Best Pizza in Westfield NJ (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve been all over the world tasting pizza in every way, shape and form it comes in, so I’m confident that my opinion on the best pizza places in this area is sound.

I decided to take a deep dive into Westfield NJ’s local cuisine and evaluate 11 different pizza joints. It was no easy task… but someone had to do it. Despite being a demanding mission, I took immense joy in sifting through various crusts and flavors.

What did I find? Well, you’ll just have to read further along to find out!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Outta Hand Pizza

The first thing that struck me about this restaurant was the cozy atmosphere. From the outside, I could tell it was going to be a classic New Jersey pizza joint, and they didn’t disappoint. The inside had a classic look, with all the pizza-making paraphernalia you’d expect.

The menu was expansive, but I was there for one thing: pizza! I decided on their specialty – an Outta Hand Special – and boy, did it not disappoint! The crust was nice and crispy, cooked just right in an oven that gave it a perfect char. The toppings were fresh and flavorful. It really hit the spot!

I also sampled some of the appetizers while I waited – garlic knots and cheese-stuffed breadsticks. Both were delicious! And you can’t forget about their famous homemade Italian salad dressing. It’s like crack – you can’t stop eating it once you start.

All in all, Outta Hand Pizza is my go-to for best pizza in Westfield NJ! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than this local favorite.

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Cranford!

#2 Massa Roman Square Pizza & Italian Specialties

I was initially skeptical, but the owners have clearly put a lot of thought into the menu and ingredients. The dough is fresh, made with high-quality flour and cut into perfectly-sized squares with just the right amount of crispy edges. The toppings are amazing – from spicy pepperoni to earthy mushrooms – and it’s all cooked in a wood-fired oven for added flavor.

The atmosphere at Massa Roman Square Pizza & Italian Specialties is also great – warm, inviting and buzzing with energy. The owners are incredibly welcoming and always willing to chat about their pizza recipes or offer advice on what toppings to try.

Most importantly, though, their pizza tastes great! Honestly, their slices were the best I’ve had in Westfield NJ (and maybe anywhere else!). I would definitely recommend visiting Massa Roman Square Pizza & Italian Specialties!

#3 Gennaro’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Gennaro’s is warm and inviting, with a cozy little dining room that has all the charm of a traditional Italian pizzeria. The staff is friendly and helpful, always making sure that you’re taken care of and your pizza needs are met.

The ingredients used for the pizza are fresh and of the highest quality, ensuring a delicious masterpiece every single time. The crust is thin but still manages to support all the toppings, while still maintaining its chewy texture that I look for in good pizza.

Speaking of toppings, the selection at Gennaro’s is exceptional! From classic favorites like pepperoni or sausage to more exotic selections like eggplant or artichoke, they have something for everyone. And they even offer vegan options so you can get your pizza without guilt!

But what really sets Gennaro’s Pizzeria apart from other places around town is their commitment to using locally sourced ingredients when possible. This really shows in the taste; you can tell that everything was made with love and care by people who are truly passionate about their craft.

I’m confident in saying this place has some of the best pizza in Westfield NJ! If you’re looking for great pizza in this area, Gennaro’s Pizzeria should be at the top of your list!

#4 Casa di Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew this place had something special. The atmosphere was friendly and inviting and the staff were incredibly helpful. The menu selection was top-notch, with an impressive range of specialty pizzas, including some truly unique options that you won’t find elsewhere.

When it came time to order my pizza I went for the Pan di Pizza – which is a bit like a calzone – and boy was it delicious! The combination of the doughy, crunchy crust with creamy cheese and all those amazing toppings really hit the spot. Not to mention they weren’t stingy on the toppings either – there was plenty of flavor packed into every slice!

But the best part of Casa di Pizza? Hands down their service. From start to finish everyone was incredibly friendly and helpful; they even gave me some handy tips on how to get free delivery! Plus they got my order out fast, so no waiting around hungrily while my pizza was being made.

I can definitely say one thing: If you’re looking for great pizza in Westfield NJ then Casa di Pizza should be at the top of your list! Hands down this is some of the best pizza that’s been made anywhere in recent memory, so don’t miss out on this place!

#5 Buona Pizza Inc

My first visit to Buona Pizza Inc was a little intimidating. The décor was definitely from another era, but I still felt welcome as soon as I walked in the door. The scents emanating from the kitchen were tantalizing and I knew I had made the right decision.

The pizza itself is something special. They use only the freshest ingredients and the crust is cooked to perfection – not too thin or thick, just enough crunch to give it that ‘wow’ factor. The toppings are always plentiful, flavorful and expertly crafted. Even their vegetarian pies are creative and tasty – a real feat!

It’s clear that Buona Pizza Inc takes pizza seriously, which is why they have some of the best pizza in Westfield NJ. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing take-out, you’ll be sure to enjoy every bite of your slice (or two!) from Buona Pizza Inc!

