Best Pizza in Webster NY (Updated Jan 2023)

I’ve sampled more than a few pies all over the world, but this small Upstate New York town has its own flavor. After taking some time to taste test 11 different spots around Webster, I now have the definitive list of the best pizza places in town.

Be prepared to laugh and maybe even cringe along with me as I uncover all that Webster NY has to offer when it comes to pizza!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Carl's Pizza Kitchen

#1 Carl’s Pizza Kitchen

Open Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 11AM-9PM
Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-10PM
Saturday: 11AM-10PM
Sunday: 11AM-9PM

Benefits
  • Has a kid’s menu
  • Offers dessert


The first time I stepped in here, I was blown away by the authentic Italian atmosphere. The décor was perfect for a cozy dinner date or an evening out with friends. Plus, the friendly staff was always eager to help me decide which delicious pie to try.

Speaking of pies, their selection is simply incredible! Everything from classic New York-style pizza to more gourmet options like white pizza and four-cheese pies – something truly for everyone!

Their traditional pizzas deserve a special mention – they use only the freshest ingredients and cook them to perfection in their brick ovens. Every bite is pure bliss!

Plus, Carl’s Pizza Kitchen also offers vegan and gluten-free options so even if you have dietary restrictions you can still enjoy some good ol’ comfort food.

To top it all off, Carl’s Pizza Kitchen has reasonable prices so you won’t break the bank when treating yourself or your family!

I’ve been around the world trying different pizzas but none compare to what’s on offer here at Carl’s Pizza Kitchen – it truly is the best pizza in Webster NY and I would highly recommend it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Rochester!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Fire Crust

#2 Fire Crust

Open Hours
Monday: 11:30AM-8:30PM
Tuesday: 11:30AM-8:30PM
Wednesday: 11:30AM-8:30PM
Thursday: 11:30AM-8:30PM
Friday: 11:30AM-9PM
Saturday: 11:30AM-9PM
Sunday: 11:30AM-8:30PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert
  • Has some vegetarian options


Let me tell you, there is not a pizza out there that can compare. The pizza crust is thin and crispy, made with fresh ingredients like mozzarella and tomato sauce. The toppings are creative and full of flavor – they offer everything from classic pepperoni to more unexpected options like jalapeños or artichoke hearts.

The atmosphere at Fire Crust is lively and fun – the staff always makes sure our experience is top-notch by ensuring we have the freshest pizza with every order. Plus, their drinks selection is fantastic; they carry an array of both domestic and imported beers.

I highly recommend trying out Fire Crust for some of the best pizza in Webster NY! Their unique recipes make for a delicious meal that no other restaurant can match.

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Rhino's Pizzeria

#3 Rhino’s Pizzeria

Open Hours
Monday: 10:30AM-9PM
Tuesday: 10:30AM-9PM
Wednesday: 10:30AM-9PM
Thursday: 10:30AM-9PM
Friday: 10:30AM-10PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Sunday: 12-8:30PM

As soon as I walked in, the aroma of delicious homemade pizza filled my nose. The decor was simple; tables and chairs neatly arranged around a large glass case displaying exquisite pizzas that make your mouth water!

I ordered a Sicilian style supreme pizza loaded with gooey cheese, flavorful meats, and fresh vegetables. When it arrived at my table, I knew I had made the right choice. The crust was perfectly cooked; not too chewy nor soft. The toppings melted in my mouth, making every bite better than the last.

The portions are generous; enough to make you feel full but still leave room for dessert! The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, offering helpful suggestions and adding extra touches to make our meal special.

My stomach is still growling as I type this review. Rhino’s Pizzeria offers up some of the best pizza in Webster NY – you won’t be disappointed!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - jojo Bistro & Wine Bar - Webster

#4 jojo Bistro & Wine Bar – Webster

Open Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 4-9PM
Wednesday: 4-9PM
Thursday: 4-9PM
Friday: 4-10PM
Saturday: 4-10PM
Sunday: Closed

Benefits
  • Has some vegetarian options
  • Has insanely good dessert
  • Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)

Downsides
  • No delivery


The atmosphere here is great – the perfect place to grab a slice or two with friends, enjoy some libations (yes, even hard liquor!), and chat about life. Plus, they have a few vegetarian options if you need them.

