Best Pizza in Midlothian VA (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve been around the world searching for the ultimate pizza experience. And after 11 taste tests in Midlothian VA, I’m ready to share with you my ranking of the best pizza places.

From traditional thin crust pies to outrageous gourmet creations, it’s time to see if Midlothian VA is living up to my expectations. Fasten your seatbelts and prepare for a fun ride as we visit some of the most delicious and unique pizzas out there!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Virginia

#1 Brooklyn Pizza Authority

When I first stepped into the restaurant, I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere. The walls were lined with vintage photos of pizza-makers and their families, and the aroma of fresh-baked pies made my mouth water.

The pizza itself was outstanding — a thin crust with plenty of flavorful toppings that were cooked just right. I must admit, I am usually picky about my pizzas but this one was extraordinary! I also tried some of their signature sauces, which were out-of-this-world good.

The service at Brooklyn Pizza Authority was also top-notch. The staff greeted me warmly and went out of their way to make sure my experience was exceptional. They even gave me a free slice of cake when they heard it was my first visit — now that’s hospitality!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Midlothian VA, then look no further than Brooklyn Pizza Authority. Their combination of tasty pies and great service make it well worth the visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Chesterfield!

#2 Cabrera’s Pizza

The presentation alone will make your mouth water—the smell of the fresh ingredients and the bubbling cheese on top of freshly-baked crust is simply unparalleled. But it’s not just presentation—the taste of their pizza is out of this world! The sauce is perfectly spiced with a hint of sweetness, the cheese is perfectly gooey and melts in your mouth, and the crust is just thick enough for your preferred style. Plus, they have a wide variety of topping combinations that makes their pizzas incredibly unique.

I can confidently recommend Cabrera’s Pizza to anybody in Midlothian VA looking for great pizza. It truly tastes like no other pizza I’ve had before—it’s honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had!

#3 Sergio’s Pizza

The first time I stopped into Sergio’s, the atmosphere was a bit intimidating. There were pictures of old Italian men in suspenders decorating the walls and I could here opera playing in the background. But that all disappeared when I took my first bite of their pizza.

The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy with just the right amount of charring on the edges for flavor. The sauce had sweet notes that balanced out well with the salty cheese and savory toppings. It was definitely something special! Their specialty pie, “The Old-Fashioned,” is an absolute must-try with its unique blend of herbs, spices and cheeses.

Overall, Sergio’s Pizza is an excellent place to satisfy your pizza cravings – whether it’s for dine-in or takeout. Every slice is made with love, quality ingredients, and a whole lot of pride!

#4 Cousin Vinny’s Pizza

When I walked into Cousin Vinny’s, their relaxed atmosphere and exposed brick walls provided a welcoming environment—the perfect place for pizza that can stand up to my high standards.

The freshness of the ingredients was obvious, and as for the taste? To die for! The crust was perfectly crisp and crunchy—just how it should be. The toppings were generous and flavorful, providing an unforgettable combination of flavors. Plus, the special hot sauce they gave me actually succeeded in elevating the pizza to something truly special!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Midlothian VA (and even around the world!), then Cousin Vinny’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out. Not only will you get an amazing meal that satisfies your stomach and your taste buds, but you’ll also enjoy a unique dining experience in a cozy atmosphere.

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Richmond!

#5 Vinny’s Italian Grill

My meal started off with the all-time favorite, garlic knots – a must try, they were amazing! The dough was soft and perfectly cooked, and oozing with garlicky goodness.

Next up was the pizza. And let me tell you – it was delicious! The cheese was melted to perfection with a slight crisp on the bottom of the crust. The toppings were fresh and plentiful and all around it had an amazing flavor profile that exploded in my mouth.

The atmosphere of Vinny’s Italian Grill adds to the whole experience. Its warm and inviting interior creates a cozy vibe that’s perfect for catching up with friends, or just enjoying some old-fashioned comfort food.

Overall, I highly recommend Vinny’s Italian Grill! The pizza is exquisite and will make any pizza lover jump for joy!

#6 Mike’s Pizza & Grill

The pizza is freshly made and the crust is perfectly crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Their topping selection could give a five-star Italian restaurant a run for its money; their Italian sausage is especially delicious. I might have to come back just for that!

