Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Surprise AZ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Arizona

Best Pizza in Surprise AZ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

147 Views

I’ve traveled around the world tasting all sorts of pizza, and I’m excited to put my taste buds to the test in this small city. I’ve sampled twelve pizza places in Surprise AZ, so I’m sure I’ll find some that will surprise my palette!

In this article, I’ll share with you the best pizzas that Surprise AZ has to offer. While I take my reviews seriously, you can expect a humorous and lighthearted tone throughout. So, buckle up and prepare your stomachs for a virtual journey featuring the most delicious pizzas in Surprise AZ!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arizona

#1 Lucky’s Pizza

First off, the atmosphere of Lucky’s Pizza is really welcoming; I felt right at home as soon as I walked in. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, and they were eager to answer any questions I had about their pizzas.

The pizza itself was amazing. The crust was cooked perfectly – not too thick, not too thin – and you could definitely taste the wood-fired flavor in every bite. The toppings were all fresh, with just the right amount of seasoning to give it that classic Italian flavor.

I honestly cannot say enough about my experience at Lucky’s Pizza. From the friendly staff to the perfectly cooked pizza, it was truly one of the best experiences I’ve ever had eating pizza. If you’re ever in Surprise and looking for some great pizza, make sure to check out Lucky’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Peoria!

#2 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I mean, what more could a traveling food critic ask for? Delicious fresh ingredients, a convenient and friendly ordering experience, and the option to simply pick it up or have it delivered right to your door.

The staff was friendly and accommodating. I was greeted with a smile, given helpful advice on toppings selection and they even offered me tasting samples! It really felt like they wanted us to enjoy the pizza-eating experience.

The food itself was nothing short of amazing. The crust was perfectly cooked, the mozzarella had just the right amount of gooeyness, and all of the ingredients blended together perfectly. And since I ordered my pie online, it was already prepared for baking when I arrived – which made for an easy pick-up!

Overall, my dining experience at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza in Surprise was delightful from start to finish. It certainly has earned its title as one of the best pizza spots in town!

#3 Little Sicily Pizza

At first glance, the restaurant looks unassuming and kind of run-down. But don’t let appearances deceive you — Little Sicily Pizza is full of surprises!

The pizza crust was perfectly crisp, with a light and fluffy center. The sauce was flavorful without being overly spicy, and the cheese was perfectly melted and gooey. The classic Vegetarian pizza I sampled was overflowing with fresh vegetables, each adding their own complimentary flavor to the pizza.

But my favorite part of Little Sicily Pizza had to be the service. Everyone there was incredibly friendly and engaging, as if I were part of their family. They made sure we got exactly what we ordered and that every bite was as good as we expected it to be.

I can confidently say that Little Sicily Pizza is easily the best pizza in Surprise (or anywhere else for that matter!). If you want an amazing Italian experience you won’t forget, this is definitely the place to go!

#4 Ray’s Pizza

I was fortunate enough to stop by Ray’s Pizza on my recent trip through town, and I must say that I was very impressed. The menu is extensive, with lots of variety for all types of customers – from vegan to traditional. Not to mention the numerous specialty pizzas!

The atmosphere at Ray’s Pizza is warm and inviting; it’s obvious that they care about creating a great environment for their customers. The staff was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable; they were always more than willing to answer any questions I had about their menu and the pizzas in general.

The pizza itself is nothing short of mouth-watering deliciousness. Every bite was flavorful and perfectly cooked; you can tell from the aroma alone just how fresh these pies are! From classic Margherita to specialties like Hawaiian and Buffalo Chicken, there really is something here for everyone.

In conclusion, I have to give praise where praise is due – Ray’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Surprise! Serve it up with a side of good conversation, great customer service, and cozy atmosphere, and you have yourself one heck of a pizza experience!

#5 Deno’s Pizza surprise AZ

I was particularly impressed with how friendly the staff were. From the moment I stepped in the door, I felt right at home – it’s like their motto should be ‘Welcome home to Deno’s Pizza surprise AZ!’

The pizza itself was outstanding. With its perfectly cooked crust, zesty sauce, and ample toppings, it really brought out all of my taste buds! The menu has something for everyone and definitely caters to those who are picky eaters.