Now, let’s talk about the food. First of all, they have an incredible selection of gourmet pizzas to choose from! There’s something for everyone here – classic cheese, veggie supreme, and plenty more in between. The pies are cooked to perfection and the flavor is simply out of this world!

And don’t forget dessert. One word: amazing! They have every kind of sweet treat you could want – tiramisu, cheesecake slices, cannolis… and it’s all insanely delicious. I mean seriously- this stuff deserves its own award!

Unfortunately there is one downside here at jojo Bistro & Wine Bar: no delivery service. So if you’re looking for your pizza fix delivered to your door, you’ll have to settle for another spot unfortunately. But if you can make it out for a nice evening at jojo Bistro & Wine Bar – Webster- definitely do it! You won’t regret it!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta

#5 Marvin Mozzeroni’s Pizza & Pasta

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-9PM
Tuesday: 11AM-9PM
Wednesday: 11AM-9PM
Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-11PM
Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Sunday: 11AM-9PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert


The crust and cheese were just perfect – not too thick, not too thin. The sauce was also unique – sweet with a subtle kick of spice. They definitely know how to whip up a classic marinara!

The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the proportions were spot on. From pepperoni to mushrooms, each topping was added in perfect harmony. Not only that, but their selection of ingredients is out of this world! Even the most discerning pizza connoisseur would be impressed.

All in all, Marvin Mozzeroni’s Pizza & Pasta has been my favorite pizza experience by far! And I’ve tasted pizzas from around the world, so I’m pretty confident when I say they have some of the best pizza in Webster NY! You won’t be disappointed if you stop by for a slice or two…or three!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Joe's Brooklyn Pizza Webster

#6 Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza Webster

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-8PM
Tuesday: 11AM-8PM
Wednesday: 11AM-8PM
Thursday: 11AM-8PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Sunday: 12-8PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert


The atmosphere was perfect for a pizza lover like me – dimly lit and classic. The staff was friendly and accommodating, ensuring we had whatever we needed.

When the pizza arrived, I could tell this was something special: authentic New York style with a crisp crust and flavorful sauce. The cheese was gooey and melted in my mouth, while the toppings were flavorful and abundant.

My overall experience at Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza Webster exceeded all expectations; I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Rochester!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

#7 Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-9PM
Tuesday: 11AM-9PM
Wednesday: 11AM-9PM
Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-10PM
Saturday: 11AM-10PM
Sunday: 12-9PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert
  • Great place to watch sports
  • Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
  • Has a kid’s menu


When I stepped into Salvatore’s, I knew I was in for something special. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with beautiful decor that transported me to an Italian pizzeria. But what really blew me away were the incredible pizzas they had!

The crust on their pizzas is just perfect: thin, crispy, and flavorful. I tried a few different varieties on my visit and each one was cooked to perfection. And the toppings! Wow, talk about fresh and flavorful. They truly know how to create a masterpiece of a pizza that will have you coming back for more!

If you are ever in Webster NY and looking for great pizza, Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out. Believe me when I say they have some of the best pizza around!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Mark's Pizzeria

#8 Mark’s Pizzeria

Open Hours
Monday: 10AM-9PM
Tuesday: 10AM-9PM
Wednesday: 10AM-9PM
Thursday: 10AM-9PM
Friday: 10AM-10PM
Saturday: 10AM-10PM
Sunday: 10AM-9PM

Benefits
  • Offers dessert


From their skilled dough-makers to the careful selection of toppings, Mark’s Pizzeria delivers a pizza experience that is sure to impress. Every bite is cooked to perfection, with a lightly crisp crust, just the right amount of sauce, and generous portion of cheese. The topping combinations are infinite – you could eat here every day for a week and still not try them all!