The service at Mike’s Pizza & Grill is impeccable. They always greet you with a smile, quick to get your order taken, and there’s never any waiting time. Plus, they always remember my order from last visit, even though it was months ago!

To top it all off, the atmosphere at Mike’s Pizza & Grill is cozy yet vibrant. Wood paneling lines the walls and the music creates an exciting yet relaxing vibe – perfect for unwinding after a long day or gathering with family or friends. It doesn’t get much better than this!

Bottom line: If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Midlothian VA, look no further than Mike’s Pizza & Grill! Five stars all around!

#7 Joe’s Pizza & Subs

I was blown away by the incredible selection and quality of the pizza. From classic cheese to triple pepperoni, they have it all! The crust is perfectly crispy and the crust is thick but not too thick.

The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and all the ingredients combine to make a perfect pizza. I had the Hawaiian Supreme with extra pineapple – perfection!

The subs are also delicious, and I’d recommend getting an Italian Deluxe with extra Giardiniera – you won’t regret it! Plus their prices are very reasonable for great quality food.

If this wasn’t enough, Joe’s Pizza & Subs also offers catering for events or parties, which is great. All in all, Joe’s Pizza & Subs definitely lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in Midlothian VA!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Henrico!

#8 Marco’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed was the friendly atmosphere in the restaurant. The staff was really welcoming and it felt like I was at home. Every pizza I had there was remarkably delicious and they had an excellent selection of toppings. Every time, the crust was perfectly crispy, golden brown on the outside, with a soft interior that just melted in your mouth. The cheese to topping ratio exceeded my expectations with each slice.

I can confidently recommend Marco’s Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Midlothian VA. As a traveling food critic, I’ve been around the world tasting pizza, but none have compared to Marco’s Pizza!

#9 Domino’s Pizza

I’ve sampled pizza from far-flung places like Italy, Thailand, and Mexico, but the deliciousness of Domino’s Pizza is undeniable. The cheese is gooey and the crust just the right crispness. And it comes with a variety of toppings to choose from – so many that I’m never able to make up my mind!

The atmosphere of Domino’s really sets it apart from other pizza restaurants. With it’s bright colors, upbeat music, and friendly staff, I can’t help but feel at home when I’m there.

But what makes Domino’s truly special is its commitment to quality. They use only fresh ingredients in all their pizzas and offer a wide range of options for those with dietary restrictions. It’s clear that they take pride in their product!

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Midlothian VA, you’d be hard-pressed to find better than Domino’s Pizza. Trust me – I’ve been around the world tasting pizza so I ought to know!

#10 Chanello’s Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy, with plenty of space to spread out. The staff is friendly, even when I asked for extra cheese on every slice. And the pizza itself? Delicious! From the crispy crust to the zesty sauce, it was obvious that the chefs at Chanello’s take great pride in their pies.

I tried both cheese and pepperoni pizza during my visit and I was impressed with both of them. The cheese had that perfect balance of stringy melted cheese, thick crust, and zesty tomatoes. And the pepperoni? It was loaded with flavorful slices that were cooked to perfection.

Overall, my experience at Chanello’s Pizza was one I won’t forget soon – from the people to the food itself – this place is definitely worth a visit if you find yourself in Midlothian VA looking for some delicious pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 52 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Williamsburg!

#11 Gino’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

On my visit to Gino’s, I was amazed by the delicious selection of pizza on offer. With more than 10 different toppings available and all of them freshly made, I was truly spoiled for choice! The atmosphere in the restaurant is also fantastic; it’s cozy and inviting, just like an Italian trattoria!

The pizza itself is where Gino’s really shines. They use only quality ingredients and the cooking process is carefully monitored to ensure that each pizza comes out perfectly cooked with a delicious crust and melted cheese. The flavors are vibrant without being overwhelming and they compliment each other perfectly.

If there’s one thing that stands out above all else at Gino’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant, it has to be the service. Everyone involved in my meal was friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, making sure that I had a great experience from start to finish.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Midlothian VA, then Gino’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant has got you covered! Highly recommended from this world traveler!