Overall, this is hands down one of the best pizza places I’ve ever been to and sure to please everyone from the pickiest eater to the pizza connoisseur. If you’re looking for great pizza in Surprise, then don’t miss out on Deno’s Pizza Surprise AZ!

#6 Bonfire Craft Kitchen and Tap House Surprise

I recently visited this restaurant while on vacation, and I can say without hesitation that their pizza is absolutely delicious. The crust was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char. The cheese was gooey, flavorful, and melted perfectly over all the various toppings. And speaking of toppings—they had an incredible selection! Their classic pepperoni pizza was, in a word, mouthwatering. But for something a bit more adventurous, I tried one of their specialties: the Pesto and Roasted Garlic. This unlikely combination turned out to be truly amazing!

The atmosphere at Bonfire Craft Kitchen and Tap House Surprise is also great; it’s cozy yet modern, giving off an inviting vibe that’s perfect for a relaxing meal or an evening out with friends. And they have an extensive beer menu too—a great bonus!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Surprise, then look no further than Bonfire Craft Kitchen and Tap House Surprise!

#7 Pieology Pizzeria

From the moment you walk in, you can feel the comfortable atmosphere that Pieology Pizzeria has created. The polite staff behind the counter is always eager to help, helping me pick out the best combination of toppings and sauces.

The build your own pizza is my personal favorite. With a variety of fresh ingredients, it’s almost like creating a work of art. From classics like pepperoni to more exotic toppings such as roasted red peppers and artichokes, I can never get enough!

And the taste? Incredible! The crunchy crust pairs so well with the sweet tomato sauce and all of the delicious toppings. Not to mention, they also have amazing calzones, salads, desserts and drinks to complete your meal.

I highly recommend Pieology Pizzeria for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Surprise!

#8 #1Brothers Pizza

I’ll admit I was a little skeptical at first, especially when I saw the menu. But after having the classic margherita pizza, my doubts were quickly put to rest. The fresh mozzarella and tomatoes were out of this world!

My second try was the pepperoni and prosciutto special. All I can say is wow! Perfectly cooked pepperoni with just the right amount of salty prosciutto made for an amazing flavor combination.

The best part about #1Brothers Pizza is how they manage to keep everything so affordable. Even though they make top-notch pizzas, they don’t charge outrageous prices like some places in town. They also have excellent customer service that makes sure you get what you want without any hassle.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Surprise, then look no further than #1Brothers Pizza! Their pizzas are a mouthful of flavor and their prices won’t break your bank. So come on over for a slice (or two!) and taste what everyone’s been raving about!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Glendale!

#9 U S Pizza

I’m a pizza connoisseur, so I know what I’m talking about! From the moment I stepped into U S Pizza, I could smell the delicious aroma of freshly made dough. The staff were more than happy to answer any questions that I had and took extra care in selecting the best ingredients— everything from the specially sourced cheeses to veggies grown locally.

What truly sets U S Pizza apart is their unique crusts. They serve up both thin and thick-crust pizzas, so you can choose whichever one suits your taste buds. Apart from pizza, they also serve up amazing salads and sandwiches. And mind you -their fries are absolutely to die for!

To top it off, they have a great atmosphere where you can enjoy a slice or two with friends or family. All in all, U S Pizza is some of the best pizza in Surprise and worth checking out if you’re ever in town!

#10 Barro’s Pizza

On my most recent visit, I was pleasantly surprised that their signature pepperoni pizza tasted just as good as it did the first time I tried it. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the sauce added just enough sweetness to the dish, and each piece of pepperoni added a hint of spiciness.

The selection and variety of toppings at Barro’s Pizza is second-to-none. From classic mushroom and olives to unique dishes like BBQ chicken, there are truly something for everyone here. Not to mention, they offer some really delicious specialty pizzas like the margherita or pesto pizzas.

But what really sets Barro’s Pizza apart from other pizza restaurants is their attention to detail: they take great care in preparing each order with fresh ingredients and making sure that their customers are always satisfied. This is why I have returned here time after time – because I know that when I order a pizza from Barro’s Pizza, it will be nothing but pure perfection every single time!

#11 Rosati’s Pizza

I stopped in on a recent visit and was absolutely delighted. The restaurant is cozy, but with enough room to accommodate groups of all sizes. I was immediately greeted by the friendly staff and offered their menu, which has something for everyone – including vegan options!

