Best Pizza in Morristown NJ (Updated Jan 2023)

I’m here sampling the 11 best pizza places in town and am ready to tell you who makes the cream of the crop. But first, some background on my qualifications: I’ve been around the world eating pizza, so I bring a wealth of experience when it comes to ranking pies.

Of course, personal preference plays a major role in what makes good or bad pizza. That’s why my opinion should be taken with a grain of salt. I’m going to give you a humorous and light-hearted review of each pizza joint. So let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 A Legna Wood Fired Pizza

My trip to A Legna started before I could even walk through the door. As soon as I stepped off the curb, the wonderful smell of cooking pizzas that wafted out to me was mesmerizing. The smells of fresh dough and sauces were enough to make me forget my own name!

Once inside, I knew immediately that this place was special. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming – perfect for a casual dinner out. The staff are friendly and accommodating and made sure that all my needs were met, including accommodating my vegan friend (they have great vegan toppings too!).

But, of course, we all came here for the pizza and this did not disappoint! The house specialty is their wood fired pizzas which are simply unbeatable. Cooked in a wood-fired oven over an open flame, these pizzas had amazing flavor and crunchy edges. And if you need something different from pizza, they offer wood-fired appetizers like roasted Brussels sprouts with balsamic glaze or roasted cauliflower with garlic herb butter.

In short, A Legna Wood Fired Pizza is definitely one of Morristown NJ’s best spots for authentic Italian pizza. If it’s good enough for a world-traveling food critic like me, it’s definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Madison!

#2 Verrilli’s

The atmosphere alone could make it the crown jewel of Morristown’s pizza restaurants. The warm decor and inviting atmosphere had me feeling right at home as soon as I walked in.

The food was even better than I expected. The crust was thin, but not too thin. The cheese was gooey and flavorful, and the sauce had just the right amount of garlic and herbs. My favorite topping combination was sausage, peppers, and onions – it all worked together perfectly!

The service was also top-notch. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable, answering any questions we had with a smile on her face. I felt like royalty while dining there!

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Morristown NJ, look no further than Verrilli’s! My search for great pizza is officially over – this place is definitely a keeper!

#3 Coniglio’s Old Fashioned

The restaurant itself has an inviting and cozy atmosphere that feels like you’re coming home. The smells emanating from the kitchen are tantalizing and make your mouth water in anticipation of your meal.

The service was top notch; the staff was very attentive to my needs, quickly refilling my drink when needed and making sure I had everything I needed for a comfortable meal.

The pizza itself is what made Coniglio’s stand out in a crowd! It had just the right amount of sauce, cheese and toppings that made every bite a mouth-watering experience. Plus, they have some vegetarian options if that’s your thing!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery; you’ll have to get up off the couch, dust off your shoes, and head on over to Coniglio’s Old Fashioned if you want one of their delicious pies. But trust me – it’s worth it!

Overall, I would highly recommend Coniglio’s Old Fashioned if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Morristown NJ!

#4 Dominicks Pizza LLC

The first thing that stood out to me was the smell. The dough was baking in the oven, and it reminded me of being back home with my family. The crust was thin and crispy, while still maintaining its classic Italian texture.

The sauce was exactly what I expect from an Italian eatery–rich, thick, and full of flavor. My favorite topping combination is their mushroom and pepperoni pizza. It’s got all the flavors of a classic Italian pie, but still packed with some extra punch from all their different toppings.

I’m also impressed with the service at Dominicks Pizza LLC – they were friendly and knowledgeable about the different pizzas they had on offer. I even got a free dessert for ordering two large pizzas!

Overall, Dominicks Pizza LLC is definitely one of my top picks when it comes to finding great pizza in Morristown NJ. Their food is consistently delicious and their staff always adds a personal touch to make every visit special. If you’re ever looking for an amazing slice of pizza near Morristown, Dominick’s Pizza LLC should be your first stop!

#5 Pomodoro Ristorante & Pizzeria

I was skeptical of the claims that I had heard, but my doubts were quickly assuaged when my first bite of their pepperoni pizza hit my taste buds. The combination of bold flavors and perfectly cooked crust had me going back for more!

The staff at Pomodoro Ristorante & Pizzeria are friendly and helpful. They always made sure that all my needs were met, from ordering to getting me extra napkins for all the cheese sliding off my slice.

The atmosphere of Pomodoro Ristorante & Pizzeria is great as well. There’s a cozy feeling inside, making it comfortable enough to linger even after you’ve finished devouring your pizza.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Morristown NJ, look no further than Pomodoro Ristorante & Pizzeria! I’d give them an A+ rating for their excellent pizza and customer service.

