Best Pizza in Harlem (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve tasted pizza all around the world, from Italy to New York City, and my latest adventure was to the diverse neighborhood of Harlem. With its unique African-American culture, it’s a great place to explore different flavors and styles of pizza.

I decided to try 11 different pizza places to find the absolute best slice in Harlem. It won’t be an easy task, but I’m up for the challenge! After all, I’m sure many locals know great spots that still remain secrets. So come join me on a mouth-watering journey through Harlem as I search for its tastiest pizza treat.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Dado’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Dado’s Pizza, I knew it was something special. The cozy atmosphere, combined with the smell of freshly baked pizza made me immediately excited for what was to come.

When my order arrived, it more than exceeded my expectations – the crust was perfectly cooked, just the right amount of cheese and sauce, and all of the ingredients combined to make a simply delicious meal!

The service at Dado’s was friendly and attentive without being intrusive – they let me enjoy my meal in peace while offering helpful recommendations when needed.

Overall, I can’t recommend Dado’s Pizza enough! They serve some of the best pizza in Harlem that I’ve ever tried, and are sure to please even the pickiest eaters!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!

#2 Sottocasa

I’ve had my fair share of New York pizza, and it’s tough to find a place that stands out from the rest. But Sottocasa is different. The pizza here is something special. It has a perfect crunchy yet chewy crust, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.

The atmosphere of the restaurant itself was amazing as well. The seating was cozy and comfortable, and I felt right at home. Not to mention the service was top notch – they really seemed to care about making sure my experience was perfect.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Harlem, this is definitely the spot! If you haven’t been to Sottocasa yet, then what are you waiting for? Get down there now!

#3 314

I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of their pizzas. The crust was perfectly cooked: crisp on the outside and fluffy inside. The cheese was exceptional and the toppings were flavorful and fresh.

The atmosphere at 314 is what really drew me in though. They have a cozy, casual setting with a relaxed vibe. Plus, their music selection was great!

The service at 314 was outstanding too. The staff were friendly and attentive and made sure my experience was enjoyable from start to finish.

Overall, I had a fantastic experience at 314 and would highly recommend it for anyone looking for delicious pizza in Harlem!

#4 P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

I stopped by P & M about a month ago, and I’ve been dreaming about it since then. The restaurant looks small but has a really cozy atmosphere – exactly what I’d expect from this kind of place.

The pizza was the real star here, though. The crust was thin yet crunchy, and the ingredients were of the highest quality. Their signature topping combo is tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms and olives – and boy did I love it! Even when you get a couple slices to go, they still manage to capture that taste perfect at first bite.

It’s also worth mentioning that their staff are super friendly and accommodating – always eager to help in any way they can. That just added to the overall pleasant experience of dining there.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Harlem- look no further than P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant! Here you’ll find fresh ingredients combined with top-notch service for an unforgettable experience.

#5 Armonie

They start with a delicious, chewy crust which is just the right mix of crunch and softness. The sauce is outstanding – it has just enough tomato flavor without being too heavy. The cheese is stretchy and rich, and the toppings are varied and plentiful!

I recently tried their BBQ Chicken Pizza on a gluten-free crust and it was phenomenal. The combination of sweet BBQ sauce, juicy chicken breast, caramelized onions, crisp red peppers and hearty mushrooms was absolutely perfect.

The restaurant itself has a great atmosphere too. It’s cozy with nice music playing in the background. Plus, there are plenty of seats to accommodate large groups of friends or families.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Harlem – head over to Armonie for a truly delicious experience!

#6 King’s Pizza of Harlem

From the moment I stepped inside and saw the giant brick ovens, I knew this place was special. The crust was perfectly cooked with a nice char to it and the sauce was flavorful and had an excellent balance of spices. The cheese was gooey and melted in my mouth.

The topping choices were endless! From classic pepperoni to unique options like BBQ chicken, there’s something for everyone. Every bite was even better than the last, leaving me wanting more.