The atmosphere in the restaurant is also incredible. It’s quaint and cozy with friendly staff and fast service. What more could I ask for from an establishment?

Finally, as any good pizza connoisseur can attest, it’s not just about the slice – it’s all about how you enjoy it. At Mark’s Pizzeria they know this too: each visit comes with a complementary supply of napkins and table cloths so that you can get messy without getting scolded.

All in all, Mark’s Pizzeria makes some of the best pizza in Webster NY – if not the world!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Domino's Pizza

#9 Domino’s Pizza

Open Hours
Monday: 10:30AM-12AM
Tuesday: 10:30AM-12AM
Wednesday: 10:30AM-12AM
Thursday: 10:30AM-12AM
Friday: 10:30AM-1AM
Saturday: 10:30AM-1AM
Sunday: 10:30AM-12AM

I have to admit, I was a bit skeptical at first; Domino’s isn’t known for its pizzas exactly. But the delicious smell and friendly staff won me over quickly.

The pizza crust was cooked to perfection, crisp and golden brown on the outside just like it should be. The sauce was flavorful and fragrant with a hint of garlic. The toppings were generous; all the vegetables were fresh and vibrant, and the cheese was melted perfectly over everything. It was downright heavenly!

The end result? Deliciousness! I can confidently say that Domino’s Pizza is some of the best pizza in Webster NY that I’ve ever tried. If you’re looking for a quality pizza experience in this area, look no further than Domino’s!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Ferrari Pizza Bar

#10 Ferrari Pizza Bar

Open Hours
Monday: 11AM-10PM
Tuesday: 11AM-10PM
Wednesday: 11AM-10PM
Thursday: 11AM-10PM
Friday: 11AM-11PM
Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Sunday: 12-9PM

Benefits
  • Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
  • Has a kid’s menu
  • Has some vegetarian options
  • Great place to watch sports
  • Offers dessert


I had the pleasure of visiting this restaurant during my most recent pizza-sampling tour, and it certainly didn’t disappoint. From the moment I stepped in, I was immediately charmed by the friendly staff and inviting atmosphere.

The menu boasted a variety of vegetarian and meat options – all made with fresh ingredients. After trying a few slices, I can confidently say that Ferrari Pizza Bar takes their pizza seriously. The thin crust was crispy yet soft, and the toppings were cooked to perfection. It was truly one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had!

If you’re looking for an excellent slice of pie, look no further than Ferrari Pizza Bar! Whether you’re looking for a light lunch or an indulgent dinner, you won’t be disappointed. It’s definitely worth every penny!

#1 best pizza place in Webster - Wegmans Meals 2GO

#11 Wegmans Meals 2GO

Open Hours
Monday: 10AM-8PM
Tuesday: 10AM-8PM
Wednesday: 10AM-8PM
Thursday: 10AM-8PM
Friday: 10AM-8PM
Saturday: 10AM-8PM
Sunday: 10AM-8PM

My first impression of the restaurant was that it had a great atmosphere. The place is bright, clean, and welcoming. From the moment I walked in, I could tell this place takes its pizza seriously.

The pizza selection at Wegmans Meals 2GO is unlike anything I’ve ever seen! Their menu features an incredible variety of toppings to choose from; whatever you’re craving, chances are that Wegmans has something for you! Plus, all their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, so you can enjoy the best tasting slices out there.

When I tried it for myself, I was amazed by the flavor combinations. Every bite was like a little party happening in my mouth! The crusts were crispy and the cheese melted perfectly. Not to mention they offer vegan and gluten-free options as well.

Overall, I highly recommend Wegmans Meals 2GO if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Webster NY! With their delicious recipes and generous portions, this is one pizza joint worth visiting again and again!

If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Canandaigua!

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Solve : *
2 + 21 =


Pizza Oven Radar