Best Pizza in Perdido Key (Updated Jan 2023)

This pizza quest took me around town in search of the absolute best. After a few days of nonstop eating, I finally have results. Eleven pizzerias were judged, and only one came out on top!

I’m excited to share my findings with you, so buckle up and get ready for fun. I’m here to tell you the story of my mouth-watering journey to find the best pizza in Perdido Key!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Sky’s Pizza Pie

The atmosphere was quite enjoyable and comforting. The place is decorated with lots of old-fashioned memorabilia and photos that gave it a nostalgic feel. The staff were very friendly and accommodating.

As for the pizza, oh boy! It was delicious! The crust was light and fluffy, while still having an amazing crunchy texture. Every bite melted in my mouth like butter. The toppings were cooked to perfection — just the right amount of char on each piece.

Speaking of toppings, Sky’s Pizza Pie has some really unique options. They’ve got everything from pepperoni and chorizo to eggplant parmigiana and even PBJ (yes, you read that right!). I tried the PBJ pizza, which might sound weird at first, but trust me it was amazing!

To top it all off, the price is unbeatable too. For less than $10, I got a large cheese pie with extra topping — more than enough for two people to share!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Perdido Key stop by Sky’s Pizza Pie ASAP! You won’t regret it – I guarantee it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Gulf Breeze!

#2 Pizza At The Pass

I stopped in for lunch one day to try their classic Margherita pizza, and it was a revelation. The dough was perfectly crisp, the tomatoes were sweet and juicy, and the cheese was melted just right. I was in heaven!

The friendly staff at Pizza At The Pass made the experience even better. They gave me tips about the best topping combinations and provided great service throughout my meal. Plus, they have some of the most creative pizzas I’ve ever seen – think spicy Mexican pizza with jalapeños and chorizo!

If you’re looking for a tasty treat in Perdido Key, make sure to visit Pizza At The Pass – they truly deserve five stars!

#3 Marco’s Pizza

My first Marco’s experience was nothing short of spectacular. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly cooked, and the cheese was gooey and flavorful.

The toppings were also fresh and of high quality. The pepperonis were crisply fried, adding great texture to each bite. The sauce was zesty and full of flavor, without being too spicy or overwhelming.

What really set this pizza apart from the thousands of others I’ve had around the world is the atmosphere at Marco’s Pizza. The staff are friendly and helpful, making sure you have everything you need for your experience there to be an enjoyable one. On my visit, they even brought out some free games to keep us entertained while we ate! Everyone in our group had a great time bonding over board games and good conversation while indulging in amazing pizza!

In summary, I can confidently say that Marco’s has the best pizza in Perdido Key! Not only do they serve up delicious slices with great toppings, they provide a wonderful atmosphere and excellent service too. If you’re ever in Perdido Key looking for some excellent pizza, look no further than Marco’s Pizza!

#4 Paul’s Pizza Company

As a food critic, I’ve had my share of pizza experiences – from wood-fired ovens in Italy to classic New York slices. But Paul’s Pizza Company surpassed all my expectations!

The moment I stepped through the doors, I was overwhelmed with the smell of freshly baked dough and delicious sauce. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, which featured an impressive selection of classic and unique pizzas.

I was so excited to try it out that I ordered both a Margherita pizza as well as one of their signature “Paul’s Special” creations – topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, and bacon.

The experience was absolutely phenomenal! The crust was crunchy yet fluffy on the inside and incredibly flavorful. The toppings were fresh, tender, and perfectly cooked. Add in a nice cold beer or your favorite soda and you have yourself an amazing meal!

I’m still trying to figure out how Paul’s Pizza Company manages to make such delicious pizzas every single time. All I know is that they belong at the top of any best-of list for pizza in Perdido Key. If you’re ever passing through town or just looking for an incredible pizza experience, be sure to give Paul’s Pizza Company a try – you won’t regret it!

#5 Rotolo’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Rotolo’s is electric, the vibe is lively and the staff are friendly and attentive. The menu offers something for everyone, but the specialty pizzas are the stars of the show! The freshest ingredients, a signature sauce and homemade dough- it’s no wonder they’re so popular!

My personal favorite was their signature pepperoni pizza. It was cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside yet still soft and fluffy on the inside. The sauce was tangy with a hint of sweetness, while the pepperoni provided an irresistible crunch. I’m convinced that this is one of, if not THE best pizza in Perdido Key!

I’d highly recommend Rotolo’s Pizzeria to anyone looking for a delicious slice of pizza in Perdido Key. In fact, I’ll most likely be back next time I’m in town – just writing this review has my mouth watering!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Pensacola!