#6 Annabella’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

I am so impressed with their selection and the quality of their eats. The decor is inviting, the staff are friendly, and the atmosphere is a pizza-lover’s dream.

I started out with their famous “Annabella’s Special” which was a supreme pizza loaded with all my favorite toppings. The sauce was perfectly balanced and had just the right amount of kick to it while still allowing the flavors of the meats, cheese, and vegetables to shine. It truly was a feast for all my senses!

Next I tried the “Outrageous Pepperoni”, which not only lived up to its name but exceeded my expectations! This one had more pepperoni than I’ve ever seen in one place before and it was cooked perfectly – crisp on the outside with just enough moisture in the middle for maximum flavor. I also really enjoyed their “Artichoke Delight” which was surprisingly light yet still tasted like a slice from heaven.

In addition to great food, Annabella’s also offer delicious beers as well as wine and specialty cocktails made from premium spirits. And if that wasn’t enough, they also have live entertainment on weekends for those looking for an evening full of fun!

All in all, I highly recommend this restaurant – from the ambiance and service to the quality of their pizzas – you won’t be disappointed when you visit Annabella’s Pizzeria & Restaurant!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Morris Plains!

#7 Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I could tell this place was special. The atmosphere and decor were inviting and the staff was incredibly friendly.

The pizza is truly unique and delicious! Every topping is fresh and carefully selected to create a one-of-a-kind flavor experience that’s hard to beat. My personal favorite was the pork sausage with banana peppers—it had an amazing texture, just the right amount of heat, and no grease whatsoever.

But it’s not just about the pizza at Millie’s! The meatballs are also fantastic! They come in a variety of flavors like spicy chorizo, Parmesan garlic, and even vegan options—all equally delicious!

Overall, I highly recommend Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite to eat or a full meal with friends, they have something for everyone—and it’s all tasty!

#8 Morris Pizzeria

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for enjoying a slice in the comfort of your own home. I was happy to find that the menu was full of delicious options – from traditional Chicago-style deep dish to more exotic creations like BBQ chicken.

The pizza itself was fantastic. The crust was perfectly cooked and had a nice crunch when I bit into it. The sauce was robust and flavorful, with just enough cheese to bring out the flavor. The toppings were fresh and juicy, making this one of the best pizzas I have ever had.

The service was equally impressive. Despite being a busy night in the restaurant, our server was friendly, attentive and quick to answer any questions we had about the menu items.

Overall, it’s no surprise why Morris Pizzeria is one of the best pizza spots in Morristown NJ! It’s definitely worth a visit next time you’re looking for an amazing slice!

#9 Mangiano Pizza Restaurant & Catering

The atmosphere and decor of the restaurant is very inviting. The walls are lined with old posters advertising classic Italian films and the tables are covered in checkered tablecloths. It really feels like a traditional Italian pizzeria!

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. Wow, it’s delicious! Their crusts are thick but still retain their crunchiness and the flavors of the toppings pop with each bite. There’s something for everyone on their menu from classic pepperoni to gourmet creations like fig and prosciutto. All I can say is that if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Morristown NJ, then Mangiano Pizza Restaurant & Catering should be your first stop!

#10 Lovey’s Pizza & Grill

The atmosphere of the restaurant was very cozy, almost like being at home. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that I had a great experience.

Now let’s talk pizza. Lovey’s blows its competitors out of the water with its delicious pizzas. The crust is perfectly thin yet fluffy, and the sauce is just the right amount of sweet and spicy. The toppings are fresh, generous, and cooked to perfection – making each bite even more delicious than the last!

I couldn’t get enough of Lovey’s pizza. It definitely lives up to its reputation as the best pizza in Morristown NJ! If you’re looking for a delicious pizza experience, look no further than Lovey’s Pizza & Grill!

#11 Milan Pizzeria

The first time I walked into Milan Pizzeria, I knew it was going to be special. The smell of freshly made pizza dough and garlic wafted through the air, and my mouth began to water in anticipation.

When I ordered a large pepperoni pizza, the chef gave me a knowing nod – as if he had been expecting me. He went about his business with a level of passion and artistry that can only come from years of experience working with pizza dough. And indeed it showed – when my pizza came out, it was like looking at a piece of edible art!

The pepperoni melted perfectly on top of the thin crust, and each bite was filled with flavor. The fresh ingredients added to the deliciousness and made for an unforgettable meal. Even the sauce had subtle hints of oregano that lingered in my mouth long after I finished eating.

I’m glad to report that Milan Pizzeria lives up to its reputation as being one of the best pizzerias in Morristown NJ! Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Parsippany!