Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Pensacola FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Pensacola FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

09/19/2023

143 Views

I’m not easily impressed, having sampled pizza from all over the world! But I can safely say that the 12 pizza places I’ve visited in Pensacola FL have been noteworthy.

In my quest for hot, cheesy goodness, I’ve compared crust thickness, sauce flavor, and topping options. Some of these places are even offering some unexpected yet delicious toppings.

Join me on this culinary adventure as we crown the best pizza in Pensacola FL. These reviews will be humorous and lighthearted but will still give you a clear idea of who has the best pie in town! So let’s get started and find out which pizza place is truly deserving of the title.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of trying their classic Margherita pizza and was instantly impressed. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with a delicious chewy texture. And the ingredients were top-notch! The tomatoes were bright and flavorful, the cheese melted to perfection, and the herbs added a nice zest!

But New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria isn’t just about great pizza – they also offer some amazing sides. My favorite is their garlic knots – I could barely resist devouring them all in one sitting!

Overall, I’d have to say that New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria is definitely worth visiting – it’s home to some of the best pizza in Pensacola FL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Pensacola!

#2 The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria

The atmosphere of the place is great, with the head chef greeting you with a warm smile and handshake. The staff is friendly and helpful, which made my experience even more enjoyable.

I tried a few different pizzas at The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria and I don’t think I could have made a better choice! The thin-crust pizza was cooked to perfection and had just the right amount of toppings. And the traditional Italian pizza was also delicious—the perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings in every bite.

The best part is that everything is freshly prepared from scratch using only the freshest ingredients from local suppliers. This level of quality really sets The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria apart from other places in Pensacola FL.

And when it comes to taste, words can’t express how good this pizza was—some of the best I’ve ever had! A flavor explosion that left me wanting more. Trust me, if you’re looking for great pizza in Pensacola FL, then make sure to add The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria to your list!

#3 Sky’s Pizza Pie

As soon as I entered this lively pizzeria, I was greeted by a smiling staff that showed me to my seat. The restaurant has a cozy, homey atmosphere with wood-paneled walls and old-fashioned light fixtures that make you feel right at home.

The menu offers an extensive selection of delicious pizza pies in all shapes and sizes. I opted for the classic pepperoni pizza, which was served on a crispy thin crust with just the right dose of spice. The topping was plentiful and the cheese melted perfectly in my mouth. It’s definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

The server was friendly and attentive, making sure our glasses were never empty. He even recommended some excellent beer pairings to complement our meal.

All in all, Sky’s Pizza Pie is a great spot for quality pizza. Whether you’re looking for something simple or something more creative, they have something for everyone. With its cozy atmosphere and top-notch service, it’s no wonder why this is considered the best pizza joint in Pensacola FL!

#4 East Hill Pizza

I recently had the pleasure of dining at East Hill Pizza, and I have to say it was one of the most enjoyable pizza experiences I’ve ever had. The atmosphere was lively and friendly, and the service was outstanding.

The pizza itself was truly delicious – each bite was full of flavor. The crust was the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful. And what really set East Hill Pizza apart for me was their selection of gourmet topping choices. From classic options like pepperoni and sausage, to creative combinations like feta cheese with olives, there really is something for everyone here.

Overall, East Hill Pizza has earned my seal of approval as the best pizza in Pensacola FL! Not only will you enjoy a high-quality meal at an affordable price, but you’ll also get to experience some great conversation over your meal thanks to their friendly staff!

#5 Dieci Pensacola

As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I knew they took their pizza seriously. The walls were lined with old-world photos of Italian chefs and the kitchen staff was bustling with busy hands. It was clear that this place had a passion for pizza!

I ordered a classic Margherita pie and it exceeded my expectations. The crust was thin and crispy, just like an authentic Italian pizza should be. The sauce was sweet yet savory, and the mozzarella melted perfectly on top.

The service here is also top-notch. All the staff members were friendly and attentive to my needs, ensuring that I had everything I needed for an enjoyable meal.

