Best Pizza in Scarsdale (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve had a chance to sample the wares of eleven local pizza joints and I’m ready to share my findings.

This isn’t your usual top five; it’s actually a top eleven list filled with surprises. While you might expect the list to be full of traditional Italian spots, there are some unexpected places in there too. I take my pizza seriously and have sampled pizza from around the world, so trust me when I say this list should not be overlooked!

You can expect plenty of humor and lightheartedness as I review each option and determine which is the best in Scarsdale. So sit back, grab a slice, and let’s get started finding out who will make the cut among these 11 contenders.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta

The first thing I noticed when walking in were the friendly faces behind the counter. The staff was incredibly helpful and accommodating, making sure my visit was as enjoyable as possible.

The pizzas at Pizzarelli’s are quite something special. They have an impressive variety of toppings to choose from – you can get your pizza with anything from pepperoni and sausage to artichokes and anchovies. There’s something for everyone! The crust is perfectly crisp and slightly chewy, while the cheese is deliciously melty and gooey.

And it doesn’t stop there! In addition to pizza, they offer a wide selection of pasta dishes such as lasagna, ravioli, and fettuccine Alfredo. The portions are generous and satisfying, just like their pizzas. And their garlic bread has quickly become one of my favorites – it’s a real treat with every bite!

All in all, Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta is definitely worth a visit when you’re looking for the best pizza in Scarsdale. This restaurant will not disappoint; I guarantee it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in White Plains!

#2 Pizza Domo

As soon as I stepped in the door I knew I’d found something special. The friendly staff greeted me warmly and I could smell the deliciousness of fresh-baked pizza in the air.

The pizza was phenomenal. Fresh and flavorful ingredients, a perfect crunchy crust, and just enough melted cheese to make it heavenly. To top it off, their sauce was out of this world!

I was also very impressed with their dessert selection. Sweet and savory treats ranging from decadent rainbows of colors to classic favorites like cannolis were available for my indulgence.

Top all that off with an inviting atmosphere and attentive service,and you’ve got a winner. If you’re anywhere near Scarsdale, make sure to check out Pizza Domo–you won’t regret it! Best pizza in Scarsdale? Absolutely!

#3 Utica Pie Co.

The atmosphere was incredibly inviting and welcoming. The walls were covered with decorations from the local area and it added to the cozy feeling of the place.

When it was time for the main attraction, Utica Pie Co’s pizza didn’t disappoint. The pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven, and the flavors were just so spot on! I tried their classic pepperoni pizza, and I still dream about it sometimes. The sauce was just the right combination of sweet and spicy, and all of the toppings blended perfectly together.

But my favorite part was that the staff was so friendly. Everyone from the server who took my order to the chef who prepared it went out of their way to make sure I had an amazing experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Scarsdale, then Utica Pie Co is definitely worth checking out!

#4 Mezzaluna Pizzeria & Restaurant

From the moment I stepped foot in this restaurant, I was overwhelmed with a sense of happiness. With its bright and airy atmosphere, there’s no doubt that the place has an overall inviting feel to it. Plus, the staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming—the perfect combination for a great pizza night!

The pizza here hits all the major spots. From the perfectly crisp crust to its flavorful toppings, you can expect nothing but deliciousness in every bite. The ingredients are fresh and flavorful and pair nicely with their unique selection of sauces. On top of that, their prices are unbeatable—you really get your money’s worth here!

I could go on and on about how much I enjoyed my visit to Mezzaluna Pizzeria & Restaurant—but why don’t you come and experience it for yourself? You won’t regret ordering some of the best pizza in Scarsdale!

#5 Cosimo & Johnny’s Pizzeria

From the moment I walked in, I was dazzled by their decor – it had just the right amount of old-school pizza parlor charm. The waitstaff were also a highlight – super friendly and attentive.

But what’s a review without talking about the food? Well, let me just say this – it was out of this world! It’s like they took all my favorite flavors and put them on top of a perfectly cooked, fluffy crust. Toppings were fresh and abundant, sauce was full of flavor and not too sweet.

Overall, Cosimo & Johnny’s Pizzeria is the perfect spot for people looking for delicious pizza in Scarsdale. They certainly have my vote for best pizza in town!

#6 Wood & Fire Neapolitan Style Pizza

From the moment I stepped in the door, I could feel the passion for pizza. The aroma of freshly-baked dough and bubbling cheese filled my nostrils as I eagerly scanned the menu. It was a difficult decision, but I eventually settled on their signature Margherita pizza.

