Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hammond IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Hammond IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

52 Views

I’ve sampled pizza from 12 different places and have tasted pies of all shapes, sizes, and flavors. From traditional Italian-style to creative gourmet pizzas, I’ve had a great time exploring the local flavor!

My mission has been to find the absolute best pizza in Hammond IN. I’m not just talking about the biggest or most expensive – instead, I’m looking for a slice that’ll keep me coming back for more. Let’s get started on this journey and find out which one is my favorite!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Verona Pizza II

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked in was the charming, old-school ambiance. The pizza ovens had been there since the 1940s, and I could smell the delicious dough baking as soon as I entered.

The crust was light and flaky with just the right amount of crunch – definitely one of the best crusts I’ve ever had. The sauce was flavorful, not too heavy or overpowering, and paired perfectly with all of their fresh toppings!

Their cheese selection is top notch, and you can always get it freshly grated if you want an extra special touch. Plus, they have some really unique topping combinations that really take their pies to a whole new level of deliciousness.

I’m so glad to have discovered Verona Pizza II while in Hammond IN – it truly has some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Tinley Park!

#2 Venice Pizza

The restaurant itself is very inviting, with a modern yet classic Italian vibe to it. Immediately upon entering, I was greeted by the most friendly and welcoming staff who made sure I had whatever I wanted.

The pizza at Venice Pizza is out of this world! Each pizza was cooked to perfection, with a crispy yet chewy crust that had an amazing flavor. The ingredients were all fresh, and combined together to make the perfect combination of flavors. Every bite was packed with flavor, and each piece was cooked just right – not too soggy or too crunchy.

I tried all of the different specialty pizzas that Venice Pizza offers, ranging from meat lover’s pies to vegan delicacies. The combinations of flavors were spot on every time. The prices are quite reasonable for the quality you get here – definitely a great value for your money!

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Hammond IN, look no further than Venice Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

#3 Barton’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere of the place is perfect for a night out with friends. The staff are friendly and accommodating, always making sure I had the best experience possible.

When it comes to the food, Barton’s Pizzeria proves they know pizza! Their crust is cooked to perfection- crispy on the outside and soft in the middle. Each layer seems like an art form with its unique blend of flavors. The toppings come fresh from local farms and never seem too overbearing or out-of-place in regards to taste.

Overall, I would absolutely recommend this place as some of the best pizza in Hammond IN! In fact, I’d say it just might be worth flying there to try out for yourself!

#4 Edwardo’s Natural Pizza

The moment I arrived at the restaurant, I was already impressed. The ambiance was cozy yet modern, and the staff were all very friendly and helpful.

When it came time to order, I knew immediately what I wanted: the Supreme Pizza. A classic favorite! This pizza was loaded with layers of flavor—pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and olives on a delectable thin crust base. The ingredients were so fresh that you could taste their quality with every bite. And let me tell you, each bite was pure heaven!

I also had the chance to sample some of their other varieties. Their Veggie Lovers Pizza featured a yummy garlic-infused sauce layered with tomatoes, spinach, bell peppers and more. It may have been meat-free but it was still incredibly scrumptious!

And finally, my favorite pizza of them all: their BBQ Chicken. The sauce was tangy and sweet while the chicken pieces were flavorful and succulent—it truly hit all the right notes!

All in all, Edwardo’s Natural Pizza is definitely one of Hammond IN’s best pizzas—perfect for a special night out or just a casual evening by yourself. Highly recommended to everyone looking for great tastes in an even greater atmosphere!

#5 The Original John’s Pizzeria

It’s hard to find a pizza restaurant that can compete with the culinary mastery of chefs from around the world, but The Original John’s Pizzeria can proudly hold its own. The crust is fresh, thin and crispy, served up hot with the perfect combination of toppings. What really stands out to me is how generous they are with their cheese, making it plentiful in every slice without being overbearing or greasy.

The atmosphere at The Original John’s Pizzeria is so inviting too! It’s just like walking into an old-school pizzeria in Italy – warm colors, friendly staff and delicious aromas coming from the kitchen. I also appreciate their commitment to sustainability – they offer alternatives like vegan cheese and gluten-free pizza dough that still taste great.

At The Original John’s Pizzeria, you’ll be sure to enjoy the best pizza in Hammond IN! Plus they offer delivery if you’re not able to visit the restaurant itself – a great option for those nights you just don’t feel like cooking. So why wait? Get your taste buds ready for an authentic Italian experience here at The Original John’s Pizzeria today!

#6 Capri’s Pizza

The pies are always cooked to perfection, with the perfect amount of crust and an ample serving of toppings. I love how they combine traditional styles with a bit of innovation (I’m thinking of their great white pizza).

From the moment you step through the door, you can smell the deliciousness coming from their ovens! The team is always friendly and accommodating, helping to create an atmosphere that is just as nice as the pizza.

Speaking of atmosphere, this restaurant really nails it! The red-and-white checkered tablecloths definitely give off an oldschool Italian vibe, but don’t discount the modern touches like their craft beer selection. There’s something for everyone!

To put it simply: if you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Hammond IN, Capri’s Pizza definitely delivers. I can vouch for that personally!

#7 Isabella’s Pizza

I had the pleasure of trying their Sausage Supreme pie, and it was absolutely delicious. The crust was cooked to perfection, with a buttery texture that melted in my mouth. The sauce was so flavorful and really brought out the flavors of the toppings. The sausage crumbles were cooked just right with an irresistible smoky flavor. The cheese and veggies provided an amazing combination of textures I just couldn’t get enough of!

On top of all this, this place sets itself apart with its friendly service. As soon as I walked in, I felt like I was part of the family. Everyone was so welcoming and took great care to make sure my experience was one-of-a-kind.