The pizza crust was crisp, yet still chewy and flavorful. Their sauce was tight, the cheese generous and melted evenly and the toppings were fresh. I’m usually picky about my pepperoni but Rosati’s had perfectly balanced portions that added great flavor but didn’t overpower the other ingredients.

All in all, Rosati’s Pizza is easily one of the best pizzas I have tasted in Surprise. The quality of ingredients and attention to detail doesn’t go unnoticed here – it makes for a delicious meal every time!

#12 Reel Pizza Pies

The first thing I noticed when I entered the restaurant was the welcoming atmosphere; the walls were lined with pictures of classic movies and actors, adding a fun and unique vibe. I was then greeted by an incredibly friendly staff member who helped me navigate their extensive menu.

The ingredients at Reel Pizza Pies were far superior to any other pizza places I’ve visited during my travels and they definitely didn’t disappoint. The crust was light and airy, while still having a satisfying crunch that held up to the generous toppings. The tomato sauce was made with fresh tomatoes and herbs, giving it a tangy yet sweet flavor. The cheese melted perfectly over top, and there were plenty of delicious options for topping like sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, peppers.. you name it!

In addition to their delicious pizzas, their calzones are also out of this world! They have amazing fillings inside like ricotta cheese and mozarella mixed together with marinara or pesto – seriously delicious!

I’m so glad I had the chance to visit Reel Pizza Pies and try their incredible food. Without a doubt they have earned the title of “best pizza in Surprise”!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Little Sicily Pizza

Picture this: I stroll into Little Sicily Pizza, parched and ready for a slice of heaven. What’s that? They serve alcohol? This is starting to sound like my kind of place! Now, hold onto your taste buds, folks, because Little Sicily doesn’t stop at a killer deep dish. Oh no, they’re just getting started.

Once I’ve demolished my pizza masterpiece, I turn my attention to dessert. And boy, oh boy, do they deliver. From decadent chocolate lava cake to creamy tiramisu, Little Sicily has dessert options that will have you swearing off carbs for life. And by life, I mean until your next visit because, trust me, you won’t be able to resist.

Speaking of visits, let’s address the only downside I could find: Little Sicily doesn’t accept reservations. Now, I’m all for spontaneity, but trying to secure a table at this joint can feel like a mission impossible. But fear not, my hungry friends, it’s worth the wait. Just grab a drink, make some new friends, and let your anticipation grow.

Now, let’s talk ambiance. Little Sicily Pizza is not only a feast for your taste buds, but it’s also a feast for the eyes. With its warm and welcoming decor, it’s a nice little tourist spot that’ll have you snapping more photos than a food blogger at a buffet.

So, folks, if you find yourself craving the best deep dish pizza in surprise az, Little Sicily Pizza is the place to be. Just bring your appetite, a sense of adventure, and prepare to indulge in a pizza experience that’ll make your taste buds do the macarena.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Little Sicily Pizza

Let me tell you folks, this place is a hidden gem nestled right in the heart of Surprise, Arizona. As a seasoned food critic, I’ve been to pizza joints all over the globe, but Little Sicily Pizza has been my most unexpected delight yet.

First of all, they serve alcohol! Picture this: enjoying a cold beer while devouring a slice of their heavenly thin crust pizza. It’s like sipping on liquid courage while conquering mountains of flavor. Trust me, it’s the perfect combination.

And if that’s not enough to tickle your taste buds, they offer dessert too! I know, right? A sweet ending to a cheesy adventure. It’s like having the best of both worlds in one place.

Now, here comes the funny part. Little Sicily Pizza doesn’t accept reservations. Who would have thought that? Apparently, the pizza gods have a sense of humor, and while they bless you with mouthwatering slices, they also throw in a dash of unpredictability. So, be ready for a little waiting time, my impatient pizza enthusiasts. But trust me, it’s entirely worth the wait.

Plus, being situated in a nice tourist spot gives you the perfect opportunity to people-watch while you salivate over the thought of sinking your teeth into a tantalizingly crisp crust. So, put your name on the list, grab a drink, savor the ambiance, and slyly judge the tourists passing by. Little Sicily Pizza is worth every moment of anticipation.

In conclusion, if you want the best thin crust pizza Surprise, AZ has to offer, head straight to Little Sicily Pizza. It’s an experience that’ll make your taste buds dance and your funny bone laugh.