The staff at King’s Pizza of Harlem couldn’t be any nicer or more inviting. They truly made me feel welcome every time I visited – which happened often! In fact, they were so accommodating that they would customize each pie to my exact specifications.

Overall, I’d definitely recommend King’s Pizza of Harlem to anyone looking for great pizza in Harlem! Best pizza in town; hands down!

#7 Fumo Harlem

When I visited, I was impressed by the cozy atmosphere and inviting decor – it was a welcome break from some of the stuffier pizza places I’ve visited. The staff were extremely friendly and accommodating, which set the tone for a great night.

I ordered the “Special”, which is their signature dish and it was truly one of a kind! The thin crust had just the right amount of crunch and the toppings were incredibly fresh and flavorful. It was clear that they take great pride in their ingredients, as they should.

On top of that, I had one of their specialty cocktails which were surprisingly good considering how small Fumo is. It really made me appreciate how skillful their bartenders are at creating delicious drinks with limited resources.

Overall, my experience at Fumo Harlem was unbelievable and I definitely recommend it to anyone looking for one of the best pizzas in Harlem!

#8 Patsy’s Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of visiting this quaint, welcoming pizzeria and was wowed by the abundance of options they have to offer. With a variety of different styles and crusts, I couldn’t decide what to get! The staff was incredibly helpful in guiding me towards the perfect slice, which made my experience even better.

But what really impressed me was the taste! It was amazing. From New York-style thin crust to Sicilian deep dish, Patsy’s Pizzeria is sure to please. The freshly made dough combined with their secret blend of herbs and spices gave each bite an unforgettable flavor experience. And the sauce! Oh wow – it was the perfect balance of sweet and savory that just elevated my pizza eating experience.

In conclusion, if you love pizza, head to Patsy’s Pizzeria for some of the best pizza in Harlem! I highly recommend it for a great meal and an even greater time.

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!

#9 125th Pizza of Harlem

It’s definitely a hole-in-the-wall type of joint, but don’t let the no-frills atmosphere fool you – the food is really good!

I had the classic pepperoni pizza and it was cooked to perfection. The mozzarella cheese was melted to just the right consistency and the pepperonis were nice and crispy. The crust was thin yet flavorful and the sauce was packed with flavor.

On top of that, I found the staff to be friendly and helpful – something that goes a long way in making sure your dining experience is enjoyable.

Overall, if you’re looking for great pizza in Harlem, 125th Pizza of Harlem should definitely be at the top of your list. The pizza is delicious and the atmosphere is inviting – what more could you ask for?

#10 New Millennium

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew that my taste buds were in for a treat. The decor was fantastic, with little touches that really brought the vibe of Harlem alive.

The pizza was even better than the atmosphere. From the thin, crunchy crust to the perfectly cooked ingredients on top, every bite was delicious and cooked to perfection. The tomato sauce had just the right balance of sweetness and acidity and it worked wonderfully alongside the other flavors.

I especially enjoyed their signature pizzas like their BBQ Chicken Pizza and Classic Meat Lovers Pizza. Their appetizers were also excellent, particularly their Focaccia Bread.

All in all, New Millennium delivers an incredible experience – from the great service to the delicious food and atmosphere – that is sure to satisfy everyone’s pizza cravings! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Harlem, look no further than New Millennium!

#11 Jumbo

Picture this: The sun gleams off the freshly mopped floors, the savory aroma of fresh dough fills the air, and the smiling faces of the staff light up the room. It’s a pizza lover’s dream come true!

When I stepped foot inside Jumbo, I couldn’t believe my eyes – their extensive menu offers everything from classic margherita to meat-lovers feast pies. What’s more, each pizza is made with only the freshest ingredients – no frozen dough or pre-shredded cheese here!

The best part? Their prices are super reasonable. You can get a delicious pizza, salad, and drink deal for just under $10. Highly recommended!

All in all, I’ve got nothing but good things to say about Jumbo Pizza in Harlem. I’m confident you’ll love it as much as I did!