Overall, Dieci Pensacola offers some of the best pizza in Pensacola FL! If you’re looking for an amazing Italian-inspired pizza experience, look no further than Dieci Pensacola!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Orange Beach!

#6 Graffiti Pizza

This place definitely stands out due to its unique atmosphere: the walls have plenty of graffiti art on them, and even some of the dinnerware has been hand-painted. Plus, it’s a great spot for tourists, offering sightseers an enjoyable experience with delicious pizza.

Their menu offers something for everyone – there are vegetarian options available, as well as a selection of delicious desserts. One thing that really sets Graffiti Pizza apart from other places is that they serve alcohol – including hard liquor! So come on down and have a few drinks with your dinner.

If you’re looking for a great spot to watch the game, this is it. Where else can you enjoy tasty pizza and witness the excitement of sports all in one place? That’s what makes Graffiti Pizza so special.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery. But in my opinion, it’s worth taking a short trip to get some of the best pizza in Pensacola FL!

#7 Georgio’s Pizza

The atmosphere of Georgio’s Pizza is enchanting, and their pizza is the perfect combination of savory and sweet. I was particularly impressed by the wide variety of toppings they have, as well as their crusts – which are perfectly crisp.

Their service is top notch, too – servers were quick to answer any questions I had about their menu, and prices were more than reasonable given the quality of food.

Another great benefit that Georgio’s Pizza offers is an extensive selection of alcoholic beverages for you to enjoy with your meal. They also offer a kid’s menu – making it easier for families with young children to enjoy dinner out. Plus, if you’re in the mood for something sweet after dinner, they have several dessert options available!

My only complaint about Georgio’s Pizza is that they don’t offer delivery. But if you don’t mind stepping out for dinner or taking a short drive across town, then it’s certainly worth it!

All in all, I’m convinced that Georgio’s Pizza makes some of the best pizza in Pensacola FL!

#8 Pieology Pizzeria, Cordova Mall Next to World Market

The atmosphere is inviting and cozy, and the service is always top-notch. The amazing selection of pizza toppings keeps me coming back for more. And the amazing thin crust pizzas are what put this restaurant above the rest.

But it’s not just the pizza that makes Pieology Pizzeria stand out from the crowd. The salads are inventive, unique, and delicious. The sides are cooked to perfection, like their homemade garlic knots or pretzel bites. And the desserts? Don’t even get me started!

My personal favorite is the sweet ‘N smoky BBQ chicken pizza with jalapenos – a Pieology classic!

So if you’re looking for great pizza in Pensacola FL, then look no further than Pieology Pizzeria – your one stop shop for delicious pies!

#9 Bubba’s 33

The atmosphere was great, with plenty of TVs to watch sports and a full liquor bar. This made it a great spot for tourists and locals alike.

And let’s not forget the food. They’ve got a great selection of pizzas, as well as other classic lunch fare. And speaking of classic, the kid’s menu was fantastic!

I also have to mention their insanely good desserts. They offer something for everyone – from classic ice cream to deep-fried Oreos and more!

One downside of this restaurant is that they don’t deliver. However, it might be worth the trip if you want the best pizza in Pensacola FL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Navarre!

#10 Mellow Mushroom Pensacola

Upon entering the restaurant, I was greeted with a warm atmosphere and friendly staff. The interior was beautifully decorated and had a relaxed vibe.

The menu offered a great selection of pizzas and other classic Italian-American favorites. From classic cheese pizzas to creative specialty pies like the “Kosmic Karma” pizza (it’s amazing!), there is something for everyone.

When our pizza arrived, we were floored by how delicious it was! The crust was perfectly crispy and chewy while the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. What really made this pizza stand out from other places I have been to is that they use only the freshest ingredients which really makes all the difference in terms of flavor.

Overall, Mellow Mushroom Pensacola is an excellent restaurant with great food and atmosphere. If you are looking for some of the best pizza in Pensacola FL, then this is definitely the place to go!

