Best Pizza in Old Town Scottsdale (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve been around the world and tried various different versions of the classic Italian dish, but I must say, Old Town Scottsdale has some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. It was a tough decision to make, but I narrowed it down to my top 11 places. Let’s get started with my roundup of the best pizza in Old Town Scottsdale!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arizona

#1 Craft 64 (Scottsdale)

As soon as I walked in the door, I was struck by the inviting atmosphere. The place looked like it had been designed to deliver a pizza-lovers paradise. There were wood-fired pizzas with craft toppings, a variety of craft beers on tap, and an amazing selection of specialty crafted cocktails.

I decided to try some of their famous creative pizzas and was not disappointed. The crust was thin and crispy, the sauces were inventive without overpowering the other flavors, and the toppings meshed perfectly together. I especially loved their margherita pizza – the tomatoes tasted so fresh!

Aside from the great food, I really enjoyed the friendly vibe of this restaurant as well. Everyone from the waiters to the chefs seemed genuinely passionate about their craft! On top of that, they had great music playing in the background and had some fun activities for kids too.

In conclusion, Craft 64 (Scottsdale) is hands down one of my favorite spots for pizza in Old Town Scottsdale and I definitely recommend giving it a try if you’re in town! You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Tempe!

#2 Crisp Premium Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew that this place was going to be something special. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, complete with festive red and green decorations for the holidays.

My first impression of their pizza was one of awe and admiration – it was unlike any other pizza I had ever eaten before! The crust was crisp and light, while still maintaining a chewy texture. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese melted perfectly over everything.

I tried several different types of pizzas from Crisp Premium Pizza, including their classics such as the Margherita and Pepperoni. They also had unique offerings such as their BBQ Chicken or Spicy Jalapeno with Bacon pizzas. I could taste that each ingredient used in every creation was top-notch quality.

The best part about eating at Crisp Premium Pizza? Every slice is made with love! You can truly tell they take great pride in making every meal special for their guests.

If you’re looking for an amazing culinary experience in Old Town Scottsdale, look no further than Crisp Premium Pizza – they have some of the best pizza around!

#3 Pasta Brioni

The restaurant itself is a bit old-fashioned, but there’s something charming about that. The staff are welcoming and the vibe is cozy, so it makes for a great dining experience right away.

The pizza here is truly one of a kind—I was amazed at how flavorful every single bite was! The crust had the perfect amount of crunch to it and the toppings were top notch. There are plenty of options to choose from too, so there’s something for everyone.

But what really sets this place apart from the rest has to be their unique sauces. They have pesto, fig, and even truffle oil sauces that you can add to your pizza in order to take it up to the next level! I can honestly say that my experience here was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tried.

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience with plenty of flavor, Pasta Brioni is definitely worth visiting at least once!

#4 The Gelato Spot

The atmosphere is welcoming and inviting, whether you’re eating with a group or going in solo. The staff were all friendly and helpful – they even offered to let me sample some of the more unique toppings. As for the pizza itself, it was delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked and flavorful, the sauces were tasty (and not too greasy), and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. Plus, it had some unique flavor combinations that I haven’t seen anywhere else.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for an enjoyable evening out with great pizza,The Gelato Spot should be at the top of your list. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for one of the best pizzas in Old Town Scottsdale.

#5 Oregano’s

When I stepped through the door, an aroma of oregano and delicious carbs wafted through my nostrils. Everything I saw made my mouth water. From the folded slices of cheesy pepperoni to the thick, freshly-baked Sicilian pies, every pizza looked positively scrumptious.

The staff at Oregano’s was friendly and attentive. My order was taken quickly and they had recommendations for me that sounded mouth-wateringly good. Plus, they were more than happy to accommodate my requests for more peppers or extra olives on my pie!

When it finally arrived, the pizza was hot and cheesy with a few packets of oregano flakes sprinkled on top – just the way I like it! I demolished that first slice in no time flat and ordered another one right away. Delicious! There’s no doubt in my mind why Oregano’s has been voted best pizza in Old Town Scottsdale many times over.

If you’re ever looking for a great spot to grab some really tasty pizza, put Oregano’s at the top of your list! You won’t regret it.

#6 Pitch

First of all, the atmosphere at Pitch is unbeatable. The exposed brick walls give it a vintage vibe and the retro-style decor creates a fun and inviting atmosphere.

The crust deserves special mention. It’s as thin as can be without being brittle or soggy, and it’s got just the right amount of crunchiness to it. I thought the sauce was out of this world – it had a smooth consistency and really made my taste buds sing! The toppings were fresh and flavorful, ranging from classic favorites like pepperoni to more adventurous options like feta cheese.

