Best Pizza in Bed Stuy (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve had pizza all over the world – from Sicily to Chicago, I know good pizza when I see it (and more importantly, when I taste it).

So, armed with my worldly experience, I’ve found 11 of the best pizza places in Bed Stuy and decided to put them to the test. In this lighthearted review, I’ll tell you all about my findings. From classic Neapolitan-style pies to unique takes on deep dish and wood-fired creations, there’s something for everyone!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Impasto

From the moment I stepped in the door, it was clear that Impasto uses only the freshest and highest quality ingredients. The toppings were so flavorful and the crust was perfectly cooked so that it was both crunchy and chewy. I had to try a few slices of different pies just to get a full taste of their deliciousness!

The staff was also friendly and accommodating, which is always a plus. After I told them my background as a food critic, they offered me free samples of some of their specialty pizzas, which were all fantastic.

Overall, Impasto is definitely one of my favorite pizza spots in Bed Stuy – no doubt about it! If you’re looking for great pizza at an affordable price, look no further than Impasto – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#2 Broadway Pizza

The first thing that grabbed my attention when I walked in was the smell of fresh dough in the air. My mouth was already watering before I even got to looking at the menu. Luckily, their menu options were fantastic! They had everything from classic Margheritas to creative specialty pies.

The pizza itself was nothing short of amazing. The crust was thin and crunchy with just the right amount of cheese and toppings. The sauce was flavorful and well balanced. In fact, it may have been one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

In addition to the food, Broadway Pizza’s service was also excellent! Everyone on staff was friendly and accommodating from start to finish. I could tell they really cared about providing a pleasant experience for their guests.

All things considered, Broadway Pizza is a must-visit spot if you find yourself in Bed Stuy craving some serious pizza. This place has earned a spot on my list of favorite places to grab a slice!

#3 Crown Heights Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of fresh herbs and tomatoes filled the air and the decor was cozy yet inviting. The staff was so friendly and helpful, they made me feel like part of their extended family.

When it came time to order the pizza, I had a hard time deciding between their classic margherita pie or their meat lovers special. In the end, I decided to go with both and boy did they deliver! The margherita pizza was as close to perfection as could be – light, chewy dough packed with flavor from the basil, tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese. Meanwhile, their meat lovers special was piled high with a medley of cooked meats that were cooked until perfectly crispy on top of a thin yet flavorful crust.

I’m already planning my next visit back to Crown Heights Pizza; there’s no doubt in my mind that it is some of the best pizza in Bed Stuy!

#4 Cuts & Slices

I started with their signature slice – the cheese only slice. The crust was wonderfully crisp and flavorful, not to mention the perfectly melted cheese on top. I also sampled a range of toppings on other slices, including fresh vegetables and savory meats. Each slice was truly delicious!

The atmosphere at Cuts & Slices was great too! There was a lively energy in the restaurant that put me in the mood for pizza. Plus, their staff was friendly and made sure my visit went well.

When it comes to pizza, I don’t think you can find better than what Cuts & Slices has to offer. For anyone looking for the best pizza in Bed Stuy, this is definitely the place to go!

#5 Pizza Spot

I’m always hesitant when trying a new pizza place, but this one exceeded all expectations. From the moment I walked in, I was struck by the inviting and friendly atmosphere. The staff were really attentive, offering to answer any questions I had and providing helpful suggestions on their menu items.

The pizzas themselves were top-notch. They offer an incredible variety of toppings that are sure to satisfy even the pickiest palate. The crust was just right; it was crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Everything was cooked perfectly and each slice was bursting with flavor.

One thing I especially liked about Pizza Spot is that they take pride in using only fresh ingredients. You can tell with every bite that the food is made with care and dedication to quality.

In conclusion, if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Bed Stuy, look no further than Pizza Spot. It’s definitely a spot you won’t want to miss!

#6 Luigi’s Pizzeria

I’m not sure if Luigi has some sort of magical pizza-making powers, but the pies here are out of this world. The crust is perfectly crisp and the cheese perfectly melted. The toppings are fresh and there’s plenty of them. Not to mention the tomato sauce is oh so tangy!