In conclusion, Isabella’s Pizza has truly earned its title as having the best pizza in Hammond IN – hands down! Whether you’re a local or just passing through, be sure to stop by for a pizza that will leave your taste buds happy!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Chicago!

#8 House of Pizza

From the moment I stepped in, I knew my experience at House of Pizza was going to be top-notch. From the friendly and knowledgeable staff, you can tell that they really care about their customers and their craft.

I started off with their signature pizza, a combination of mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, spinach, pineapples, onions and bacon. The dough was perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside yet soft on the inside and full of flavor. The toppings were fresh and flavorful and the ratio was just right – not too much cheese or toppings but enough to enjoy each bite.

But the star of this show is definitely the sauce – rich, tangy tomato sauce with a hint of spice that added depth to every slice. It’s no wonder why so many people come here again and again!

In conclusion, I think it’s safe to say that House of Pizza has some of the best pizza in Hammond IN – with its delicious pies made with quality ingredients and great service all around. Give them a try if you’re ever in town!

#9 Aurelio’s Pizza of Hammond

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with the chef standing behind the counter ready to greet guests. The smell of delicious pizza fills the air with each pie made to perfection.

When it comes to their pizza, Aurelio’s does not disappoint. The crust is light and fluffy, yet still crisp enough to hold up against all of the toppings. From classic pepperoni slices, to unusual combinations like olive and artichoke, the ingredients are fresh and flavorful.

What really impressed me about this restaurant was their ability to adjust flavor profiles for different palates. My friends who enjoy spicy food were more than pleased with their fiery slices! Not only that, but they even have vegan options for those looking for something a little bit different.

In conclusion, Aurelio’s Pizza of Hammond truly has some of the best pizza in Hammond IN! Whether you’re looking for a classic slice or something out of the ordinary, they make sure everyone leaves happy and satisfied.

#10 State Line Pizza Hammond

The atmosphere upon entering this restaurant was inviting, bustling, and a bit chaotic, with the alluring smells of fresh-baked pizza making me feel at home. The decor is modern and fun, but it’s the food that kept me coming back.

I tried the Classic Cheese Pie which was a classic cheese blend of mozzarella and provolone with a perfect balance of flavor. The crust was crispy yet fluffy – not too crunchy or too soft – and it pulled away cleanly when I took each bite. On top of that, the sauce was perfectly seasoned with just enough herbs to give it some zing without overpowering the other flavors in the dish.

I also tried their signature ‘Grand Slam’ pizza which included sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and mushrooms – my favorite. With this savory combination dominating every bite, I could almost taste each individual ingredient as it blended together in perfect harmony. As if that wasn’t enough satisfaction for one meal, they even threw in some extra special toppings like feta cheese crumbles which were the perfect finishing touch!

Overall this restaurant has got what it takes to make great pizza – from quality ingredients to perfect cooking technique – plus an inviting atmosphere so you can enjoy your meal guilt-free! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hammond IN then State Line Pizza Hammond should be your stop!

#11 Windy City Pizza Kitchen

On my first visit, I was greeted warmly by the staff who made sure all of my questions were answered. As soon as I got to the restaurant, I knew that this place meant business – it smelled amazing! The decor is casual and inviting, making it perfect for hanging out with friends and family.

The pizza here is no joke! They make their own dough from scratch and use only the freshest ingredients, so you know you’ll be getting something delicious. The thin crust has a perfect crunch that contrasts wonderfully with the creamy cheese and flavorful toppings. Not to mention, their specialty pizzas are truly unique – try the Windy City Special for an unforgettable mix of flavors!

Overall, Windy City Pizza Kitchen is definitely one of my top picks for best pizza in Hammond IN. If you’re looking for an incredible pizza experience, then look no further than this iconic spot!

#12 Squigi’s Pizza of Highland

I was truly impressed with Squigi’s gourmet pizza selection. From classic margherita and pepperoni to unique flavors like cherry-bacon barbecue and pineapple jerk, Squigi’s has something for everyone. No matter which pizza I tried, the crust was perfectly crisp and crunchy on the outside yet soft and tasty on the inside. The sauce was bursting with flavor, not too sweet or too tangy, and the cheese was just melted enough to string from one slice to another. Yum!

But what really made me a big fan of Squigi’s was their attentive staff and cozy atmosphere. Everyone from the bar tenders to servers were friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. Plus, they had TVs playing sports in each corner of the dining area so you can kick back with your friends while you wait for your meal. As far as I’m concerned, there’s no better way to enjoy a great slice of pizza than at Squigi’s Pizza of Highland!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – House of Pizza

Upon entering the restaurant, I was met with a delightful aroma of cheese and fresh dough. The decor reminded me of an old school Italian joint, complete with red-checkered tablecloths and quirky pizza-themed art on the walls. It felt like I had stumbled into a pizza lover’s paradise.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. Oh my cheesy goodness, where do I even begin? The thin crust was a masterpiece – crispy, yet chewy in all the right places. It was like biting into a cloud made of deliciousness. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the cheese was melty, gooey perfection. Each bite was a symphony of flavors dancing on my taste buds.

But what really sets House of Pizza apart from the rest is their toppings. They have an extensive menu of unique and creative options that will make your mouth water. From classic pepperoni to exotic combinations like bacon and pineapple, they truly have something for everyone. And let’s not forget their generous portion sizes – I could barely finish one slice!

The staff at House of Pizza were friendly and attentive, providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere. I couldn’t help but feel like I was part of one big pizza-loving family. The prices were reasonable too, which is always a plus.

So, if you find yourself in northwest Indiana and craving a slice of heaven, look no further than House of Pizza. Trust me, it’s worth every mouth-watering moment. Just be prepared to leave with a new addiction to the best thin crust pizza in the area.