Best Pizza in Olathe KS (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve tasted pizza all over the world from Rome to Hong Kong, so I can confidently say it’s one of my favorite foods! But when I came across Olathe KS, the thin crust pies there almost blew me away. The 11 pizza places I visited during my time there put even my most favorite Italian pizzas to shame.

With a humorous and lighthearted tone, I’m excited to share with you my picks for the best pizza in Olathe KS!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Kansas

#1 Sarpino’s Pizzeria

The crust is perfectly crispy yet still thin and pliable – the hallmark of an authentic Italian-style pizza. The cheese has a great flavor and is melted just right, while the sauce is fresh, lightly spiced and really brings out the flavors of the toppings.

Speaking of toppings, Sarpino’s offers a huge selection to choose from – everything from classic pepperoni and mushroom to more unusual combinations like BBQ chicken, feta cheese and bacon. No matter which topping you choose, it’s sure to be cooked to perfection and make your pizza truly special.

And let’s not forget about their specialty pizzas! Whether you’re in the mood for Alfredo pesto or Mediterranean delight, you won’t be disappointed. Each one is made with care from high quality ingredients so that every bite is delicious.

For those who prefer something other than pizza, Sarpino’s also offers sandwiches, salads and pasta dishes. Everything I’ve tried here has been amazing – even their side orders like garlic knots are really good!

I can honestly say that Sarpino’s Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Olathe KS – if you’re ever in town I highly recommend checking them out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Overland Park!

#2 MOD Pizza

The experience of eating at MOD was absolutely amazing. The combination of their fresh ingredients and made-to-order pizzas left me wanting more! I started with the classic Model Dough pizza on a white sauce base, however once they added all their signature toppings it tasted even better than I’d imagined.

The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating, asking detailed questions about my preferences before creating the perfect pizza for me. After biting into my first slice, I knew I had stumbled upon something special.

The atmosphere inside MOD is also worth noting. They have a vibrant environment that makes you feel like you’re dining out in Italy rather than Kansas. The music selection was especially great – they played classic Italian tunes throughout my meal that put me in an incredible mood.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Olathe KS, then MOD Pizza is definitely the place to go!

#3 SPIN! Pizza

I’ve been to pizzerias from Italy to New York and I can honestly say that SPIN! Pizza is up there with the best. The crust has just the right amount of crunch, and the toppings are flavorful and plentiful. Everything was cooked to perfection – slightly crispy on the outside and wonderfully chewy on the inside.

The atmosphere of SPIN! Pizza is also a plus. It’s a lively yet friendly place where everyone can feel at home. There’s a great selection of craft beers on tap, so you can truly relax while enjoying your favorite pizza. Plus, they serve some delicious desserts as well!

Overall, I’d highly recommend it for anyone looking for what I now believe is the best pizza in Olathe KS (and beyond!). With its top-notch ingredients, attentive staff and inviting atmosphere, SPIN! Pizza really does live up to its name. Bon appetit!

#4 Sarpino’s Pizzeria Olathe

My journey began when I entered the restaurant and was immediately struck by the inviting atmosphere and delicious aromas that greeted me. The staff were friendly and attentive, which only added to the enjoyable dining experience.

I decided to try their signature Sarpino’s Supreme pizza, which was a great choice! The crust was cooked perfectly, with an extra crunchy exterior. The cheese was stretchy and gooey, and the toppings were spread evenly throughout.

The marinara sauce had just enough tanginess to stand out without overpowering the other flavors. It felt like a truly special pizza that could rival anything I’ve tasted in Europe or Australia!

All in all, Sarpino’s Pizzeria Olathe is a superb eatery that serves some of the best pizza in Olathe KS. If you find yourself in Olathe, be sure to visit this establishment – they won’t disappoint!

#5 Toni’s Italian Restaurant

I was a bit hesitant when I first heard about Toni’s Italian Restaurant, with its unassuming location and uninspiring decor. But after one bite of their pizza, I knew that my preconceived notions were wrong.

The pizza is simply spectacular! From the perfect crust to the flavorful sauce, every bite was pure perfection. The cheese is perfectly melted and they use only the freshest ingredients. The pepperoni was even nice and crispy. It tasted like it had been made right in front of me, which is exactly how pizza should be done.

Service at Toni’s is also top-notch. Everyone there is friendly and eager to help you out with whatever you need. They also have great drink options, making it easy to enjoy your meal with a beverage of your choice.

If you’re in Olathe KS and looking for some great pizza, then look no further than Toni’s Italian Restaurant – it will not disappoint!

#6 Minsky’s Pizza

I knew this was a special place when I saw the wood-fired ovens, imported Italian ingredients, and hand-crafted dough. But it wasn’t until I took the first bite that I realized how truly amazing their pizza is.