The atmosphere at Luigi’s Pizzeria is also quite welcoming. I felt like I was in a cozy Italian grandmother’s house. The staff were all friendly and attentive, making sure I had everything I needed for a great meal.

It should be noted that Luigi’s Pizzeria doesn’t take reservations, so you will have to wait in line for your pie, but trust me when I say it’s definitely worth it!

Overall, Luigi’s Pizzeria is truly serving up some of the best pizza in Bed Stuy. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience then look no further than Luigi’s Pizzeria!

#7 Le Fatima

The smell alone draws you in. As you walk closer, your eyes are met with the sight of traditional Italian-style pizzas cooking in the oven. The flavors are mouthwatering.

I started off with a traditional margherita pizza and it was sensational! The sauce was cooked to perfection and the cheese was melted evenly all over it. The dough was crispy and had just enough crunch for my taste.

Next I tried their specialty, an asparagus, mushroom and artichoke pizza. What can I say? It blew me away! The combination of these three ingredients together created an unforgettable flavor that had me going back for seconds (and thirds!).

Overall, Le Fatima is a great restaurant for anyone looking for delicious Italian-style pizza in Bed Stuy. If you’re ever in town and have a hankering for some of the best pizza around, make sure to drop by Le Fatima – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#8 Saraghina Pizzeria

I couldn’t believe my eyes when I walked in. The atmosphere was perfect – warm and inviting. Plus, the place had a rustic Italian vibe to it that made me feel right at home.

But what really won me over was the pizza! It was cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven and had such an amazing, smoky flavor that I’m still dreaming about it. Every bite was delicious and even though I was stuffed after eating a whole pie, I could have easily gone for another slice or two.

So if you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Bed Stuy, then look no further than Saraghina Pizzeria! Their pizza is simply out of this world and I can’t recommend it enough. As far as I’m concerned, there’s no better place to get your pizza fix!

#9 Not Just Pizza

This place is nothing special on the outside, but it’s a true gem within. The dough is made with the highest quality ingredients, so you can expect a consistently perfect crust every time. The sauce is just as delicious – made with tomatoes that are perfectly balanced between sweet and savory. And then there’s the cheese which is extra creamy and flavorful!

The toppings are also top-notch; they’re always fresh and cooked to perfection. My favorite topping combo has got to be pepperoni and mushrooms – it’s heavenly!

What really sets Not Just Pizza apart from others though, is their attention to detail. Each pizza pie is carefully constructed before it goes into the oven – you can see it in every slice! They take their time when making each order, ensuring that every single bite offers up a delicious experience.

Overall, I’d give Not Just Pizza 5/5 stars for delivering some of the best pizza in Bed Stuy! It’s worth checking out if you’re ever in the area looking for an unforgettable pizza experience.

#10 Maddy`s

I’ve tried countless pies in my life, but none compared to the flavors that come out of Maddy’s ovens. From their classic cheese slice to their gourmet white truffle pizza, each bite was like an explosion of flavor!

The atmosphere at Maddy`s was also top-notch. It was filled with an eclectic mix of people – hipsters, locals, and tourists alike – who were all there to enjoy a slice of pizza heaven. The staff were friendly and always willing to help.

I can honestly say that I haven’t had better pizza anywhere else! It’s definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in Bed Stuy looking for the best pizza around.

#11 The 3 Luigis

The first thing that stands out about The 3 Luigis is the atmosphere of the restaurant. It’s always buzzing with happy customers coming and going. The walls are lined with framed photos of famous Italian-American actors, singers, and athletes. The staff is friendly and welcoming, eager to make sure you have the best experience possible.

When it comes to their pizza, it’s clear that The 3 Luigis takes their craft seriously. Every pizza they create bursts with unique flavors and textures. Whether you opt for a traditional marinara or something more inventive like an eggplant parmesan pie, each slice will leave you wanting more! And don’t forget to top your pizza off with some freshly made garlic knots – they’re the perfect complement to any order.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Bed Stuy, look no further than The 3 Luigis! I highly recommend them for anyone who values great flavors and a terrific atmosphere.