Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in South Carolina

Best Pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

25 Views

I’m sure all of my fellow pizza lovers have spent too much time agonizing over the choice of which pizzeria to visit. Well, now you can relax and just follow my tummy-satisfying recommendation!

I recently went on a mission to find the best pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp, sampling 12 different establishments. The search was long and arduous but so worth it in the end! From New York style pies to traditional Sicilian slices, I found some delicious options that were totally unique and tasty.

So join me on this tasty journey as I share with you the top choices for the best pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of South Carolina

#1 Coast Pizza

I had the pleasure of visiting Coast Pizza recently, and I must say that it was truly worth the trip. From the moment I stepped foot in the joint, I was surprised by how cozy and inviting it felt. The interior is decorated with coastal-themed murals and artworks – really setting a beachy mood right away.

The menu offers a diverse selection of pizza styles and toppings, including vegan options as well. So no matter what your dietary preferences are, you’ll be sure to find something delicious on the menu. I had their signature seafood pie – made with shrimp, clams, mussels and scallops – and it was absolutely out of this world! It was the perfect balance between cheesy goodness and salty seafood flavor – a must-try for any pizza lover.

The service at Coast Pizza is also top notch; they were very friendly and accommodating when I visited. And not to mention – the prices are quite reasonable too!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp (and beyond!) then Coast Pizza should definitely be on your list. This place is a true gem and an absolute must-visit if you’re ever in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in North Myrtle Beach!

#2 AJ’S Pizza Myrtle Beach

I was excited to finally make it here after I heard the rave reviews from friends and family. My anticipation only heightened as I drove into their parking lot and saw the bright, inviting sign that beckoned me to come in with gastronomic delights.

As soon as I stepped through the front door, I knew this place meant business. The inviting smell of garlic and cheese hit my nostrils like a freight train, sparking my appetite into overdrive!

The interior is just how you’d expect a good pizza joint should be; cozy and inviting, with plenty of tables for groups, couples or solo diners. The staff welcomed us warmly and checked us in, we were promptly seated at our table.

The menu had a lot of mouth-watering options to choose from – enough to make any pizza connoisseur salivate! With careful consideration of both classic fan favorites and unique new creations, I ultimately decided on their special – Pineapple Chicken Pizza.

My order arrived piping hot in no time at all and it was simply delicious! The sweet pineapple blended perfectly with the savory chicken slices, all cradled within an irresistible combination of melted cheeses and perfectly charred crust. Overall this pie definitely hit the spot!

AJ’S Pizza Myrtle Beach is most definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town looking for some great pizza – trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

#3 Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza

Upon entering, I was immediately enveloped in the aroma of fresh, delicious pizza. The ingredients on the menu all looked appetizing and each pizza had a unique flavor to it. Things like garlic, oregano, basil, and tomatoes only added to the amazing smell that was coming out of their ovens.

The crusts were thin and crunchy, yet still had just enough doughiness to satisfy my cravings for bread. Toppings were generous and generously applied – no skimping here! The sauce was thick and zesty yet not too overpowering and blended perfectly with the flavors of the other ingredients.

My favorite pizza from Toffino’s has to be their Margherita Pizza – lightly charred edges topped with mozarella cheese, tomatoes, basil leaves & a sprinkle of sea salt truly make it a divine combination. Each bite is simply stunning! On top of all that, their prices are quite reasonable for people on a budget.

If you’re looking for some quality Italian style pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp that won’t break the bank, then look no further than Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza! It clearly deserves it’s reputation as one of the best pizzerias around!

#4 Scotto’s Pizzeria

I’m here to report that the pizza dough was fresh, homemade and perfectly cooked. The tomato sauce had a nice balance of sweetness, acidity, and just the right amount of spice. As for the cheese, it was creamy and flavorful – definitely top notch!

The toppings at Scotto’s Pizzeria were also impressive. I tried several different combinations, including sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and spinach. Each one was delicious!

The atmosphere at Scotto’s Pizzeria was also very welcoming. The staff is friendly and professional. Plus, they have plenty of TVs and games to keep you entertained while you wait for your order to be ready.

Overall, I can confidently say that Scotto’s Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp. If you’re looking for a well-made pie with tasty toppings, look no further than Scotto’s Pizzeria!

