeSlice Pizza

The atmosphere is laid-back and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. The menu has a great variety of pizzas that are sure to appease all kinds of pizza cravings. I always love trying their ‘specialty’ pizzas like their Spinach & Artichoke, Italian Sausage & Pepperoni, or even their vegetarian-friendly Ultimate Veggie Pie.

To top off the great food, HomeSlice Pizza offers an impressive selection of craft beers to pair with your slice. This combination is unbeatable!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Durango CO then look no further than HomeSlice Pizza—it’s my favorite spot for sure! The crust is always perfect and the toppings are always fresh and delicious. It’s definitely worth the trip!

#7 J. Bo Pizza & Rib Co

This place really stands out for its top-notch quality and creative combinations. The pizzas are cooked to perfection – crispy and chewy – with bubbly cheese that’s just asking to be devoured.

The pizzas are also loaded with a variety of delicious toppings like pepperoni, bell peppers, sausage, mushrooms, olives and more! My favorite is the BBQ Chicken pizza which is extra cheesy and smothered in BBQ sauce and smoky chicken. It’s an absolute taste explosion in your mouth!

In addition to delicious pizzas, the menu also offers some heavenly ribs that are fall-off-the-bone tender and drenched in a lip-smacking marinade. They even offer homemade sides like mac ‘n’ cheese, mashed potatoes and coleslaw which are all equally yummy.

To top it off, the wait staff at J. Bo Pizza & Rib Co is incredibly friendly and helpful; you’ll get personalized service from start to finish. I’d definitely recommend this spot if you’re craving some truly awesome pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 133 miles, you can get to 8 more pizza places in Moab!

#8 HomeSlice Pizza

What’s not to love? The pizza here is nothing short of divine. From the first bite, I knew I was in for a treat. The crust is crisp with just the right amount of chewiness, and the sauce is savory with a hint of sweetness. Plus, they top each pie with a generous amount of cheese and fresh ingredients.

I also have to commend them for their friendly customer service. Every time I visited HomeSlice Pizza, the staff was always more than happy to help me out with whatever I needed – from ordering advice to suggestions on what toppings would pair best together.

All in all, this place does not disappoint! If you’re ever looking for some delicious pizza in Durango CO that’ll leave your taste buds satisfied, head over to HomeSlice Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#9 Home Slice Pizza

The atmosphere was perfect. The restaurant has a nice vintage decor and the staff were friendly enough to put up with my never-ending barrage of food related questions!

But what really sets Home Slice Pizza apart is their pizza. Not only was it hot and fresh when it arrived at our table, but it also had some of the best flavor I’ve ever tasted in a pizza. The sauce was tangy and savory, the cheese was creamy and melted perfectly over the top, and the crust had that amazing crunch that you can only get from a wood-fired oven. Everything about this pizza just screamed ‘taste explosion’!

In short, Home Slice Pizza is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Durango CO. If you’re looking for top quality pizza with good old-fashioned flavors, then look no further than Home Slice Pizza!

#10 Father’s Daughters Pizza

I’m not exaggerating either. I had one of their thin crust pizzas with a delicious blend of spicy, sweet and nutty sauce that really hit the spot. The pizza was cooked to perfection – the crust was crunchy and the cheese was gooey and flavorful.

The atmosphere at Father’s Daughters Pizza is cozy yet modern – my wife and I enjoyed it immensely! Plus, their service staff were friendly, efficient and eager to answer any questions we had about the menu items.

Overall, this place is definitely one of my favorite places to go for pizza in Durango CO. Hands down, it’s some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

If you’re willing to go an extra 136 miles, you can get to 9 more pizza places in Taos!

#11 Domino’s Pizza

First and foremost, their crust is always cooked to perfection. Whether you order the thin crust or deep dish, it has just the right amount of crispiness that still maintains its tenderness.

Then there’s their generous portions of toppings. I’m a real sucker for fresh mushrooms and sausage and Domino’s never skimps. There’s plenty of tasty toppings on each slice so you never have to worry about missing out.

On top of that, they have some delicious specialty pizzas that can make all your pizza dreams come true! I recently ordered the Supreme Pizza and was blown away by how much flavor it had in every bite.

All in all, Domino’s Pizza is definitely one of my go-to restaurants whenever I’m in Durango CO! Their pizzas are consistent, flavorful, and always made with fresh ingredients. It just doesn’t get any better than this!