Recently, I had the chance to bite into 11 different pizzas from some of the top pizza places in this local area. And with my taste buds so well traveled, I’m here to report on which Watertown joint reigns supreme when it comes to pizza.
In this article, you won’t just get a list of 11 pizza joints – you’ll get an inside scoop on what each place has to offer, along with a few fun facts and stories that make these restaurants unique. So sit back and get ready for a lighthearted adventure into tasty pizza!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Massachusetts
#1 Gigi’s Pizza Co.
The moment I stepped inside this cozy family spot I was warmly welcomed and quickly ushered to my seat. The decor is a great combination of classic Italian style with modern touches – perfect for a family night out.
I had the “Grandma Gigi’s Special” which included pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, olives and a delicious homemade sauce. The sauce had the perfect balance of sweet and savory – and the crust was thin but crispy with just the right amount of chewiness. To top it all off, the cheese was flavourful and melted in your mouth. In short, it was pizza perfection!
What makes this place so special is how friendly and accommodating the staff is – they genuinely seemed to care about my experience at Gigi’s Pizza Co. That personal touch really made this pizza meal something special.
If you’re in Watertown MA and looking for some seriously delicious pizza, then look no further than Gigi’s Pizza Co.!
If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Waltham!
I’ve had the pleasure of trying their classic cheese pizza and it’s truly something special. Every bite is oozing with flavor and the toppings are always perfectly balanced. They have a vast selection of pizzas to choose from, so there’s something for everyone.
The atmosphere is also great – the servers are friendly and attentive, the decor is modern yet cozy, and they even have TVs on the walls playing sports games! What more could a pizza fan want?
All in all, Pizza-Roma is an exceptional establishment offering some of the best pizza around, especially in Watertown MA. I highly recommend it if you’re looking for an authentic Italian-style pizza experience!
#3 Newton Corner House of Pizza
From the minute I stepped foot inside, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The dining room is simple yet comfortable, making it ideal for a low-key pizza night out.
When it comes to the pizza itself, their options are simply outstanding. The crusts are cooked to perfection and offer the perfect balance of crisp and chewiness. The toppings are imaginative and plentiful, ranging from succulent pepperoni to unique veggie creations. Each bite is better than the last!
The service is also noteworthy, as the staff members were incredibly friendly and helpful when putting together our order. They made sure to take note of all my dietary needs which was greatly appreciated!
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Watertown MA, then look no further than Newton Corner House of Pizza!
#4 Emilio’s Homemade Italian Subs
- No delivery
I’ve seen many good pizzas, but Emilio’s really stands out from the crowd. The dough is perfectly cooked and it has a soft texture; the sauce has just the right amount of tang, and their toppings are always fresh and flavorful.
The restaurant itself has a cozy atmosphere that I truly enjoy. It almost feels like I’m in Italy when I enter their doors!
Unfortunately, there’s one downside to Emilio’s Homemade Italian Subs: they don’t offer delivery service. That means if you live outside Watertown MA, you’ll need to take a drive to get your pizza fix. Not cool!
But if you’re willing to make that drive, then Emilio’s is definitely worth it – they have some of the best pizza in Watertown MA.
#5 Max and Leo’s Pizza Newton
- Great place to watch sports
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
The pizza is simply divine. From the freshly made dough to the perfectly cooked toppings, this place has it all. The crust is crispy and golden brown, yet still light and fluffy inside. Then there’s the variety of toppings – from classic pepperoni to more exotic selections like artichoke hearts and roasted garlic. And don’t forget about their signature sauces! They are out of this world!
The atmosphere at Max and Leo’s is great too, with its cozy décor and warm lighting. And the staff – they truly make you feel like family! Everyone is so friendly and accommodating they can make you feel like home no matter where you’re from.
I highly recommend Max and Leo’s Pizza Newton if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Watertown MA. Delicious food, a comfortable atmosphere, and great service – what more could you ask for?
#6 Arsenal Pizza
The pizza crust was perfection, with the perfect amount of char and chewiness. The sauce had just enough sweetness and a hint of oregano that made me want to lick my plate. The mozzarella and other toppings were top notch, so much so that it’s hard to single out any particular ingredient!
What really blew me away was the presentation. Wow! Instead of the generic round pizza slices you find everywhere, Arsenal Pizza makes pizzas in a variety of shapes – from footballs to stars – which is an amazing touch.