#6 Graffiti Pizza

I was really impressed with the atmosphere at Graffiti Pizza; it was a great place to watch sports, and the fact that they served drinks, including hard liquor, definitely added to the experience. It’s also located in a good tourist spot, so I got to take in some of the local sights while enjoying my meal.

The food was amazing! They had a great selection of pizzas both with and without meat, plus vegetarian options too – all of which were incredibly fresh and flavorful. The crust was just right – crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.

The only downside is that Graffiti Pizza doesn’t offer delivery – but if you don’t mind eating in or taking your pizza to go, Graffiti Pizza is definitely worth checking out. You won’t be disappointed!

#7 Lillian’s Pan Pizza

When I arrived, I was immediately impressed with how cozy and inviting the atmosphere was. The servers were friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, quickly explaining what Lillian’s had to offer.

On my first visit, I opted to sample their signature pan-style pizza. The thin crust was light and airy, while the cheese melted perfectly across the top. The sauce was slightly sweet with a nice Italian flavor that wasn’t overpowering. With each bite came a delightful crunch that made my tastebuds jump for joy!

Aside from having absolutely fantastic pizza, Lillian’s also offers an impressive selection of unique toppings. From traditional pepperoni to pineapple, you can find just about anything you’d expect in any quality pizzeria – plus some unconventional options like roasted garlic or rosemary mushrooms!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Perdido Key then look no further than Lillian’s Pan Pizza!

#8 Pizzaluté

The atmosphere was great – it’s a great tourist spot and a great place to watch sports, plus they serve alcohol which is always nice. And the food! Wow, delicious! They had quite a few vegetarian options as well and even offered dessert. So, it’s definitely a great place to grab dinner with friends and family.

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery. But you know what? It almost makes the experience better because you get to go in person and pick out what toppings you want (or create your own!). Not to mention, the wait staff there are wonderful and friendly, so you’re treated like family.

Overall, Pizzaluté has some of the best pizza in Perdido Key and I highly recommend it!

#9 Surfside PIzza Orange Beach

I’ve had some amazing slices in my lifetime, but Surfside takes the cake. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was met with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was friendly and attentive to my every need, making sure my experience was pleasant throughout.

When it came time to order, I couldn’t decide between all the delicious options on their menu. Everything sounded so good! But I knew that if I wanted to get the full experience, I had to try out their specialty – their signature Surfside Pizza! It was amazing! The crust is thin and crunchy with a generous layer of melted cheese on top. You can really taste the difference when you bite into each slice – absolute perfection!

As for the toppings, they have something for everyone. Every topping from pepperoni to pineapple was fresh and flavorful. If you’re looking for something extra special, make sure you try their Chef’s Special – a unique blend of flavors that will tantalize your tastebuds.

All in all, Surfside PIzza Orange Beach offers an incredible pizza experience like no other! Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or a full meal, Surfside PIzza Orange Beach has got you covered with some of the best pizza in Perdido Key – guaranteed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Orange Beach!

#10 Rotolo’s Pizzeria

I visited Rotolo’s and was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere. There was a lively crowd of locals, tourists, and foodies alike, all eager to dig into some delicious pizza. The staff were friendly and helpful in guiding me through the menu – not that I needed it, but hey, every little bit helps!

The pizza itself was out of this world. I tried a specialty called ‘The Beachcomber’ – it had pepperoni, mushrooms, bell peppers and italian sausage on top of a perfectly cooked dough with ooey-gooey cheese. It was flavorful without being overly greasy or cheesy – just the right combination! My taste buds were dancing with delight!

The portion size was generous as well so everyone in my party could enjoy their share. The prices were quite reasonable too considering the quality of the ingredients used to make these pizzas. All in all, Rotolo’s Pizzeria is definitely one of the best places to get pizza in Perdido Key!

#11 Perdido Beach Pizza Company

The pizza itself was delicious and really hit the spot. The ingredients were fresh, like they had been prepared just minutes before I arrived.

What really sets Perdido Beach Pizza Company apart from other pizzerias is the fact that they have a kid’s menu that my little ones enjoyed. It was great not to have to worry about them being too picky when it came to finding food!

Not only did we get a tasty meal but we also finished off our night with some delicious desserts, which totally made the experience even better.

The only downside to this restaurant is that they don’t offer delivery services, which would be a great addition if they ever make it happen in the future.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Perdido Key then look no further than Perdido Beach Pizza Company! Highly recommend!