#5 Vicini’s Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of dining here and it was a great experience. The atmosphere was wonderful and the staff was delightful. Plus, they have a kid’s menu and some vegetarian options, so everyone can find something to eat!

The pizza itself is absolutely delicious! They have an extensive menu with all kinds of toppings, so there’s something for everyone. And if you’re looking to indulge afterwards, they even offer dessert!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery-but their location is quite convenient and makes for a nice tourist spot too. Plus, they serve alcohol-which I definitely enjoyed 🙂

All in all, I highly recommend Vicini’s Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria for anyone looking for great pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp!

#6 Little Italy

The crust was airy and perfectly cooked, the cheese perfectly melted and mozzarella-tastic, and the sauce full of flavor. It all added up to a simply spectacular pizza experience.

Not to mention that Little Italy has some of the most generous portions I’ve ever seen. Two slices felt like four or five! But unlike some places where this is accomplished by skimping on toppings, every slice was loaded with generous amounts of whatever I chose.

As if that’s not enough, the staff at Little Italy was among the friendliest I have encountered in any pizza joint. They made sure my visit was an enjoyable one, and it’s clear they take pride in their restaurant.

If you ever find yourself in Myrtle Beach Yelp, make sure you stop by Little Italy for some of the best pizza you will ever taste—in this country or abroad!

#7 Mellow Mushroom Myrtle Beach

The service is top-notch and the atmosphere is laid back and perfect for an evening out or solo dining. The menu has a great selection of specialty pizzas and creative toppings, so no matter what your tastes are, you’re sure to find something to love.

My personal favorite was the classic Margherita pizza topped with fresh basil, diced tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese. It was cooked perfectly so it wasn’t soggy but still had a crispy crust. The homemade garlic knots were also amazing! They were made from scratch with rosemary, Parmesan cheese and butter – can’t get much better than that!

The cocktails are really unique too. They offer craft beers, sangrias, margaritas and more. If you’d like to try something new, I recommend the ruby red grapefruit martini – it’s tart but sweet at the same time.

Overall, I give Mellow Mushroom Myrtle Beach two thumbs up! Their carefully crafted menu items combined with their friendly atmosphere ensures you will have a delicious meal every time you visit.

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Conway!

#8 Capriccio

Their alcohol selection is top notch and it’s great that they serve hard liquor – something I don’t find in other pizza joint options. They have an amazing kid’s menu, as well as vegetarian options for my more health conscious friends. Their dessert options are insanely good too – every time I go I can’t help but order an extra slice of their famous cheesecake!

As far as tourist spots go, this place can’t be beat. It’s the perfect place to grab a couple slices when you’re out sightseeing with the family. The only downside? They don’t offer delivery services. But if you want to experience some of the best pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp, then Capriccio is worth a visit!

#9 Ultimate California Pizza

From the moment I walked into the restaurant, it was obvious that this place takes their pizza seriously. The smell of freshly baked pizza and the sound of bubbling sauce filled the air with culinary perfection.

The staff was friendly and accommodating, asking me what type of crust I wanted and making sure to use only the highest quality ingredients. When my pizza arrived, it was a sight to behold – thin, crispy crust with delicious cheese and toppings all cooked to perfection in a wood-burning oven.

I could tell that every step of their process is carefully orchestrated to create the perfect pie, from selecting high quality ingredients to cooking up their pizzas in traditional Italian style with a light, crispy crust that is both crunchy and chewy at the same time.

I’m happy I made my way here because Ultimate California Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp! If you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience, then this place should be your top pick!

#10 Extreme Pizza Myrtle Beach

On my first visit, I was presented with a huge menu boasting every kind of pizza I could imagine! From classic pepperoni to outrageous combos like mac and cheese and garlic chicken, Extreme Pizza offered something for everyone.

I opted for a classic Margherita pizza. To say the least, I was blown away. The crust was delightfully crunchy and flavorful, while the fresh mozzarella melted in my mouth. The tomatoes were ripe and sweet; they truly added a great balance to the savory dish.

Plus, this place had an excellent atmosphere to boot! With lively music playing and friendly staff members, it’s no wonder why they have some of the best ratings on Myrtle Beach Yelp!

It’s safe to say that Extreme Pizza is one of my new favorite places – definitely check out this spot if you’re ever in town!

#11 Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria

What can I say about Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria? The pizza is simply delicious! The dough is light and fluffy, the crust crispy and thin, and the toppings are plentiful. Plus, the prices are quite reasonable.