#11 Hungry Howie’s Pizza

Their thin-crust pizza is light, crisp, and crunchy – and the perfect combination of flavors. The toppings are never skimpy, and they always deliver on their promise of quality.

The service here is also top-notch. Everyone is friendly and helpful, and they go out of their way to make sure you have an enjoyable visit. Their staff is knowledgeable about their menu offerings, so there’s no guesswork involved when ordering.

But it’s not just the pizza that makes Hungry Howie’s my favorite spot for pies in Pensacola! They also have a great selection of sides like garlic bread sticks, deep-dish garlic cheese bites, and nachos topped with delicious melted cheese. Plus their salad bar always has something new and exciting to try.

All in all, I highly recommend Hungry Howie’s Pizza the next time you’re looking for the best pizza in Pensacola FL!

#12 Domino’s Pizza

The first time I tried the pizza, I was amazed. The crust was light and fluffy, with just the right amount of char. The sauce was perfectly balanced, not too sweet or salty. And the cheese! Oh my goodness, it was so cheesey and delicious.

The toppings were piled high and varied – from pepperoni to mushrooms to green peppers to extra cheese – everything came together to make a truly amazing pizza experience. Plus, Domino’s offers great sides like garlic breadsticks and cheesy bread for a chance to mix things up.

I also have to commend them on their customer service: they always answer their phones with enthusiasm and deliver in a timely manner. They even threw some extra cookies in my bag at no extra charge!

All in all, Domino’s Pizza in Pensacola FL is an excellent option for anyone looking for great pizza on the fly – you won’t be disappointed!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria

First of all, let me just say that as a food critic, I appreciate any pizza place that serves alcohol. There’s nothing quite like sipping on a cold beer while sinking your teeth into a delicious slice of cheesy goodness. And let me tell you, the beer selection at The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria is top-notch. They have local craft beers that pair perfectly with their mouthwatering pizzas.

Now, I’m not a vegetarian, but even I can appreciate a good veggie option on a menu. Luckily, The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria has a variety of vegetarian pizzas that are so tasty, they can make even the most carnivorous of us forget about meat for a moment.

And let’s not forget about dessert! The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria offers some delectable options to satisfy any sweet tooth. From creamy tiramisu to sinfully rich chocolate lava cake, they know how to end a meal on a sweet note.

Now, I have to mention one downside of this place – they don’t accept reservations. But trust me, it’s worth the wait. Besides, it gives you a chance to explore the charming tourist spot of Pensacola while you work up an appetite.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best deep dish pizza in Pensacola, look no further than The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria. Their delicious pizzas, extensive beer selection, vegetarian options, and delightful desserts make it a must-visit spot for any pizza lover. Just make sure to arrive early and bring your appetite!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Graffiti Pizza

First of all, let me tell you about the benefits of this place. Not only do they serve alcohol, but they also have the hard stuff! You’ll have a hard time finding a pizza joint that can provide you with a whiskey to go with your pie. And if you’re a vegetarian like me, fear not! Graffiti Pizza offers some delicious veggie options that will make your taste buds sing like a choir of happy vegetables.

But wait, there’s more! They even offer dessert! Because nothing pleases me more than stuffing my face with pizza and then following it up with a sweet treat. It’s like a foodie dream come true.

Now let’s talk about the downsides. Unfortunately, Graffiti Pizza doesn’t do deliveries. So if you’re feeling lazy and don’t want to leave the comfort of your couch, tough luck. You’ll have to haul your hungry self to their restaurant. And oh, they don’t accept reservations either, so be ready to put your name on the waiting list and hope for the best.

But hey, don’t let the downsides discourage you. Graffiti Pizza is a nice spot for tourists, and it’s also a great place to catch a game. So grab a cold drink, enjoy some delicious thin crust pizza, and cheer on your favorite sports team. Because at Graffiti Pizza, they’ve got it all – except for delivery and reservations.