The crust was perfectly light and fluffy, with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was zesty and flavorful, yet still subtle enough for me to enjoy the real star of the show –the cheese. It was some of the freshest mozzarella I have ever tasted! As for toppings – they have something for everyone. My favorite was their ‘Meat Lover’s Pizza’, which had sausage, pepperoni, and bacon all cooked to perfection.

Overall, Minsky’s Pizza not only met my high expectations; it exceeded them! If you ever find yourself in Olathe KS looking for the best pizza around then you owe it to yourself to go check out Minsky’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Pizza Shuttle

From the moment I walked into Pizza Shuttle, I was thrust into a pizza lover’s paradise. Inside this cozy spot, the smells of vine ripened tomatoes and fragrant basil combined to create a tantalizing aroma that set my stomach growling in anticipation.

The staff at Pizza Shuttle were nothing short of amazing. Everyone was friendly and attentive, making sure that all my needs were met. They even took the time to explain their menu offerings so that I could make an informed decision about what to order.

As for the pizza itself, it definitely lived up to the hype! The dough was perfectly crispy on the outside yet still fluffy on the inside – exactly how great pizza should be! The sauce was rich and flavorful with just the right amount of sweetness, while all other toppings were fresh and flavorful. It tasted like no other pizza I’ve ever had before – amazing!

At Pizza Shuttle you definitely get more than your money’s worth. With great service, delicious food and a cozy atmosphere, it’s no surprise why this place is one of Olathe KS’s best pizzerias!

#8 Minsky’s Pizza

My first impression when I walked in the restaurant was that there was a laid back and cozy atmosphere. The staff were all friendly and helpful, which made my visit even more enjoyable.

The menu had an impressive selection of options, from classic Italian to specialty flavors. I decided to go with their signature Minsky’s Deluxe Pizza, which did not disappoint! It was loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers and cheese!

The crust was perfect; it had just the right amount of crunch and tasted like it came straight out of the oven! The toppings were all delicious as well- the pepperoni was perfectly salty and the sausage was so flavorful.

I have to say that my experience at Minsky’s Pizza truly exceeded expectations. From its delightful atmosphere to its mouthwatering pizza, I can honestly say that this place is one of the best pizza restaurants in Olathe KS!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Kansas City!

#9 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

It was a great experience. I walked in, and the staff were friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was inviting and it smelled delicious. I ordered their signature Papa Murphy’s Original Combo Pizza and it was simply amazing.

The crust was mouth-watering, with perfect amounts of doughy goodness. The sauce was robust yet not overpowering, leaving the other toppings to shine through. The toppings were plentiful, from pepperonis to mushrooms to olives, each slice boasted its own unique flavor profile. Once cooked in my own oven at home the pizza melted together into an excellent pizza masterpiece that I couldn’t get enough of.

I’ve definitely found the best pizza in Olathe KS! I highly recommend checking out Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza!

#10 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The selection of pizzas at this place is amazing – there’s something for everyone! From classic pepperoni and margherita to vegetable-packed delights and white sauces, you can get whatever your heart desires. Plus, the prices are more than reasonable.

Let’s talk quality – I’m always a bit skeptical about places that offer pre-made and take-out options, but I’m pleased to say that Papa Murphy’s impressed me in this regard. The crust was light and fluffy, the toppings were full of flavor and generously applied, and the sauce was fantastic. All in all, it made for a top-notch pizza experience.

The service here was also excellent – the staff were friendly and helpful throughout my visit, which is always appreciated.

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Olathe KS, head on over to Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza – it won’t disappoint!

#11 Old Shawnee Pizza & Craft Cocktails-Lenexa

The first thing that struck me about this pizza joint was the inviting atmosphere. The decor was modern yet cozy, making it a great place to gather with friends and family. The tables were spaced out nicely and the staff was extremely helpful in accommodating our large group.

The pizzas here are top notch! They offer a variety of specialty pizzas as well as classic flavors like pepperoni, cheese, and veggie. The crust is hand-tossed and perfectly thin – not at all doughy! The toppings are fresh, flavorful, and plentiful. We especially enjoyed their unique combinations like the spicy Hawaiian BBQ pizza.

The craft cocktails are also noteworthy! Choose from a selection of inventive libations or go with a classic like an Old Fashioned. They even offer beer on tap for those that prefer a more traditional beverage to accompany their pizza.

All in all Old Shawnee Pizza & Craft Cocktails-Lenexa has some of the best pizza in Olathe KS and I would highly recommend it for anyone looking for an enjoyable night out or just a delicious pizza dinner with friends and family!