#6 La Famiglia Sorrento

I’ve had many delicious slices of pizza all around the world, and La Famiglia Sorrento was no exception. I ordered a large Margherita pizza and it was divine! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the tomatoes were so fresh and flavorful. The cheese was so gooey that it melted in my mouth, and the herbs added just the right amount of flavor. It really felt like I was eating a slice of Italian heaven!

The atmosphere at La Famiglia Sorrento is also really inviting. There’s always background music playing, and the tables are spaced out nicely so you can enjoy your meal without feeling too cramped. The staff were incredibly friendly as well – they made sure to check in with us often to make sure we were enjoying our meal.

Overall, if you’re ever in Westfield NJ looking for some great pizza then La Famiglia Sorrento should definitely be your first choice! From their delicious food to their welcoming atmosphere, this is one spot that will have you coming back for more.

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Elizabeth!

#7 Chrones Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, which makes it perfect for a meal with family and friends. From the moment I stepped inside, I was struck by the warm and friendly staff who went above and beyond to make sure we had a pleasant dining experience.

The pizza itself was spectacular! The crust was light and crispy, made with fresh ingredients that were cooked to perfection. The ingredients themselves were of great quality- every bite was filled with flavor. And don’t even get me started on the sauce; it was just divine!

I’m convinced that Chrones Pizza has some of the best pizza around- not just in Westfield NJ but anywhere in the world. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, this is definitely the place for you!

#8 Roma Pizzeria

The crust was perfect – it had a nice balance of crunchiness and chewiness. It had great flavor, too. I think it was the generous combination of garlic, oregano and parmesan cheese that made it truly special.

The toppings were also spot on. The sauce was so flavorful – it had just the right amount of sweetness and acidity. And then there were the cheeses, oh my! They were just the right amount of gooey, with each bite melting in your mouth and transforming into pure deliciousness.

The service was great too – everyone was really friendly and accommodating, which always helps give a good impression of a place.

All in all, Roma Pizzeria is easily one of the best pizza spots around – not only in Westfield NJ but anywhere! I’m already planning my next visit back here to try out all their other offerings that I haven’t gotten a chance to yet… Yum!

#9 Grano Pizzeria & Italian Tavern

The moment I walked into the restaurant, I was greeted by an aroma of delicious pizza that made me salivate. The menu was vast and overwhelming, with pizza options ranging from classic Margherita to an unexpected mix of sweet balsamic garlic chicken.

The pizza itself was cooked to perfection and the crust was a perfect blend of crunchy yet tender. For toppings, Grano uses fresh and quality ingredients – from the tomato sauce to the melted cheese and flavorful meats – it all comes together perfectly!

But, Grano Pizzeria & Italian Tavern isn’t just about amazing pizza; they also feature other classic Italian dishes such as lasagna, spaghetti and meatballs, or ravioli. The portions are generous and their pasta dishes are just as delicious as their pizzas!

Plus, their service is top notch! Our waiter was friendly and attentive throughout our meal. He even took time to chat with us about his favorite dishes he recommended. I was super impressed and would come back in a heartbeat!

Overall, I can confidently say that Grano Pizzeria & Italian Tavern serves some of the best pizza in Westfield NJ. If you’re looking for a delicious Italian dining experience – this is definitely the place to be!

#10 Joe’s Rotisseria

When I first walked in the door, it was obvious that this would be a great experience. The rotisserie-style oven filled the air with delicious smells of baking pizza and I could feel my mouth watering in anticipation.

The staff was friendly and welcoming, and after hearing about some of the unique toppings they have available, such as buffalo ranch or mac & cheese, I couldn’t wait to try them.

I decided to go with the classic pepperoni option, but added some extra jalapenos for an extra kick. Boy did it deliver! The crust was perfectly cooked – golden brown and crunchy on the outside, light and fluffy on the inside; and the topping combination was simply sublime. As if that wasn’t enough, everything from their specialty sauces to their homemade dough made each slice even more amazing.

I can confidently say that Joe’s Rotisseria has some of the best pizza in Westfield NJ – and all of New Jersey for that matter!

#11 Rudy’s Italian Restaurant

The space is warm and inviting, and the staff is friendly and helpful. I was particularly impressed with the range of topping options; from veggie-lovers to meat-lovers, there’s something for everyone on their menu.

And, of course, the pizza! The crust was cooked to perfection—not too thin or soggy and not too thick either. It was firm enough to hold up all the delicious toppings without getting lost in the mix. And speaking of toppings, all the ingredients were fresh and flavorful and made for a delightful bite every time.

I would recommend Rudy’s Italian Restaurant to anyone looking for a truly great pizza experience. After sampling their pies I can say with certainty that they really do make some of the best pizza in Westfield NJ!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Elizabeth!