When the pie arrived at my table, it was like a work of art! The cheese was perfectly melted and the crust had that perfect charred flavor. It was one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever tasted.

The service at Wood & Fire Neapolitan Style Pizza was also top-notch. The staff were friendly, knowledgeable and attentive – they went out of their way to make sure every customer had an outstanding experience.

If you’re looking for some truly excellent pizza in Scarsdale, then Wood & Fire Neapolitan Style Pizza is definitely the place to go – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 BURRATA

I was wowed from the moment I walked into this restaurant. The atmosphere is excellent; the staff are friendly and welcoming, and the décor is tastefully done.

When it comes to their menu, BURRATA has some of the most unique and delicious pizzas I’ve ever tasted! The crust is perfectly thin yet still crisp with a subtle dusting of herbs. Toppings are just as delicious; they range from classic tomato sauce to inventive combinations like truffle-scented mushrooms or smoked salmon. Every bite will leave you wanting more!

I also love their wide selection of beers and wines that pair nicely with their pizzas. On my last visit, I had a glass of Chianti to go with my ‘Mushroomicious’ pizza – an amazing combination!

At BURRATA, you can be sure that you’re getting some of the best pizza in Scarsdale. So why wait? Grab a few friends and head over for a night filled with great food and even better company!

#8 SLICE of Scarsdale

From the moment I walked in, I was impressed with the atmosphere. It was cozy and inviting, and the wood-burning oven gave it a unique charm. Plus, they had a nice selection of Italian wines to pair with my meal.

The pizza itself was impressive too: the crust was thin but sturdy and lightly charred on the edges, and the cheese was flavorful and creamy. The toppings were fresh and generously layered, making for a truly delicious pizza experience.

The menu also had some creative options that you wouldn’t find at most places – like their signature pesto sauce made with roasted garlic, pine nuts, and kale!

The service was great too; my server was knowledgeable about their menu items and helpful in offering suggestions. He even surprised me with a complimentary dessert at the end of my meal! Talk about hospitality!

All in all, I’d say that SLICE of Scarsdale is easily one of the best pizzerias in Scarsdale – no matter where you’ve come from or where you’re going!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Mt Vernon!

#9 Happy Days Pizza Place

My first impression walking in was that this place had a lot of character. There are postcards from all over the world on the walls and you can tell they take pride in their restaurant.

When I finally got to tasting their pizza, I knew I had hit the jackpot! The crust was thin and crispy, just as I like it, and the cheese melted in my mouth like a dream. The toppings were also fresh and flavorful. Not to mention they have some really creative combinations that make their pizzas stand out from the crowd.

I would highly recommend Happy Days Pizza Place if you’re looking for the best pizza in Scarsdale – even if you don’t care about traveling around the world looking for great pizza (like me!).

#10 Venetian Delight

The place looks small from the outside, but they’ve packed a lot of authentic Italian pizzazz into this restaurant. The decor has an old-world Venetian feel with plenty of red, white and green accents. But it’s all about the pizza here – and it certainly delivers!

The pizzas are some of the most flavorful I’ve tasted anywhere in the world. With their homemade tomato sauce and handmade dough, these pies have an incredible flavor that is both comforting and exciting at the same time. The toppings are fresh and the cheese is melted to perfection – you can really taste the quality ingredients in every bite.

But my favorite thing about Venetian Delight was definitely their staff. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming, which made for a wonderful experience. They were also happy to answer any questions I had about their menu, which made me feel like I was eating with family!

If you’re looking for one of the best pizzas in Scarsdale, look no further than Venetian Delight! Their delicious food and warm atmosphere will satisfy your hunger and make you feel right at home.

#11 Polpettina

The first time I visited, I was immediately impressed by the decor. The walls have a polished modern look and the tables have a cheerful red-and-white checkered tablecloth that made me feel like I was in an Italian restaurant.

The menu has all the classic pizzas you would expect from a good pizza place, but the specialty pies really stand out. They range from classics like margherita to more creative flavors like wild mushroom and truffle oil.

I always order their signature polpettina – small meatballs served over pizza dough with tomatoes, onions, and mozzarella cheese. It’s absolutely delicious! It has such a unique flavor that rivals any Italian restaurant I’ve been to anywhere in the world.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Scarsdale, then look no further than Polpettina. This place is definitely worth checking out!