The atmosphere at Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria is warm and inviting. From the moment you walk in, you feel like you’re part of a family. The staff is friendly and helpful, always willing to answer your questions about their food or suggest a great pairing for your meal.

I tried two pizzas here – one traditional margarita pizza with tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, garlic and olive oil; and another with grana padano cheese, sausage, pepperoncinis and mushrooms. Both had incredible flavor — richly cheesy with a hint of smokiness from the sausage — yet still managed to remain incredibly airy in texture. Wow!

I can honestly say that Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria serves some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted — not just in Myrtle Beach Yelp but anywhere I’ve been! If you’re ever in town, be sure to check them out. You won’t regret it.

#12 Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill

When I first walked in, I was immediately attracted to the smell of freshly baked pizza pies. There was an entire wall of various sized pizza pans waiting to be filled with delicious combinations of toppings. The atmosphere was lively and the servers were friendly and knowledgeable.

The menu had some unique twists on classic pizzas, such as a veggie-centric BBQ chicken pizza, as well as more traditional offerings like pepperoni and sausage. They also offer a variety of pastas from classic favorites like lasagna to more daring options such as jambalaya pasta.

I went with the BBQ chicken pizza topped with cilantro and pineapple, which they called the ‘Carolina Dream’. It was unlike any pizza I have ever tasted before! The sweetness of the barbecue sauce complimented perfectly with the tanginess of pineapple along with fresh cilantro; it was divine!

I highly recommend Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill if you’re looking for a unique take on classic dishes that will excite your taste buds and satisfy your pizza cravings. After all, hands down this is one of the best places for delicious pizza in Myrtle Beach Yelp!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Hungry Howie’s Pizza

Picture this: you’ve just spent the day lounging on the beautiful beaches of Myrtle Beach, working up quite the appetite. You stumble upon Hungry Howie’s Pizza, and let me tell you, it’s like finding a hidden treasure amidst the sandcastles.

Let’s start with the main attraction: the deep dish pizza. Oh boy, it’s a gastronomic work of art. The crust is so thick and fluffy, it’s like biting into a cloud made of pizza. The cheese stretches for miles, and the toppings are so plentiful, you’ll wonder if they’ve mistaken your order for a deluxe buffet. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you cancel your gym membership and embrace your newfound love handles.

But here’s the funny thing about Hungry Howie’s – they offer dessert! Yes, you heard me right. Who needs a beach bod when you can sink your teeth into their gooey, chocolatey brownies? It’s a beautiful collision of sweetness and regret, and trust me, it’s worth it.

Now, I must warn you, hungry traveler, that Hungry Howie’s does have one downside: they don’t accept reservations. So expect to arrive and wait for a table, just like every other pizza lover drawn to this heavenly wonderland. But take my word for it, it’s worth the wait. Plus, it’s a great opportunity to bond with your fellow pizza enthusiasts and perhaps even exchange some secret topping combinations.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a pizza joint that offers the best deep dish pizza in Myrtle Beach, look no further than Hungry Howie’s Pizza. Just be prepared to indulge in some mouthwatering goodness, and leave your reservations (both literal and metaphorical) at the door.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria

Myrtle Beach, known for its gorgeous beaches and stunning views, may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of pizza. But let me tell you, Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria is here to change your mind – and your taste buds!

As I walked into the restaurant, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was so friendly, I couldn’t help but get excited about the delicious pizza they were about to serve me. And boy, did they deliver!

The first bite into their thin crust pizza was like a taste explosion in my mouth. The crust was perfectly crisp, just the right amount of chewy, and beautifully topped with a generous amount of cheese and flavorful toppings. It was like the pizza gods themselves had crafted this masterpiece specifically for me.

But it wasn’t just the crust that made Ducatis stand out. The sauce, oh the sauce! It was tangy, zesty, and had just the right amount of spice to make my taste buds dance with joy. And let me tell you, the toppings were not to be overlooked either. From the classic margherita to the more adventurous buffalo chicken, each slice was bursting with flavor.

So, if you find yourself in Myrtle Beach and craving some amazing thin crust pizza, make a beeline straight for Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria. Your taste buds will thank you, and you may find yourself booking a return trip to Myrtle Beach just for another slice of their heavenly pizza.