Service-wise, Pitch hits it out of the park. Our waiter was attentive, courteous, and prompt; he made sure we never had to wait for anything. He also gave us great advice on which pizzas to try – his recommendations definitely didn’t disappoint!

Overall, I’d have to say that Pitch has some of the best pizza in Old Town Scottsdale – in fact, I’d even go so far as to say it’s on par with some of the best pizza places I’ve tried around the world! If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience during your next visit to Scottsdale, look no further than Pitch!

#7 Pomo Pizzeria Napoletana – Scottsdale

I’ve been to Italy, and I can honestly say that Pomo’s pizza tastes just like the real deal. The thin crust is perfectly cooked, with a hint of char that adds a bit of smokiness to every bite. The toppings are fresh and plentiful, with nothing too overpowering any of the other flavors.

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with wooden-paneled walls adding a rustic feel to the place. Service is friendly and efficient, making sure you get your food in no time.

Overall, I would highly recommend Pomo Pizzeria Napoletana – Scottsdale for anyone looking for great pizza in Old Town Scottsdale! Delicious food and friendly service make it one of my top choices for pizza in this area.

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Scottsdale!

#8 Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

From the moment I entered this restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The intense aroma of baking pizza filled the air and set my mouth to watering. For starters, I had the Garlic Knots which were delicious – delicately spiced and crunchy on the outside.

Then came my main attraction – a large pepperoni pizza with extra cheese! It was cooked to perfection – melted cheese layered between flavorful tomato sauce and generous helpings of pepperoni. The crust had a delightful crunch to it and it was so fresh that you could still taste the doughy flavor.

The staff at Grimaldi’s were friendly and attentive, making sure that I had everything that I needed throughout my meal. All in all, this restaurant delivered an unforgettable pizza experience, one that will bring me back time after time. Without hesitation, I would confidently rate Grimaldi’s Pizzeria as having some of the best pizza in Old Town Scottsdale!

#9 Pizzería Virtu

The atmosphere was definitely nice and welcoming, but the pizza is what really made my experience stand out. The crust was just the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy, and the toppings were cooked to perfection. What’s more is that they serve alcohol, so I could enjoy a beer with my meal!

Speaking of dessert, Pizzería Virtu offers some great options to satisfy your sweet tooth. Thankfully, I had enough room for a slice of their delicious tiramisu. It was heavenly!

The only downside of this spot is that they don’t offer delivery. But hey, it’s worth visiting this place any day of the week if you want to treat yourself to some mouthwatering pizza in Old Town Scottsdale!

#10 Barro’s Pizza

Let me tell you, the atmosphere of this pizzeria is top-notch. As soon as you walk in you are greeted with a friendly smile and the smells of freshly baked pizza dough. The decor is rustic and inviting, with booths and tables that invite you to linger.

Now onto the important part – the pizza! The crust is perfectly thin yet crispy, and holds up to all of their delicious toppings which include artichokes, Italian sausage, onions, olives and much more. Their selection of specialty pies are second-to-none in Old Town Scottsdale. They serve classic combinations such as Margherita and Pepperoni & Mushroom as well as unique creations like BBQ Pork and Chickpea Curry Pie. Whatever type of pizza you’re craving, Barro’s Pizza has got it!

The service here is great too – the staff is always happy to help with any questions or special requests you may have. The prices are reasonable too – they offer family size pies for a great price so everyone can enjoy a large slice of heaven without breaking the bank!

Overall, Barro’s Pizza is simply one of the best pizzerias around! If you’re ever in Old Town Scottsdale be sure to stop by for some delicious pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#11 Sauce

When I walked in to Sauce, I was immediately drawn in by the aroma of freshly-baked dough, bubbling cheese and zesty sauces. The inviting atmosphere only further heightened my anticipation for a delicious meal!

My loyal companion, Mr. Pepperoni Pizza, joined me at the table and we quickly perused the mouthwatering menu. I simply could not get enough of all the options available – from classic Margherita to specialty creations like BBQ Bacon Cheddar – so I decided to order one of each! (Yes, that’s how serious I am about pizza!)

When our pizzas arrived at the table, it was love at first sight. Every pie was cooked to perfection with a lightly charred crust and just the right amount of toppings. The cheese was melted perfectly and melted in my mouth with each bite. And the sauces! Oh yes, those sauces really packed some flavorful punches!

Thankfully none of us had food comas after polishing off all these delicious pizzas because then we would have missed out on their delectable dessert menu. With an incredible selection of cannolis, tiramisu and more – it honestly was hard to choose! But after much deliberation (and stomach growling), we eventually decided on everyone’s favorite: a classic slice of New York style cheesecake.

If you’re ever craving delicious pizza or heavenly desserts, look no further than Sauce for some seriously good eats! It’s definitely become my go-to spot for the best pizza in Old Town Scottsdale.