The atmosphere at this place was fantastic too. It has a cozy feel with a great selection of craft beers and locally sourced ingredients. Plus, the service was friendly and attentive as well!
I’m glad I made the trip to Watertown MA, because it allowed me to experience one of the best pizzas I’ve had in my travels – Arsenal Pizza! If you’re looking for some seriously delicious pizza, this is where you need to go.
#7 D & A House of Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
I’ll start off with my favorite – the crust. It has this amazing combination of crispiness and a hint of chewiness that is simply unbeatable! The sauce is carefully crafted, made in-house with the freshest ingredients. And the cheese – oh, the cheese! It’s perfectly balanced, not too greasy and stringy like some other pizzas I’ve had elsewhere.
The toppings are always fresh and they give you plenty of options. Whether you’re in the mood for pepperoni or Mediterranean veggies, this place has it all! I highly recommend trying their speciality pizza, it is honestly one of the best pizzas I have ever tried.
All in all, D & A House of Pizza is a no-brainer if you’re looking for great pizza in Watertown MA! They have delicious food at an affordable price, plus entertaining staff to make your experience even better. So go ahead and treat yourself to some of the best pizza around – you won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 50 more pizza places in Boston!
#8 C & N Pizza and Grille
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
My first bite of their signature slice was literally out of this world. The thin, but not too thin crust was perfectly crisp and had the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. The toppings were fresh and flavorful and added just the right balance of flavor. It was delightfully cheesy, with a hint of spice that made it all the more delicious.
But C & N is so much more than just pizza! They offer a wide variety of menu items that are sure to please everyone in your party. From salads to sandwiches to calzones and more, you can find something for everyone here! The prices are very reasonable for what you get, making this one of my go-to spots in Watertown MA!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Watertown MA, look no further than C & N Pizza and Grille. Their combination of amazing ingredients and great atmosphere make them a must try for all pizza lovers!
#9 Stella’s Pizza
The experience at Stella’s Pizza was simply unbelievable. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting and the pizza was divine. I had a delicious margherita pizza with fresh mozzarella and basil that melted in my mouth. The sauce was seasoned to perfection and the crust was crispy and chewy, just like a perfect pie should be!
I also had the opportunity to try some of their other specialty pies such as the Funghi Pizza, which is loaded with mushrooms, garlic, parmesan and olive oil. It was a flavor explosion!
The service at Stella’s Pizza was also top notch. Not only did they greet me warmly but they also gave me helpful suggestions about which pizzas to try. Plus, it never felt like I was rushed even though it seemed like all the tables were busy – definitely a plus in my book!
Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Watertown MA then look no further than Stella’s Pizza. With its exceptional atmosphere, divine pies and friendly staff – you won’t be disappointed!
#10 Belmont Pizza
As soon as I stepped in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff didn’t just treat me like any other customer, they made me feel like part of their family. They even offered to give me a custom tour of their pizzeria and showed me where all the fresh ingredients were sourced from!
The real star at Belmont Pizza is undoubtedly their pizza. I had the pleasure of trying out their classic margherita pie, which tasted like it was straight outta Naples! It had the perfect amount of sweetness and tang, making it an absolute joy to eat. The crust was super thin, yet still managed to be crunchy and full of flavor, while the sauce was spot on with a hint of spice that really brought out the flavors in the pies.
Overall, this place is one of my top picks for best pizza in Watertown MA. All-in-all, it’s a great spot for anyone who enjoys authentic Italian pizza crafted by diehard pizza artisans!
#11 Michael’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The crust is miraculously light and crunchy – something that’s hard to come by. The cheese is melted to absolute perfection and the sauce has just the right amount of zing. You can tell they use only the freshest ingredients, too!
I would have to say that the highlight of my experience here was their pepperoni pizza. It was a work of art, really: with layers of spices and flavorings which revealed themselves as I munched through slice after delicious slice.
I also tried one of their specialty pizzas, which featured mushrooms, olives, onions, and peppers – all atop a garlic butter base. The combination was truly remarkable; it was almost like I’d left Italy and gone straight to Michael’s Pizza!
If you’re in Watertown MA looking for some top-notch ‘za then Michael’s Pizza is definitely a must-visit spot! The friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere make it an ideal location for a night out or simply grabbing a quick bite to eat. So next time you’re in town, don’t miss out on this incredible pizza – you won’t regret it!